Combinatorial Approach to the Second Law

Rafael Díaz · 2026

Read Combinatorial Approach to the Second Law by Rafael Díaz (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-16434.txt.

Introduction

Diaz studies the second law in the context of combinatorial processes, looking at the ways that give rise to irreversible behavior from deterministic, invertible, and reversible dynamics. The paper asks how one-way trends arise from dynamics that are deterministic, invertible, and reversible. Its focus is the mechanism linking those reversible rules to one-way results. The question is how a one-way trend can come from rules that run the same in both directions, and the paper treats that puzzle through combinatorial processes.

Catalog record

CREATORRafael Díaz
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE86299
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.16434

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Combinatorial Approach to the Second Law Rafael Díaz Abstract We study the second law in the context of combinatorial processes, focusing on the mechanisms that give rise to irreversible behavior from an underlying deterministic, invertible, and reversible dynamics. 1 Introduction A key feature of the second law is that it inherently operates on two scales—a microscale and a macroscale. Intuitively, the microscale corresponds to a complete description of the system’s state (i.e., points in phase space), while the macroscale is the scale accessible to the observer, both operationally and informationally. This duality finds its geometric expression in the introduction of a distinct space, beyond phase space, known as state space, whose points label the equilibrium states of a system. As discussed below, the second law characterizes possible transitions between equilibria in terms of entropy changes, while presupposing the underlying process of equilibration [ 3 ] . Boltzmann, most famously via his H -theorem [ 9 , 10 ] , introduced an extension of the second law that applies to the equilibration process itself, i.e. to transitions between non-equilibrium states 1 1 1 In a different usage, the term ’non-equilibrium states’ often refers to non-equilibrium steady states [ 6 ] . in isolated systems (i.e. not interacting with the outside.) This was made possible by introducing a macrostate space whose points label both equilibrium and non-equilibrium states available at macroscale, and by extending the notion of entropy as counting microstates compatible with a given macrostate. Our aim in this work is to study entropy and the out of equilibrium second law, following the Boltzmann approach, within a combinatorial setting [ 8 ] . We specifically focus on the mechanisms that gives rise to irreversible process starting from an deterministic reversible process. The connection between the second law and combinatorics dates back to Boltzmann. In his investigation of equilibrium macrostates, in a system of indistinguishable particles distributed among discrete energy levels, he was led to study the asymptotic behavior of multinomial coefficients using Stirling’s approximation. Niven in [ 18 , 19 ] provides a general picture of the use of combinatorial methods along this line. The main advantage of the combinatorial approach is that rigorous definitions and computations, that may be elusive in the continuous case, become available allowing hypothesis and conjectures to be probed. A natural way to construct combinatorial systems is going through a double process of discretization, as in Examples 2 , 3 , 4 , i.e. discretization at micro and macro scales. This process typically results in stochastic dynamics, but here we focus on deterministic invertible dynamics. However, from the combinatorial viewpoint, it is natural to postpone taking this limit to the very end, as it has been successfully done in other areas, for example, in h -calculus and q -calculus [ 16 ] . Although the combinatorial definitions used in this work are completely self-contained, and require no prior background in physics, for the reader benefit, we briefly explain where these definitions come from, and what are the intended applications. For in depths introductions to this topic, the reader may consult [ 2 , 10 , 14 , 15 ] . In thermodynamics entropy \ S_{T}\ is a function on state space whose points parameterize equilibrium states of the system. The second law states that when an isolated system in equilibrium \ X\ has a constraint removed (e.g. a wall is removed,) causing the system to evolve (in phase space) to a new equilibrium \ Y,\ then entropy increases, i.e. \ S_{T}(X)\leq S_{T}(Y).\ The second law only demands that entropy be defined at the beginning and at the end of this process. There are three different definitions of entropy \ S_{T},\ which turn out to be equivalent, in the sense that in the examples where this quantities have be computed, they give the same result (in the thermodynamic limit, up to a constant). Jaynes [ 13 ] is a main reference on this topic, however, there seems to be a lack of general formal rigorous statements and proofs of this equivalence in the literature. Clausius entropy \ S_{C}\ is defined via the differential equation on state space dS_{C}\ =\ \frac{dQ}{T}, (1) where \ dQ\ is the heat received, and \ T\ is the temperature of the system. From this equation \ S_{C}(X)\ can be obtained, up to a constant, by integration over paths in state space, i.e. integration over reversible paths. The second law follows the inequality 1 1 1 Here the system receives heat \ dQ\ from a reservoir at temperature \ T.\ Note that the temperature of the system may not be defined as it step away from equilibrium. Clausius justified this inequality from Carnot’s principle. \oint\frac{dQ}{T}\ \leq\ 0, (2) which is an identity for a reversible process, and strict for irrevesible processes. Gibbs entropy is based on an explicitly description of equilibrium states as probability distributions on phase space. It is given by S_{G}(X)\ =\ kH(p_{X}), (3) where \ k\ is the Boltzmann constant, and \ H(p_{X})\ is the Shannon entropy ( 7 ) of the equilibrium distribution \ p_{X},\ i.e. \ p_{X}\ is the distribution of maximum Shannon entropy \ H(p)\ among all probability distributions \ p\ on phase space compatible with the state point \ X.\ The connection between Gibbs and Clausius entropy comes from the fact that, in the intended examples, \ p_{X}\ is given explicitly by the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution, so \ S_{G}(X)\ can be computed and it is shown that it satisfies Clausius differential equation ( 1 ). The second law states that when a system in equilibrium \ X\ has a constrain removed, and the system evolve to a new equilibrium \ Y,\ then \ H(p_{X})\leq H(p_{Y}).\ Assuming that evolution preserves Shannon entropy, which follows from Liouville’s theorem, and that \ p_{X}\ is transported to a probability distribution \ p^{\prime}_{X}\ compatible with \ Y,\ then \ \ H(p_{X})=H(p^{\prime}_{X})\leq H(p_{Y}),\ \ because \ H(p_{Y})\ is maximum among all distribution compatible with \ Y. Boltzmann entropy is based on a more intuitive description of equilibrium states which are now understood as subsets of phase space. It is given by S_{B}(X)\ =\ k\mathrm{ln}W\ =\ k\mathrm{ln}\mathrm{vol}(a_{X}), (4) where \ k\ is the Boltzmann constant, \ a_{X}\ is a subset of phase space, and \ \mathrm{ln}\mathrm{vol}(a_{X})\ is the logarithmic volume of \ a_{X}.\ Intuitively, \ a_{X}\ is the set of phase space points compatible with the system being at state \ X.\ The bridge between Boltzmann and Gibbs entropy is the asymptotic equipartition theorem, which tell us, when applicable, that the distribution \ p_{X}\ is overwhelmingly concentrated on a subset \ a_{X}\ of phase space such that \ p_{X}\ is, roughly speaking, uniform on \ a_{X},\ thus \ \ S_{G}(X)\ =\ kH(p_{X})\ \approx\ k\mathrm{ln}\mathrm{vol}(a_{X})\ =\ S_{B}(X).\ \ The second law states that when a system in equilibrium \ X\ has constrain removed, and the system evolves to a new equilibrium \ Y,\ then \ \mathrm{vol}(a_{X})\leq\mathrm{vol}(a_{Y}).\ If volume is preserved, then \ \mathrm{vol}(a_{X})\leq\mathrm{vol}(a_{Y})\ since the reproducible evolution maps points in \ a_{X}\ to points in \ a_{Y}.\ This work is organized as follows. In Section 2 we define micro-macro systems, introduce examples, methods of constructions, and study the classes of isomorphisms of such systems. In

Read the complete text