Early Emergence of Environmental Effects: Accelerated Galaxy Assembly in a z = 2.96 z=2.96 Protocluster in the COSMOS Field Facilities: JWST (NIRCam)

Shuaiyi Li, Zheng Cai, Yunjing Wu, Fujiang Yu, Xiaojing Lin, Jingyang Men, Xiaoyang Wei · 2026

Read Early Emergence of Environmental Effects: Accelerated Galaxy Assembly in a z = 2.96 z=2.96 Protocluster in the COSMOS Field Facilities: JWST (NIRCam) by Shuaiyi Li, Zheng Cai, Yunjing Wu, Fujiang Yu, Xiaojing Lin, Jingyang Men, Xiaoyang Wei (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-15712.txt.

Introduction

Shuaiyi Li and six colleagues report protocluster PC J1001+0214 at redshift 2.96 in COSMOS. Built from COSMOS2025 and JWST spectroscopy, it shows an overdensity of 2.66 in catalog data. It holds 131 galaxies: 21 confirmed by spectra, via helium emission, and 110 photometric members. Against a mass-complete sample, members show a 0.2 dex shift to higher stellar mass, a sign of faster assembly. Low-to-mid mass galaxies show star formation gains from 0.11 dex to 0.15 dex over field galaxies. The quiet fraction stays tiny and field-like, so environmental quenching has not yet taken over.

Catalog record

CREATORShuaiyi Li, Zheng Cai, Yunjing Wu, Fujiang Yu, Xiaojing Lin, Jingyang Men, Xiaoyang Wei
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45202
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.15712

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Early Emergence of Environmental Effects: Accelerated Galaxy Assembly in a z = 2.96 z=2.96 Protocluster in the COSMOS Field Facilities: JWST (NIRCam) Shuaiyi Li, Zheng Cai, Yunjing Wu, Fujiang Yu, Xiaojing Lin, Jingyang Men, Xiaoyang Wei Abstract The redshift range z = 2 z=2 –4 marks a critical transition in large scale structure formation, where the dynamically unrelaxed progenitors of local massive clusters undergo rapid stellar mass assembly. We report the discovery and physical characterization of a highly significant protocluster, PC J1001+0214, at z=2.96 within the COSMOS field. Leveraging the multi-wavelength COSMOS2025 catalog with exceptional photometric precision in conjunction with JWST/NIRCam wide-field slitless spectroscopy (WFSS) from the COSMOS-3D program, we robustly identify a cosmic overdensity with δ = 2.66 \delta=2.66 . The structure comprises 131 member galaxies, including 21 spectroscopically confirmed members (identified primarily via He i λ ​ 10830 \lambda 10830 emission) and 110 high-fidelity photometric members. A comparative analysis against a mass-complete coeval field sample reveals a statistically significant +0.2 dex shift in the stellar mass distribution of protocluster members, signaling accelerated mass assembly in the dense environment by z ∼ 3 z\sim 3 . While the protocluster population broadly follows the star-forming main sequence, low-to-intermediate mass galaxies ( log 10 ⁡ ( M ∗ / M ⊙ ) ≤ 9.7 \log_{10}(M_{*}/M_{\odot})\leq 9.7 ) exhibit a measurable star formation rate (SFR) enhancement of +0.11 to +0.15 dex. Crucially, the quiescent fraction remains extremely low and indistinguishable from the field sample, implying that environmental quenching mechanisms have not yet become dominant. Furthermore, a preliminary size-mass analysis hints at elevated morphological compactness among protocluster members at fixed stellar mass. These results suggest that PC J1001+0214 represents a growth-dominated protocluster phase in which environmental effects are already detectable, primarily through accelerated stellar mass assembly and ongoing growth rather than through strong quenching. show][email protected] I Introduction Galaxy properties in the local Universe are strongly dependent on environment, with massive, quiescent systems dominate the high-density cores of virialized clusters ( 13 ; 25 ; 17 ) . When and how such environmental dependencies manifest at higher redshift, especially at z\sim 2 –4 when cosmic star formation and stellar mass assembly are both highly active, remains a fundamental challenge in observational cosmology. ( 28 ; 43 ; 50 ; 15 ) High-redshift protoclusters, the progenitors of present-day massive galaxy clusters, provide a unique temporal window into this problem. By observing these extreme overdensities at z\geq 2 , prior to cluster virialization and the onset of pervasive intra-cluster medium (ICM) shock-heating, protoclusters serve as premier laboratories to study the early effects of environment on star formation efficiency, metallicity, hierarchical mass assembly, and the onset of systemic quenching. ( 35 ; 40 ; 56 ; 50 ; 47 ) . Previous studies reveal a complex, often conflicting picture of environmental effects in high-redshift protoclusters. On one hand, dense environments can actively fuel early galaxy growth. Observations reveal enhanced star-formation activity in protoclusters relative to the coeval field ( 19 ; 42 ; 44 ; 32 ; 56 ) . In contrast, some other overdense systems z\sim 2 –4 appear surprisingly mature. These structures already exhibit elevated quiescent fractions and early red-sequence formation ( 41 ; 24 ; 51 ; 47 ) . This diversity implies that protoclusters span a broad range of evolutionary phases. A larger sample of well-characterized systems is therefore required to systematically study different evolutionary stages and to understand how environmental effects emerge and operate in overdense regions ( 9 ; 35 ; 1 ) . While protoclusters at high redshift are traditionally identified using biased tracers like radio galaxies, quasars, or narrowband emitters, these approaches are intrinsically selective. Deep photometric redshift surveys offer a more systematic and complete alternative for mapping overdensities across broad redshift ranges. However, given the uncertainties and catastrophic failures inherent to photometric redshift selections, as well as the coarse redshift resolution of photometric membership, spectroscopic validation still remains essential to confirm genuine physical structures ( 35 ; 11 ; 18 ; 20 ) . Surveys that combine wide area, sufficient depth, accurate photometric redshifts, and efficient spectroscopic follow-up are required. COSMOS2025 and COSMOS-3D are particularly well suited to this need. Based on James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) COSMOS-Web program (PID 1727) and ancillary multiwavelength data, COSMOS2025 delivers robust photometry, morphologies, and SED-based physical parameters for 780,000 galaxies over the central 0.54 \rm deg^{2} COSMOS field. With its exceptional photo- z precision and improved mass completeness, COSMOS2025 provides a more complete sample to search protoclusters ( 7 ; 46 ) . In addition to COSMOS2025, we also use COSMOS-3D survey for possible spectroscopic follow-up validation. COSMOS-3D is a JWST/NIRCam Wide Field Slitless Spectroscopy (WFSS) program (PID 5893) within the COSMOS-Web field and is designed to provide slitless spectroscopic constraints on galaxies in the early Universe. It provides abundant 2D spectra for precise redshift verification, allowing us to confirm overdense structures. In this work, we search for protocluster candidates in COSMOS2025 catalog and identify a significantly overdense structure, PC J1001+0214. We use COSMOS-3D spectra to validate the structure and identify a clear redshift peak near z\sim 2.96 . We compare the protocluster members with a coeval field sample in terms of stellar mass distribution, the stellar formation rate (SFR)-stellar mass ( M_{*} ) relation, quiescent fraction, and the size-mass relation. This allows us to establish the reality of the structure, and to examine whether an overdense environment at z\sim 3 already leaves observable signatures on galaxy growth and how these signatures manifest. This paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we describe the data and sample selection. In Section III , we present our searching method and main results. Finally, we summarize our results and discuss their implications in Section IV . All magnitude are expressed in the AB system ( 34 ) . II Data and Reduction II.1 COSMOS2025 Photometric Catalog Our analysis is mainly based on the COSMOS2025 catalog, which serves as the parent sample for the photometric identification of candidate protocluster galaxies. 1 1 1 The catalog is publicly available at https://cosmos2025.iap.fr/ . Built upon the JWST COSMOS-Web survey ( 7 ) , COSMOS2025 combines deep near-infrared imaging from NIRCam in F115W, F150W, F277W, and F444W with parallel MIRI/F770W observations, together with extensive ancillary data from space- and ground-based facilities. The resulting catalog covers the central 0.54\,\mathrm{deg}^{2} of the COSMOS field and provides matched photometry over 37 bands spanning 0.3 – 8\,\mu m, along with morphological measurements, photometric redshifts, and SED-based physical properties for nearly 780,000 galaxies. The depth and wavelength coverage of COSMOS2025 are particularly suited to studies of galaxies at high redshift. The JWST observation reaches 5\sigma depths of 27.2–28.1 mag in the NIRCam bands, while the MIRI/F770W imaging extends over \sim 0.20\,\mathrm{deg}^{2} to 25.2 mag. Owing to this broad multiwavelength baseline and the improved near-infrared sensitivity, the catalog delivers highly reliable photometric redshifts. Comparison with spectroscopic compilations in 27 shows a precision of \sigma_{\rm MAD}\approx 0.012 for sources with magnitude m_{\rm F444W}<28 , remaining effective out to z\sim 9 ( 46 ) . Here the median absolute deviation (MAD) is defined as: \sigma_{\rm MAD}=1.48\times\mathrm{median}\left(\frac{|\Delta z-\mathrm{median}(\Delta z)|}{1+z_{\rm spec}}\right), (1) where \Delta z=z_{\rm phot}-z_{\rm spec} . In addition, COSMOS2025 substantially improves the stellar-mass completeness

Read the complete text