Which Moments Matter? Heuristics of Remembered Travel Experience in Public Transport Journal: Transportation Research Part F: Transport Psychology
Esther Bosch, Klas Ihme, Stefan Bohmann · 2026
Read Which Moments Matter? Heuristics of Remembered Travel Experience in Public Transport Journal: Transportation Research Part F: Transport Psychology by Esther Bosch, Klas Ihme, Stefan Bohmann (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-15817.txt.
Introduction
Esther Bosch, Klas Ihme and Stefan Bohmann ask which moments of a bus or train trip shape how travelers later judge it. They sampled on-trip experience every five minutes across 2576 real public transport trips in three German cities, then compared aggregation rules against post-trip satisfaction. A Minimum-End rule, combining the worst moment with the final experience, predicted best. Averages, peak-end rules, the final moment alone and trip length all fared worse. The authors suggest fixing bad moments and endings to lift remembered satisfaction.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Esther Bosch, Klas Ihme, Stefan Bohmann |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34791 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.15817
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Which Moments Matter? Heuristics of Remembered Travel Experience in Public Transport Journal: Transportation Research Part F: Transport Psychology Esther Bosch, Klas Ihme, Stefan Bohmann Abstract Understanding how travelers form overall evaluations of public transport journeys is critical for improving travel satisfaction and encouraging sustainable mode choice. While travel satisfaction is discussed to influence attitudes and future behavior, the cognitive rules by which moment-to-moment experiences are aggregated into retrospective evaluations remain poorly understood in transport research. Drawing on psychological theories of experienced and remembered utility, this study investigates which temporal aggregation heuristics best predict post-trip travel satisfaction. Using a smartphone-based experience sampling approach, we collected high-frequency on-trip experience ratings and post-trip evaluations for 2576 real-world public transport trips across three German cities. Travel experience was assessed every five minutes during trips using a multi-item scale, allowing direct comparison of competing aggregation rules, including mean experience, peak–end, minimum–end, final moment, and trip duration. Multilevel regression models were estimated to evaluate the explanatory power of each heuristic. Results show that retrospective travel satisfaction is best predicted by a Minimum–End heuristic, combining the most negative moment of the journey and the final experience. Models based on mean experience, peak–end rules, final moment alone, or trip duration performed substantially worse. This pattern indicates that both negative extremes and the final phase of a journey independently contribute to remembered evaluations, rather than overall satisfaction reflecting an average of momentary experiences. The results have important implications for theory and practice, suggesting that targeted interventions at critical negative moments and at trip endings may yield substantial improvements in remembered satisfaction and, ultimately, support shifts toward sustainable mobility. † † highlights: High-frequency experience sampling captures moment-to-moment travel experience during real-world public transport trips. Retrospective travel satisfaction is best predicted by a Minimum–End heuristic rather than by mean experience or duration. The most negative moment and the final experience disproportionately shape remembered public transport journeys. Fine-grained withon-trip measurements outperform coarse or single-item approaches for testing evaluative heuristics. Targeting worst moments and trip endings offers leverage points for improving public transport satisfaction and mode choice. 1 Introduction A large-scale shift from private car use to public transport (PT) is a central challenge for a transition towards sustainable mobility. Achieving this shift is crucial to providing door-to-door accessibility for all travelers while reducing environmental impacts. However, despite substantial investment in PT infrastructure and service quality, many travelers remain reluctant to switch modes. Short-term interventions such as monetary incentives can temporarily encourage the use of sustainable transport modes, but their effects are typically limited to the duration of the intervention and the targeted behavior itself ( 15 ; 25 ) . To achieve lasting change, behavioral interventions must address not only situational barriers but also the underlying motivations and attitudes toward public transport. One promising pathway for strengthening positive attitudes toward PT lies in enhancing travel satisfaction. In the Travel Mode Choice Cycle described by 7 , the choice of travel mode influences the evaluation of the journey (travel satisfaction), which then shapes the mode-specific attitude and intention to use that mode in the future. Recent extensions of the model ( 17 ) explicitly incorporate within-trip subjective experiences influenced by cognitive appraisals of events such as stations, comfort, cleanliness, and availability ( 26 ) . Consistent with this, empirical evidence shows that service-related factors such as on-board cleanliness and comfort, courteous and helpful behavior from operators, safety, punctuality, and service frequency are particularly influential for satisfaction, while perceptions of value-for-money, on-board safety and cleanliness, and interactions with personnel are central to increasing loyalty and long-term commitment to PT ( 27 ) . Furthermore, feeling safe and the frequency of PT use have been identified as important predictors of perceived accessibility ( 16 ) . If improving the travel experience can enhance travel satisfaction, and if satisfaction influences attitudes and subsequent choices, then targeted improvements to these specific service attributes could contribute to long-term behavioral change. However, the mental process by which travelers integrate moment-to-moment experiences into an overall evaluation of a completed journey remains poorly understood in the PT domain. Psychological research on the evaluation of temporally extended episodes suggests that retrospective assessments are subject to systematic biases. A robust finding, known as the peak–end rule, is that global retrospective evaluations are disproportionately influenced by the most intense moment (peak) and the final moment (end) of the experience, rather than by its duration or average moment-to-moment quality ( 13 ; 20 ; 2 ) . In some contexts, such as medical procedures, small changes to the end of the experience can meaningfully alter global evaluations and subsequent behavior ( 21 ) . While PT journeys differ from such medical episodes in structure and salience of duration, the possibility that remembered satisfaction is similarly dominated by salient or final moments could offer opportunities for behavioral intervention. A related stream of work has emphasized the importance of critical incidents during travel as drivers of satisfaction and emotional well-being. Critical incidents are discrete positive or negative episodes, such as an unexpected delay, unhelpful staff interaction, or a pleasant social encounter, that disproportionately affect remembered travel experience ( 4 ; 9 ; 11 ) . 8 demonstrated that negative critical incidents in public transport, such as repeated delays or unreliable information, not only shape immediate post-trip mood but also accumulate over time into stable cognitive evaluations of service quality. Theoretical models formalize overall evaluations as an aggregation of incident-specific emotional responses, weighted by memory-decay parameters and primacy–recency effects ( 24 ; 3 ; 6 ) . This perspective suggests that remembered travel satisfaction may depend not only on the average of momentary experiences but also on the salience and frequency of particularly impactful events. Finally, the measurement of travel-related emotional well-being has itself been subject to increasing research interest. A comprehensive review highlights that most existing studies rely on retrospective reports of mood or satisfaction, while only a smaller number capture current mood before, during, and after travel ( 10 ) . The review concludes that instantaneous, repeated assessments provide the most valid basis for aggregating commuting-related emotional well-being, yet such methods are often impractical at scale. Importantly, this literature also draws attention to the distinction between experienced utility, i.e. the subjective quality of the trip as lived, and decision utility, i.e. the expected utility that guides travel choices ( 14 ; 18 ) . Because decision utility often diverges from experienced utility, especially under conditions of uncertainty or habit, interventions that improve travelers’ experienced utility may gradually shift decision-making toward sustainable modes. In the literature, related but partly distinct terms are used to describe retrospective evaluations of trips: psychologists often refer to this as remembered utility or recalled happiness, whereas transport researchers typically use the construct of travel satisfaction, which operationalizes such evaluations with domain-specific scales. In practice, all three terms capture travelers’ post-hoc assessments of their journeys, though they emphasize different disciplinary perspectives. Throughout this paper, we will refer to the construct as travel satisfaction. We use the term ’travel experience’ to refer to the momentary utility during a journey. A study that also used experience sampling, however not clearly concentrated on traveling, is 19 , who measured moment utility as real-time happiness in a