Learning with Conflicts of Interest

Nischal Aryal, Arash Termehchy, Ali Vakilian, Marianne Winslett · 2026

Read Learning with Conflicts of Interest by Nischal Aryal, Arash Termehchy, Ali Vakilian, Marianne Winslett (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-15504.txt.

Introduction

Nischal Aryal, Arash Termehchy, Ali Vakilian, and Marianne Winslett study learning systems whose owners and users pull apart. Biased outputs can steer users to choices that harm them. Past fixes ask owners to curb their own bias. Owners lack motive to do so and cite free speech or trade. The team instead frames the clash as a game. Their scalable tools with proof pledges boost wanted facts and acts while cutting biased, manipulative acts.

Catalog record

CREATORNischal Aryal, Arash Termehchy, Ali Vakilian, Marianne Winslett
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE118381
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.15504

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Learning with Conflicts of Interest Nischal Aryal, Arash Termehchy, Ali Vakilian, Marianne Winslett Abstract Financial, social, and political factors often prevent the interests of the owners of ML systems and services and their users from being perfectly aligned. ML systems often produce biased information that can influence users to make decisions that are not in their best interest. Current solution approaches require ML systems to implement protocols to mitigate their biases. However, ML system owners usually do not have any incentive to implement these protocols and often argue that it limits their freedom of expression or business. We believe that a successful solution to this problem must recognize the conflict of interest between the ML systems and their users, and use this information to protect users against information that adversely influences their decisions while allowing users to safely benefit from these systems. To this end, we propose a game-theoretic framework that models the interaction between ML systems and users with conflicts of interest. We present scalable algorithms with theoretical guarantees that maximize the amount of desired information and actions and minimize the amount of biased and manipulative actions in interaction with ML systems. 1 Introduction Popular ML systems and services are usually developed and operated by government or business entities. Financial, social, and political factors prevent the incentives of these entities and their users from being perfectly aligned [ 29 ] . For example, companies are often said to rework their recommendation and ranking models to promote their own products and undermine those of their competitors [ 10 , 18 , 21 ] . News sources often provide biased recommendations that can convince users to make decisions based on the goals of the website owner [ 27 , 32 ] . Social networks often promote extreme content or points of view, which is not necessarily in the best interest of their users or society [ 30 , 31 , 27 ] . The access to a wealth of background knowledge using foundation models has given AI agents a substantial ability to influence user decisions [ 27 , 29 , 9 , 14 , 4 , 24 ] . Current proposals to combat these undesirable actions and influences of ML systems require them to implement certain rules and restrictions [ 29 , 31 ] . However, these restrictions usually conflict with the objectives of the entities behind these systems, so they do not have an incentive to implement them. In addition, some argue that these restrictions limit the freedom to consume, learn from, and distribute information or conduct business and may not be ethical or would have long-term adverse impacts on society. Also, they often impose significant computational overhead [ 29 ] . In this paper, we propose a game-theoretic framework for supervised learning in settings where the user and the learner have conflicts of interest. In our framework, the user has private training data that, if truthfully conveyed to the ML system (learner), may lead the system to learn a biased model to the benefit of the system. Importantly, our framework also captures the case where the system first learns an unbiased model and then injects bias at inference time. In both cases, the model’s predictions undermine the user’s interest, e.g., by providing biased recommendations. However, the owner of the ML system and the user do share some interests: the ML system should satisfy the user’s objective well enough to keep them engaged. If the system learns an overly biased model, the inferences using this model may be too biased and discourage the users from using the system, e.g., recommending a set of products that only remotely reflect the training data collected from the user. We can leverage this partial common interest and design algorithms that take the user’s true data as input and compute the optimal training data to share with the learner to minimize the bias of the learned model. But two can play this game! The ML system may be aware that users know about its undesirable biases in learning, e.g., based on their previous experiences. Thus, it may try to interpret the input training data strategically to offset the user’s modifications, e.g., by using its prior information about the user. We propose novel algorithms that find the equilibria of this reasoning and detect the equilibria in which the user and the learner have enough common interest to make learning an accurate model possible. We also provide efficient algorithms that find strategies for the user to modify the training data so that the resulting data reflects the true training data, to learn an accurate model, and convince the learner to deploy the least biased model possible in the setting. 2 Related Work Our model is related to several active areas in strategic and robust machine learning, but it is distinct in both what is manipulated and how the interaction is modeled . In our setting, the user privately observes a dataset D\sim\pi and sends a costless, unverifiable report M\in\mathcal{M} to influence the learner’s choice of hypothesis h\in\mathcal{H} . The learner then updates beliefs about D and chooses a hypothesis that maximizes its expected utility. Thus, the strategic object is not an individual feature vector or a corrupted training point, but the reported dataset itself, and the interaction is modeled as a Bayesian information-transmission game. This differs from strategic classification , where agents manipulate their own observable features at deployment time in response to a fixed decision rule [ 12 , 1 , 5 , 20 , 7 ] . There, the central question is how a classifier changes behavior when individuals best-respond through costly feature manipulation. In contrast, in our model the user does not adapt features to a deployed classifier; instead, the user strategically controls the information released before learning , anticipating how the learner will interpret the report and choose h . It also differs from the literature on adversarial examples , which studies worst-case test-time perturbations of an input within a geometric budget such as an \ell_{p} ball [ 28 , 11 , 16 ] . That literature is primarily minimax and robustness-driven. By contrast, our model is incentive-driven: the user chooses a report to maximize U^{r}(D,h) , the learner responds according to U^{\ell}(D,h) , and equilibrium depends on beliefs and strategic signaling rather than norm-bounded perturbations. Finally, our setting is distinct from data poisoning , where an attacker modifies the training pipeline by injecting or altering data to degrade the learned model [ 3 , 26 , 13 , 19 ] . Poisoning treats the learner as training directly on corrupted samples. In our model, the key friction is instead information asymmetry : the learner knows only the prior \pi and the received report M , and must infer the hidden dataset through Bayes’ rule. For this reason, our framework is closer in spirit to cheap talk and Bayesian persuasion with endogenous learning objectives [ 15 , 6 ] than to standard poisoning models. In summary, compared with these related areas, our framework focuses on strategic dataset reporting under conflicting utilities , where equilibrium behavior is governed by signaling, posterior beliefs, and the learner’s downstream choice of hypothesis. 3 Model We study a

Read the complete text