AI-Mediated Communication Can Steer Collective Opinion

Stratis Tsirtsis 1, Kai Rawal 2, Chris Russell 2, Brent Mittelstadt 2,3, Sandra Wachter 1,2 · 2026

Read AI-Mediated Communication Can Steer Collective Opinion by Stratis Tsirtsis 1, Kai Rawal 2, Chris Russell 2, Brent Mittelstadt 2,3, Sandra Wachter 1,2 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-16245.txt.

Introduction

Tsirtsis and four colleagues show that AI-mediated communication can steer collective opinion, not just individual views. Language models instructed to edit texts on contested topics introduce directional biases, for instance nudging texts toward gun control and against atheism. Their opinion-dynamics model places an AI system between users on a social network, transforming expressed and perceived opinions. Simulations on real network data show such biases amplify and shift collective opinion, and an audit of X's Explain this post feature found pro-life bias in Grok's abortion-related outputs.

Catalog record

CREATORStratis Tsirtsis 1, Kai Rawal 2, Chris Russell 2, Brent Mittelstadt 2,3, Sandra Wachter 1,2
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE85895
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.16245

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

AI-Mediated Communication Can Steer Collective Opinion Stratis Tsirtsis 1, Kai Rawal 2, Chris Russell 2, Brent Mittelstadt 2,3, Sandra Wachter 1,2 Abstract Generative artificial intelligence (AI) is increasingly integrated into the online platforms where humans exchange opinions; large language models (LLMs) now polish users’ posts on LinkedIn and provide context for content shared on X. While prior work has shown that AI can express biased opinions and shape individuals’ opinions during human-AI interactions, less attention has been paid to its influence on collective opinion formation when mediating human-to-human communication. We address this gap via a combination of empirical and theoretical analyses. We show empirically that LLMs from multiple popular families introduce directional biases when instructed to edit human-written texts on contested topics, for example, nudging texts in favor of gun control and against atheism. Building on this observation, we introduce a mathematical model of opinion dynamics in which an AI system sits between users on a social network, transforming the opinions they express and perceive. By analytically characterizing the equilibrium of this model and performing simulations on real social network data, we show that biases introduced by AI in human-to-human communication can be amplified through the network and shift collective opinion in their direction. In light of these findings, we investigate whether such biases are controllable by online platforms. We audit the “Explain this post” feature on X and find evidence of pro-life bias in Grok’s outputs on abortion-related content, which we trace back to specific design choices. We conclude with a discussion of the broader implications of our findings in relation to ongoing legislative efforts in the European Union. 1 Introduction Imagine you visit a social media platform to share your thoughts on whether AI should be used in education. You lean positively, and you draft a short post endorsing the idea: “ AI might be a useful tool for personalizing the education of students. ” Before sharing it, you decide to click the “ Improve my post ” button, and a large language model (LLM) provided by the platform returns a polished and more explicitly endorsing version: “ Let’s embrace the potential of AI to personalize learning and revolutionize education for every student! ” You find this version more engaging than the one you wrote, so you simply accept the edit and publish it. A simple nudge. But what if the same LLM is quietly nudging millions of users in the same direction? Generative AI systems are widely embedded in major online platforms. For example, on LinkedIn, they help users improve their posts [ 14 ] ; on YouTube, they generate video summaries based on transcripts [ 16 ] ; and on X, they provide context to help users better understand others’ content [ 15 ] . In such use cases, AI systems do not produce standalone content, but modify content created by humans or enrich it with additional information, effectively mediating communication on the very platforms where humans often exchange and form opinions about contested social and political issues. While AI has shown potential to play a positive role in tempering disagreement and helping humans find common ground [ 19 , 78 ] , its use is no panacea. For example, evidence suggests that LLMs carry biases in the opinions they express, both directly when asked to take a stance on politically salient topics [ 68 ] and indirectly when asked to summarize diverse human opinions on a topic [ 51 ] . At the same time, LLMs have been shown to have persuasive effects on individuals through targeted messaging [ 48 ] and conversational interactions [ 49 , 67 ] . More worryingly, they have also been shown to shift individuals’ expressed opinions without their awareness in seemingly innocuous interactions, such as during assisted writing [ 52 ] . This raises concerns about how AI biases may shape the opinions of users who rely on them to express themselves online and interpret the opinions of others. A question naturally arises: How do the biases of an AI system influence the collective opinion within a social network when used to mediate communication? To answer this question, we draw insights from mathematical sociology, where a rich literature on opinion dynamics has studied how social influence and network structure interact to shape a population’s collective opinion over time [ 35 , 41 , 66 , 70 ] . Beyond characterizing the opinion formation process itself, a parallel line of work in computer science has examined levers through which one can influence the process, such as changing the opinions of key individuals or perturbing the network’s connections [ 47 , 22 , 61 , 44 , 79 , 59 ] . Our work points to AI-mediated communication as a new such lever, with underexplored implications for human knowledge [ 63 , 80 ] and democratic processes [ 76 , 54 ] . 1 1 1 For a discussion of further related work, refer to Appendix A . Our contributions. Our work introduces a combination of empirical, theoretical, and legal analysis of AI biases and the effects they can have on collective opinion when AI systems are used to mediate human-to-human communication on online platforms. Specifically, we make the following contributions: 1. We instruct a set of open-weight LLMs from four different families to draft and improve social media posts on 13 contested topics given original arguments and posts written by humans. We develop a methodology to score each post by the degree to which it expresses an opinion in favor or against the respective topic, and use it to show that all LLMs we study introduce directional biases across topics, even when instructed to maintain the opinion expressed in the original text. 2 2 2 The code used in our experiments can be found at https://github.com/stsirtsis/llm-opinion-formation . 2. We introduce a mathematical model of AI-mediated opinion dynamics extending the seminal model by Friedkin and Johnsen [ 41 ] , in which an AI system sits between users on a social network, transforming the opinions they express and perceive. We formally analyze the equilibrium and convergence properties of this model and characterize the shift in collective opinion at equilibrium due to the AI transformation. 3. We complement our aforementioned theoretical analysis with simulations on real social network data, showing that biases introduced by an AI system to individual opinions can be amplified through the network over time, leading to a shift in the long-run average opinion much larger than the average bias the AI system introduces to individual opinions. 4. We investigate whether AI biases and, by extension, the opinion formation process, can be shaped through platform design choices. To this end, we audit the “Explain this post” feature deployed on X by asking Grok to contextualize a set of human-written posts on abortion, following the feature’s publicly released implementation. We find evidence that Grok presents a directional bias—it more frequently generates context that aligns with the stance of the human-written post when it is pro-life than when it is pro-choice—which is driven by one specific guideline provided to the model by X. We conclude with a discussion of the broader implications of our findings in relation to specific articles in

Read the complete text