Gaussian fluctuations in the tunneling probability of a closed universe
Luca Salasnich · 2026
Read Gaussian fluctuations in the tunneling probability of a closed universe by Luca Salasnich (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-16150.txt.
Introduction
Salasnich works out the odds that a closed universe tunnels into being, in the Euclidean path-integral picture. The formula keeps both the exponential suppression and the exact Gaussian prefactor from small wiggles around the instanton. In a fixed-interval minisuperspace setup, he imposes the Hamiltonian constraint at the classical instanton level. The result sharpens past work and gives a clear estimate of the nucleation rate.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Luca Salasnich |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30778 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.16150
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Gaussian fluctuations in the tunneling probability of a closed universe Luca Salasnich Abstract We consider the quantum creation of a closed universe within the Euclidean path-integral formalism. An analytical expression for the tunneling probability is derived, including both the exponential suppression and the exact Gaussian prefactor due to quadratic fluctuations around the instanton. The calculation is performed in a fixed-interval minisuperspace formulation, where the Hamiltonian constraint is imposed at the level of the classical instanton, while the full lapse integration is not included beyond the leading semiclassical approximation. The result provides a transparent and self-consistent semiclassical estimate of the nucleation rate, refining previous analyses with the inclusion of Gaussian fluctuations. I Introduction Understanding the quantum origin of the universe remains one of the fundamental challenges in theoretical cosmology cosmo-book . In the framework of closed Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) models, the nucleation of a finite-size universe can be described as a quantum tunneling process from “nothing”, that is from the classically forbidden region where the scale factor vanishes pagels ; vilenkin . This scenario provides a concrete and physically motivated mechanism for the quantum creation of the universe. The Euclidean path integral offers a natural framework to describe such a process, expressing the transition amplitude between two three-geometries as a sum over all interpolating Euclidean metrics. In this approach, the semiclassical tunneling probability is dominated by the contribution of the instanton solution that extremizes the Euclidean action, leading to an exponential term governed by the cosmological constant. This picture was first formulated in the seminal works of Atkatz and Pagels pagels and Vilenkin vilenkin . Quite remarkably, although the leading exponential dependence of the tunneling probability is well understood pagels ; vilenkin ; linde ; zeldovich ; rubakov , and also generalized including massive scalar fields vilenkin2 ; vilenkin2018 ; jia2023 ; lehners , the accurate determination of the prefactor due to Gaussian fluctuations was never performed exactly, because it requires handling a complicated differential operator with non-constant coefficients and carefully treating boundary singularities in the instanton solution. To the best of our knowledge, an explicit closed analytical expression for the Gaussian fluctuation prefactor in this Euclidean closed-FLRW tunneling problem has not been previously derived. The aim of the present work is therefore not to formulate a complete constrained gravitational path integral, but to isolate and evaluate exactly the quadratic fluctuation determinant associated with the standard semiclassical Euclidean instanton. Figure 1: Graphical summary of the main results discussed in this paper: the analytical calculation of the quantum tunneling probability of a closed universe including Gaussian fluctuations. In this work we adopt the path-integral formulation of quantum cosmology for a closed FLRW universe and derive a fully analytical expression for the tunneling probability, including both the exponential suppression and the exact Gaussian prefactor arising from quadratic fluctuations around the instanton solution. See also Fig. 1 . Our derivation extends the analyses of Refs. pagels ; vilenkin , yielding a transparent and self-consistent semiclassical estimate of the tunneling rate, and clarifying the role of the fluctuation determinant in the Euclidean path integral for quantum cosmology. It is important to emphasize that the issue of fluctuations in quantum cosmology has been discussed in detail in several works in the literature. For example, Ref. dealwis2019 analyzes the nature of quadratic fluctuations around homogeneous backgrounds within a Hamiltonian/Wheeler-DeWitt formalism, including implications for cosmological perturbations. Ref. halliwell2019 investigates conceptual aspects of the no-boundary wave function and the structure of fluctuations in that context, focusing on the definition of the quantum state rather than on an explicit evaluation of a fluctuation determinant. Moreover, Ref. feldbrugge2017 explores the Lorentzian path integral approach with complex contour deformations as a foundation for quantum cosmology. More recent developments have further investigated Lorentzian and Picard-Lefschetz formulations of quantum cosmology, including truly Lorentzian minisuperspace path integrals, resurgence methods around cosmological saddle points, and extensions involving torsion jia2023 ; honda2024 ; mondal2024 . In contrast, the present work remains within the standard Euclidean tunneling proposal for a closed FLRW universe and focuses on the explicit analytical evaluation of the Gaussian prefactor associated with quadratic fluctuations around the Euclidean instanton solution. This provides a closed-form expression for the semiclassical tunneling probability and quantifies directly the contribution of quadratic fluctuations to the prefactor, without relying on contour deformations or numerical approximations. II Closed Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker universe Let us consider the action functional of a closed Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker universe cosmo-book S[a(t)]=-A\int dt\,[a\,{\dot{a}}^{2}-V(a)]\;, (1) where A={3\pi c^{3}\over 4G\Lambda} (2) with c the speed of light in vacuum, G the gravitational constant, and \Lambda the cosmological constant. Here a(t) is the scale factor of this minisuperspace approximation of the universe with V(a)=a\left(1-{1\over 3}a^{2}\right) (3) a sort of effective potential energy, and {\dot{a}}=da/dt . Please note that a is dimensionless and it must be multiplied by a_{0}=1/\sqrt{\Lambda} to get the dimensional one. Similarly, t is the dimensionless time and it must be multiplied by t_{0}=a_{0}/c to get the dimensional one. The constant of motion during the time evolution is E=-A\,[a\,{\dot{a}}^{2}+V(a)]\;. (4) Notice that both A and E have the dimensional units of an action (Joule \times seconds). In quantum cosmology the lapse function is the Lagrange multiplier enforcing the Hamiltonian constraint and reflects the invariance under time reparametrizations. In the present reduced formulation we work in a fixed proper-time gauge, so that the lapse is not treated as an independent dynamical variable in the fluctuation determinant. Equivalently, the zero-energy Hamiltonian constraint is imposed on the classical instanton solution, while the Gaussian determinant is evaluated for fluctuations of the scale factor with fixed endpoints over the corresponding Euclidean time interval. This allows us to compute Gaussian fluctuations directly for this fixed-interval system, providing a well-defined semiclassical prefactor within the chosen gauge-fixed minisuperspace setting, although it does not represent the full Faddeev-Popov or BRST quantization of the gravitational path integral. III Quantum tunneling from “nothing” In the description of a closed FLRW universe, invariance under time reparametrization leads to the constraint E=0 vilenkin ; dewitt . Under this constraint the region with 0\leq a\leq\sqrt{3} is classically forbidden. One can calculate the probability rate P_{T} of quantum tunneling from a=0 to a=\sqrt{3} by using the quantum propagator \langle a_{F}=\sqrt{3},t_{F}|a_{I}=0,t_{I}=0\rangle as follows P_{T}=|\langle a_{F}=\sqrt{3},t_{F}|a_{I}=0,t_{I}=0\rangle|^{2}\;. (5) The ratio is needed to have a dimensionless quantity with initial probability P_{T} equal to one. The quantum propagator can be written as a Feynman path integral hibbs-book ; altland-book \langle a_{F}=\sqrt{3},t_{F}|a_{I}=0,t_{I}=0\rangle=\int{\cal D}[a(t)]\,e^{{i\over\hbar}S[a(t)]}\;. (6) Performing a Wick rotation t=i\tau (7) we have \langle a_{F}=\sqrt{3},\tau_{F}|a_{I}=0,\tau_{I}=0\rangle=\int{\cal D}[a(\tau)]\,e^{-S_{E}[a(\tau)]/\hbar} (8) with S_{E}[a(\tau)]=A\int_{0}^{\tau_{F}}d\tau\,[a\,{a^{\prime}}^{2}+V(a)] (9) the Euclidean action and a^{\prime}=da/d\tau . Quite remarkably a_{c}(\tau)=\sqrt{3}\,\sin\left({\tau\over\sqrt{3}}\right) (10) is the instanton solution that extremizes S_{E}[a(\tau)] with boundary conditions a_{c}(0)=0 and a_{c}(\tau_{F})=\sqrt{3} provided that \tau_{F}={\pi\over 2}\sqrt{3}\;. (11) The Euclidean action for this solution can be evaluated in closed form: S_{E}[a_{c}(\tau)]=2A={3\pi c^{3}\over 2G\Lambda}\;. (12) It follows immediately that within the saddle point approximation, where P_{T}=|e^{-S_{E}[a_{c}(\tau)]/\hbar}|^{2}\;, (13) the tunneling probability reads P_{T}=\exp{\left(-{3\pi c^{3}\over G\Lambda\hbar}\right)}\;. (14) This result was obtained for the first time by Atkatz and Pagels pagels and Vilenkin vilenkin in 1982, see also Refs. linde ; zeldovich ; rubakov ; vilenkin2 ; vilenkin2018 . The exponentially decreasing behavior obtained here arises from the Wick rotation t=i\tau , that is the Vilenkin tunneling proposal. In the Hartle-Hawking no-boundary proposal hartle , the opposite sign