The First Remotely Detected Biosignature May Not Be the Most Common: Implications for JWST and HWO Journal: ApJ
Ravi Kopparapu · 2026
Read The First Remotely Detected Biosignature May Not Be the Most Common: Implications for JWST and HWO Journal: ApJ by Ravi Kopparapu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-16674.txt.
Introduction
Kopparapu warns that the first remotely detected biosignature may come from a rare but easy-to-see planet class, not the most common inhabited world. For JWST transmission spectroscopy, an early find likely favors an atmosphere-rich sub-Neptune around a nearby M dwarf over a true Earth analog. For the Habitable Worlds Observatory, volume bias weakens, but photochemistry and contrast still favor strong-feature planets. A first detection, he argues, should not be taken as typical of inhabited rocky planets.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ravi Kopparapu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47882 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.16674
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The First Remotely Detected Biosignature May Not Be the Most Common: Implications for JWST and HWO Journal: ApJ Ravi Kopparapu Abstract The first detected member of a new astronomical class is often not representative of the underlying population, but instead reflects the selection effects of the observing technique that found it. We apply this idea to the first remote detection of biosignatures with two leading near future strategies: JWST transmission spectroscopy and HWO reflected light direct imaging. Using the known signal scalings of the two methods together with a simple detectability model, we show how a rare but observationally favored planet class can dominate early detections even when it is intrinsically uncommon. For JWST, an early biosignature detection is most likely to arise from a detectability favored outlier, such as a sub-Neptune or other atmosphere rich planet around a nearby M dwarf, rather than from a true Earth analog. For HWO, the situation is subtler. Among accessible habitable-zone targets around FGK-type stars, differences in maximum observable distance and hence in effective survey volume may be smaller than in the JWST case, weakening the volume bias. At the same time, stellar-type-dependent photochemistry can alter biosignature abundances, so the first HWO biosignature may emerge from a balance between photochemical enhancement and geometric accessibility. Nevertheless, within the accessible sample, planets with stronger biosignature features and higher reflected light contrast may still be favored in early detections. A first HWO biosignature could be a selection favored outlier and should not be assumed to represent inhabited rocky planets in general. Crucially, the longest lived biosphere on a planet is not necessarily its most spectrally detectable one. If the first detection turns out to be an outlier, that may still suggest that a more broader range of habitable environments awaits discovery. I Introduction New observational capabilities often uncover not a representative sample of the universe from their first detection, but its most detectable extremes. This follows from sensitivity limited surveys: when objects span a range of signal strengths, the brightest, strongest, or otherwise most observable members are found first, while the more common but weaker members remain hidden. This selection effect was formalized long ago as Malmquist bias ( 17 ) . Some examples from the history of first detections in astronomy illustrate this pattern repeatedly: • Scorpius X-1 (Sco-X-1) was the first X-ray source discovered outside the solar system ( 6 ) , and is the brightest non-solar X-ray source in sky. • 3C 273 is the first quasar to be discovered ( 25 ; 22 ) , and is the brightest optical quasar seen from the Earth. • The first radio source outside the solar system was detected ( 8 ) from the center of the Milky Way, even though currently it is not the brightest object in the sky. At low frequencies that Jansky used, Cygnus A is the brightest source. However, Jansky’s instrument had a lower resolution and wider beam-width making more diffused emissions from large scale structures like Milkyway to be easily detectable rather than point sources like Cygnus A. • The first fast radio burst (FRB) (“Lorimer Burst”, 15 ) is an extreme outlier among the early sources detected by the Parkes radio observatory. It was found in the archival data with a burst duration of <5 ms, and was remarkably bright for its time of discovery. • Ceres is the first asteroid/dwarf-planet discovered by Giuseppe Piazzi in 1801, and is the largest asteroid. • The first confirmed exoplanet orbited a millisecond pulsar ( 36 ) . Neither pulsars, nor the pulsar planets are the most common type of objects in their category. However, the combination of pulsar planets produce the brightest (“loudest”) signal with the corresponding sensitive instrument (a radio telescope that can detect deviations in timed pulsed emissions). • The first hot Jupiter ( 19 ) , 51 Pegasi b, was a gas giant on a 4 day orbit, a geometric extreme that maximized radial velocity amplitude. Hot Jupiters represent \sim\!0.5-1\% of planetary systems ( 37 ; 5 ) , yet they dominated early exoplanet catalogs. In fact, the existence of hot-jupiters were actually predicted by 30 , mentioning that “It is not unreasonable that a planet might exist at a distance of 1/50 astronomical unit…period around a star of solar mass would then be about 1 day”. 1 1 1 The same logic may even apply to stars themselves. The first stellar object available to detailed observation was the Sun, the brightest and most accessible star from Earth, even though it is not representative of the broader stellar population. In each case, the first detected member of a new class was the loudest one accessible to the instrument at hand, rather than the most common or representative member of the underlying population. We propose that the first remote biosignature detection on an exoplanet will arise from the same observational selection effect. This paper addresses a focused and tractable question: Given the two primary near future biosignature search strategies, JWST transmission spectroscopy and HWO reflected light spectroscopy, what biosignature scenario is most detectable for each technique, and how unrepresentative is it likely to be of the broader population of inhabited worlds? The answer can be approached from known physics, instrument capabilities, and atmospheric chemistry alone, without requiring prior knowledge of how common life is. Here, the argument concerns the first biosignature signal strong enough to support a serious or widely accepted biological interpretation, not merely the first unusual atmospheric feature. 10 recently applied a related “loudest first” argument to technosignatures. Here we consider the corresponding problem for remote biosignatures , which involves a different observational domain and a different physical basis for detectability. We develop an instrument specific framework in which detectability is decomposed into the underlying geometric, atmospheric, and spectroscopic terms relevant to each observing strategy. In particular, we treat transmission spectroscopy and direct imaging separately, since they are governed by fundamentally different selection effects and therefore different notions of observational loudness. We further examine what a first HWO detection would imply, regardless of which Earth-like atmospheric state is ultimately observed. II Detection Methods and Signal Scalings In this section we summarize the signal-to-noise scalings for the two observing strategies considered in this paper: transmission spectroscopy with JWST-like facilities and reflected-light direct imaging with HWO-like facilities. These relations are not new; they are included here only to establish the different observational selection functions of the two techniques before turning, in the next section, to the question of which atmospheres are most likely to be detected first. II.1 Transmission spectroscopy For transmission spectroscopy, the wavelength-dependent excess transit depth of an atmospheric spectral feature can be approximated as \Delta\delta_{\lambda}\;\approx\;\frac{2R_{p}z_{\lambda}}{R_{\star}^{2}}, (1) where R_{p} is the solid body planet radius, R_{\star} is the stellar radius, and z_{\lambda} is the effective atmospheric height at wavelength \lambda . To leading order, the atmospheric scale height is H\;=\;\frac{k_{B}T}{\mu g}, (2) with T the atmospheric temperature, \mu the mean molecular mass, and g the surface gravity. For a strong spectral band, z_{\lambda} is typically of order a few scale heights, z_{\lambda}\sim N_{H}H, (3) where N_{H} is an order-unity factor that depends on the opacity structure, abundance of the absorber, and cloud or haze opacity. If