Searching for the Third Wheel: High-Contrast Imaging Constraints on Tertiaries to Black Hole and Neutron Star Binaries Facilities: Keck:II (NIRC2-LGS) astropy ( 4 ; 2 ; 3 ) , pyKLIP ( 92 ) , VIP ( 39 ; 19 )
Pranav Nagarajan, Kareem El-Badry, Aniket Sanghi · 2026
Read Searching for the Third Wheel: High-Contrast Imaging Constraints on Tertiaries to Black Hole and Neutron Star Binaries Facilities: Keck:II (NIRC2-LGS) astropy ( 4 ; 2 ; 3 ) , pyKLIP ( 92 ) , VIP ( 39 ; 19 ) by Pranav Nagarajan, Kareem El-Badry, Aniket Sanghi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-16498.txt.
Introduction
Nagarajan, El-Badry, and Sanghi search for tertiaries to compact binaries with near-infrared imaging of five binaries, Gaia BH1, and twelve Gaia stars. They detect several faint stars unseen in survey imaging, but none rule out matches. Reference star differential imaging models each target's point-spread function. Tertiary candidates appear, but injection-recovery tests suggest most are likely artifacts. Contrast curves limit main sequence and white dwarf temperature. They rule out main sequence and young white dwarf tertiaries above 500 au for Gaia binaries and 2000 au for distant LMXBs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pranav Nagarajan, Kareem El-Badry, Aniket Sanghi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 52099 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.16498
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Searching for the Third Wheel: High-Contrast Imaging Constraints on Tertiaries to Black Hole and Neutron Star Binaries Facilities: Keck:II (NIRC2-LGS) astropy ( 4 ; 2 ; 3 ) , pyKLIP ( 92 ) , VIP ( 39 ; 19 ) Pranav Nagarajan, Kareem El-Badry, Aniket Sanghi Abstract Hierarchical triple evolution provides a promising alternative to isolated binary formation models for black holes (BHs) and neutron stars (NSs) with low-mass stellar companions. To search for tertiaries, we perform deep, adaptive optics-assisted, near-infrared imaging of five quiescent BH low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs), Gaia BH1, and twelve Gaia NSs. We detect several faint stars previously unresolved in survey imaging, but none are close enough to robustly rule out a chance alignment. To achieve high contrast sensitivity at close separations, we use the reference star differential imaging strategy with the Karhunen-Loéve Image Processing algorithm to model and subtract the point-spread function of each target. We identify tertiary candidates in the speckle-dominated regime, but injection-recovery tests suggest most 5 σ \sigma detections are likely artifacts. We derive 5 σ 5\sigma contrast curves and convert these to limits on the mass of main sequence (MS) tertiaries and the effective temperature of white dwarf (WD) tertiaries consistent with a non-detection. We rule out plausible MS tertiaries and young, hot WD tertiaries at projected separations ≳ 500 \gtrsim 500 au for the Gaia compact object binaries and ≳ 2000 \gtrsim 2000 au for the more distant BH LMXBs. While the recent discovery of a 1.2 M ⊙ 1.2\,M_{\odot} tertiary to V404 Cygni supports triple formation scenarios for BH LMXBs, our results suggest such companions are relatively rare. Our observations remain consistent with intermediate-mass tertiaries that have since evolved into cool WDs, detectable with deeper JWST imaging. Follow-up observations are required to measure proper motions and confirm or rule out physical association of tertiary candidates. show][email protected] I Introduction A significant fraction of black hole (BH) and neutron star (NS) progenitors are born in triples and higher order multiples ( 63 ; 69 ) , suggesting that BHs and NSs may still reside in hierarchical triples today. Indeed, triple evolution can solve some of the challenges facing isolated binary evolution formation models for BHs and NSs orbited by low-mass stars, both for close, accreting systems and their wide, detached counterparts ( 67 ; 36 ; 83 ; 68 , e.g.,) . The close, accreting systems are low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs), which host BHs or NSs accreting from \lesssim 3\,M_{\odot} stellar companions ( 77 , e.g.,) , with 21 Galactic BH LMXBs dynamically confirmed to date ( 20 , e.g.,) . While the majority of all known BHs and NSs with luminous companions are in LMXBs ( 7 , e.g.,) , theoretical models predict that these systems are likely a rare outcome of binary evolution ( 74 , e.g.,) , and empirical arguments suggest that they are significantly outnumbered by wide binaries hosting non-accreting, “dormant” BHs and NSs ( 28 , e.g.,) . The Gaia mission ( 32 ; 33 ) has recently uncovered this hidden population, with Gaia astrometry already enabling the discovery and characterization of three dormant BHs (“Gaia BHs”) ( 26 ; 16 ; 65 ; 23 ; 89 ; 31 ) and a population of dormant NSs (“Gaia NSs”) ( 27 ; 24 ) in au-scale orbits. Isolated binary evolution models struggle to explain both BH LMXBs and Gaia compact object binaries. Mass transfer between a massive BH or NS progenitor and a low-mass star is expected to be unstable ( 44 ; 34 , e.g.,) . Binary evolution predicts that the orbital energy of a low-mass star is usually insufficient to unbind the envelope of a BH or NS progenitor ( 74 ; 71 , e.g.,) , so such systems should merge before the formation of the compact object. While it is possible that some binaries with a highly unequal mass ratio can survive common envelope evolution (CEE), the orbits of surviving post-CEE binaries are predicted to be tight ( P_{\text{orb}}\lesssim 1 d) ( 94 ; 71 ; 44 , e.g.,) . Such an evolutionary scenario may apply to BH LMXBs, but it cannot explain the formation of Gaia BHs and NSs, which have orbital periods of years. To make matters worse, natal kicks arising from a supernova can unbind many BH or NS binaries altogether ( 12 ; 49 , e.g.,) . Several ideas have been proposed in the literature to form BH LMXBs, including evolution of an intermediate-mass star into the present-day low-mass companion ( 72 ; 47 , e.g.,) , introduction of additional sources of energy during the common-envelope phase ( 73 ; 45 , e.g.,) , or dynamical exchanges in a globular cluster followed by binary hardening and eventual mass transfer ( 42 ; 50 , e.g.,) . Various theoretical explanations have also been suggested for the formation of Gaia BHs and NSs, such as modifications to stellar evolution that prevent the BH or NS progenitor from expanding to red supergiant dimensions ( 51 ; 37 ; 54 ; 43 , e.g.,) , or dynamical interactions in open or globular clusters that produce wide orbits and moderate eccentricities ( 76 ; 88 ; 22 ; 59 ; 29 , e.g.,) . A promising class of models for forming BH LMXBs and Gaia compact object binaries rely on hierarchical triple evolution ( 67 , e.g.,) . For example, a BH and low-mass star could have originated in a wide ( \sim 100 au) orbit with a distant ( \gtrsim 1000 au) tertiary. After formation of the BH, eccentric Kozai-Lidov oscillations could tighten the inner binary, producing a BH LMXB ( 67 ; 83 , e.g.,) . Another idea is that Kozai-Lidov oscillations induced by an outer tertiary star could delay the onset of common-envelope evolution ( 36 ) . This could lead to wider initial and final orbital separations, characteristic of Gaia BHs or NSs ( 36 ) . In such scenarios, compact object binaries could retain faint low-mass star or white dwarf tertiaries at separations of \sim 100 – 1000 au, especially if these systems experience weak natal kicks. In support of this hypothesis, 13 recently discovered that V404 Cyg, one of the best-studied BH LMXBs ( 15 , e.g.,) , is in a hierarchical triple. V404 Cyg contains a \sim 9\,M_{\odot} BH ( 48 ) in a 6.4-day orbit with a \approx 0.7\,M_{\odot} star ( 81 ) . Gaia astrometry and follow-up spectroscopy revealed that an evolved 1.2\,M_{\odot} star 1.4 arcsec away — long assumed to be a chance alignment — is in fact a gravitationally bound tertiary, with a separation of \approx 3500 au ( 13 ) . Because the tertiary is weakly bound, with an orbital velocity of only \sim 1\,\rm km\,s^{-1} , the BH must have formed with a negligible kick of <5 km s -1 ( 13 ; 83 ) . This discovery corroborates the growing picture that some BHs in binaries were born with a strong kick, while others received virtually no kick at all ( 30 ; 6 ; 99 ; 90 ; 14 ; 66 , e.g.,) . As 13 point out, V404 Cyg is nearer and brighter in the optical than