Multi-stability of Atlantic and Pacific overturning: The role of Freshwater Forcing Asymmetries and the Hydrological Cycle
2026
Read Multi-stability of Atlantic and Pacific overturning: The role of Freshwater Forcing Asymmetries and the Hydrological Cycle (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-15699.txt.
Introduction
Elian Vanderborght, Oliver Mehling, and Henk A. Dijkstra model why water forms in the Atlantic but not the Pacific. The gap tracks higher Atlantic surface salinity. Their two-basin model has wide and narrow basins. It admits states: sinking in the narrow basin, the wide basin, or both. States hinge on freshwater asymmetry and hydrological cycle strength. With a weak cycle, both basins sink unless one evaporates far more. With a present cycle, the more evaporative basin tends to sink. With a strong cycle, single-basin sinking rules.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2026 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 82495 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.15699
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Multi-stability of Atlantic and Pacific overturning: The role of Freshwater Forcing Asymmetries and the Hydrological Cycle Abstract A defining feature of the present-day global overturning circulation (GOC) is the absence of deep water formation in the Pacific, in contrast to the Atlantic. This asymmetry, associated with higher surface salinities in the North Atlantic, is reflected in the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) and the lack of a Pacific overturning (PMOC). A commonly cited explanation is the asymmetry in surface freshwater fluxes, with the Pacific receiving more freshwater per unit area than the Atlantic. Here, we develop a two-basin conceptual ocean model, consisting of a wide and a narrow basin. The model admits three states: sinking confined to the narrow basin, sinking confined to the wide basin, and sinking in both basins. We analyze the (co-)existence of these states as a function of freshwater asymmetry and hydrological cycle strength, defined as the longitudinally symmetric freshwater flux. For a weak hydrological cycle, representative of warm Pliocene-like climate conditions, sinking occurs in both basins, with symmetry breaking only when one basin is sufficiently more evaporative. For intermediate conditions, representative of the present-day climate, the basin with slightly stronger evaporation tends to host sinking, with a stronger preference in the narrow basin. For a strong hydrological cycle, single-basin sinking states are preferred, although a large interbasin freshwater asymmetry is required to uniquely localize sinking. These results provide insight into GOC sinking configurations under past, present, and potential future climates, and show good agreement with a three-dimensional global circulation model. † † authors: Elian Vanderborght \aff a, Oliver Mehling \aff a Henk A. Dijkstra \aff a,b \statement A defining question in physical oceanography is why deep water formation occurs in the Atlantic (AMOC) but not in the Pacific (PMOC). A common explanation is that the Pacific receives more freshwater, suppressing sinking, but this remains debated due to the many other proposed mechanisms. We show that this freshwater asymmetry is essential under present-day conditions, explaining why the Atlantic hosts the AMOC rather than the PMOC. Its influence, however, depends strongly on the intensity of the hydrological cycle. For weak cycles, sinking occurs in both basins, whereas for strong cycles it is confined to a single basin. In both cases, the freshwater asymmetry exerts only limited control on the localization of sinking. These results suggest that the role of freshwater fluxes in setting overturning patterns varies across climate states, with important implications for past and future ocean circulation. 1 Introduction The global overturning circulation (GOC) plays a central role in redistributing heat, carbon, and salt within the global ocean. Below the Ekman layer, and extending to depths of approximately 3,000 m, it includes the so-called mid-depth cell ( Cessi 2019 ) . This cell is characterized by deep water formation in the high-latitude Atlantic, where relatively salty surface waters lose buoyancy and are transformed into North Atlantic Deep Water (NADW). NADW forms the lower limb of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) and flows southward at depths between 1,000 and 3,000 m ( Lumpkin and Speer 2007 ) . In contrast, the present-day Pacific lacks an equivalent formation of North Pacific Deep Water (NPDW) and a corresponding Pacific Meridional Overturning Circulation (PMOC). The origin of this interbasin asymmetry remains a longstanding question in dynamical oceanography (see Ferreira et al. 2018 for a review). It has major implications for global meridional heat transport ( Ferrari and Ferreira 2011 ) and, consequently, for regional climate (e.g. van Westen et al. 2025 ). The absence of NPDW formation is commonly attributed to the low sea-surface salinity and pronounced halocline in the North Pacific, which together create a strongly stratified upper ocean that suppresses deep convection ( Warren 1983 ; Haug et al. 1999 ) . The interbasin contrast in northern sea-surface salinity has, in turn, been linked to asymmetries in atmospheric surface forcing, basin geometry, and the oceanic circulation itself. Atmospheric surface-forcing asymmetries arise in part because the North Pacific receives more freshwater per unit basin width than the North Atlantic ( Emile-Geay et al. 2003 ; Seidov et al. 2005 ; Craig et al. 2017 ) . This freshwater contrast results from moisture transport by both stationary (e.g. Sinha et al. 2012 ) and transient (e.g. Ferreira et al. 2010 ) atmospheric eddies ( Wills and Schneider 2016 ) . Additional contributions arise from anomalous moisture convergence in the tropical Pacific, associated with eastward transport across Panama ( Zaucker et al. 1994 ) , and westward transport across the western Pacific boundary linked to the monsoonal circulation ( Emile-Geay et al. 2003 ) . Surface wind variability further amplifies this asymmetry: stronger variability over the Atlantic shortens mixing timescales, promoting higher surface salinity relative to the Pacific ( Ferreira et al. 2018 ) . The role of interbasin freshwater flux asymmetry on the GOC has been investigated in numerous modeling studies. For example, Menviel et al. 2012 showed that compensating for the excess freshwater flux over the Pacific leads to the development of an active PMOC and a weakening of the AMOC. Moreover, studies examining the influence of orography on the GOC find that reduced orography weakens or even collapses the AMOC, while strengthening the PMOC. This response similarly arises from changes in the surface freshwater flux asymmetry. In particular, lowering the Tibetan Plateau decreases the freshwater flux over the Pacific relative to the Atlantic ( Su et al. 2018 ; Yang and Wen 2020 ; Yang et al. 2024 ) , while lowering the Rocky Mountains enhances moisture transport from the Pacific to the Atlantic ( Schmittner et al. 2011 ; Maffre et al. 2018 ) . Both mechanisms reduce, and may even reverse, the interbasin freshwater flux asymmetry, yielding a modified GOC configuration. Asymmetries in ocean basin geometry may further favor sinking in the Atlantic. In particular, basin width plays an important role: narrower basins are more conducive to deep-water formation because northward western boundary salt transport is less effectively compensated by the southward western boundary flow of the subpolar gyre ( De Boer et al. 2008 ; Jones and Cessi 2017 ) . Other geometric features that facilitate sinking in the Atlantic include its more northward extension, which enhances access to cold high-latitude surface waters ( De Boer et al. 2008 ; Huisman et al. 2012 ) ; interbasin exchanges through seaways such as the Mediterranean and the Bering Strait ( Reid 1979 ; Hu et al. 2012a ) ; and the shorter southward extent of the eastern continent of the Atlantic basin, which, equatorward of the zero Ekman pumping line, yields a saline westward transport from the Pacific to the Atlantic ( Nilsson et al. 2013 ; Cessi 2019 ) . However, asymmetries in sinking location may also emerge spontaneously through advective feedbacks ( Marotzke and Willebrand 1991 ) . In particular, the elevated salinity of the North Atlantic can result from the circulation itself, which imports high-salinity subtropical waters into the basin. In this framework, the presence of sinking in one basin rather than the other depends on the initial conditions ( Huisman et al. 2009 ; Nilsson et al. 2013 ) . Proxy records suggest that an active PMOC existed during the warm