Estimated Dynamic Equilibrium Model: Supply and Demand as a Sample Path of a Stochastic Process

Mikhail L. Arbuzov, Sisong Bei, Alexey Shvets · 2026

Read Estimated Dynamic Equilibrium Model: Supply and Demand as a Sample Path of a Stochastic Process by Mikhail L. Arbuzov, Sisong Bei, Alexey Shvets (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-15472.txt.

Introduction

Mikhail L. Arbuzov, Sisong Bei, and Alexey Shvets model supply and demand as a random process. Agents in the model hold noisy, mixed valuations. Clearing prices are drawn time and again from the top tail of bid lists. Those prices then feed later valuations. Mean prices drift up even when valuation slips average to zero. Piled up over time, this bias gives exponential price growth. A simulated housing block shows six distinct regimes, from calm bands to runaway bubbles.

Catalog record

CREATORMikhail L. Arbuzov, Sisong Bei, Alexey Shvets
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70563
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.15472

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Estimated Dynamic Equilibrium Model: Supply and Demand as a Sample Path of a Stochastic Process Mikhail L. Arbuzov, Sisong Bei, Alexey Shvets Abstract We introduce the Estimated Dynamic Equilibrium Model (EDEM), an agent-based framework that treats supply and demand as a coupled stochastic process driven by heterogeneous, noisy agent valuations. The model’s primary technical contribution is the identification of a generative mechanism for persistent disequilibrium: when market-clearing prices are sequentially sampled from the upper tail of noisy bid distributions and recycled as inputs for future valuations, expected prices drift upward despite strictly zero-mean estimation errors. We derive this order-statistic bias in closed form for i.i.d. uniform bids and use simulations to show that compounding this bias across epochs yields exponential price growth without requiring assumptions of investor optimism or irrationality. This framework extends Miller’s divergence-of-opinion theory to a dynamic setting, recovering Walrasian equilibrium and Miller’s static premium as limiting cases. Through controlled experiments and sensitivity analysis on a simulated real-estate neighborhood, we identify six distinct regimes—ranging from band-stability to runaway bubbles—emerging from a single agent ruleset. These results offer a potential explanation for the contradictory findings in the empirical divergence-of-opinion literature and suggest that machine-learning valuation algorithms may inadvertently amplify this inherent statistical bias. Keywords: agent-based model; bottom-up; stochastic process; disequilibrium; divergence of opinion; real-estate market 1 Introduction The Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) remains the dominant theory of price formation. It predicts when prices reflect available information but does not provide a generative microstructural account of when and why they fail to: bubbles, crashes, persistent cross-sectional return anomalies, and the stylised observation that real markets very rarely sit at the textbook supply–demand fixed point. Decades of empirical work have produced rival theories whose claims often contradict one another, because abundant and noisy financial data can be mined to support nearly any hypothesis ( 12 ) . To avoid contributing yet another empirical controversy, this paper takes the less traveled atheoretical route: constructing an economy from the ground up in a controlled environment and asking what behavior emerges from a small number of common-sense rules. The central technical claim of the paper is that two structural features — max-bid clearing and per-epoch feedback of clearing prices into agent valuations — generate persistent positive drift in realised market prices even when individual agents’ estimation errors are exactly zero-mean. The mechanism is order-statistic bias: each seller selects the maximum of multiple noisy bids, and the maximum of n zero-mean draws is, in expectation, strictly above their mean. Feeding the realised maximum back into the next round’s anchor compounds the bias multiplicatively. No behavioural assumption about investor optimism, risk aversion, or attention is required. Bubbles, business cycles, persistent overshoots, and persistent undershoots all follow from this single mechanism interacting with heterogeneous time-on-market dynamics. We use agent-based modelling ( 15 ) because it allows this kind of structural mechanism to emerge from a few simple, transparent rules. The setting is a real-estate market in a small neighbourhood — a market in which every participant must form a personal estimate of an asset whose true value is fundamentally uncertain. Real estate is a useful laboratory: prices are observable, transactions are costly enough that naïve arbitrage arguments fail, and divergence of opinion among buyers and sellers is the rule rather than the exception. The central object of study is the Estimated Dynamic Equilibrium Model (EDEM), in which supply and demand are not static schedules but realisations of a stochastic process driven by heterogeneous, error-prone agent valuations. EDEM is a dynamic extension of 11 ’s divergence-of-opinion theory, but it relaxes Miller’s static one-shot setting to allow valuations, the price level, and the population of buyers and sellers to co-evolve over time. The paper makes three contributions: 1. An order-statistic mechanism for bubbles without biased agents ( Section 3.7 ): we derive in closed form, for a clean special case, that the expected winning bid exceeds the home value by \sigma(n-1)/(n+1) when n bidders draw zero-mean errors with dispersion \sigma . Compounded across epochs, this produces the exponential price drift of Section 5.2.1 . 2. A unified framework ( Section 3 ) that nests the classical Walrasian equilibrium and Miller’s static premium as limiting cases, and admits a family of out-of-equilibrium regimes (business cycles, persistent overshoots and undershoots, bubbles, constant transition) parameterised by estimation noise, balancer strength, and time-on-market. 3. Eight primary controlled experiments plus a 30-cell sensitivity grid ( Section 5 ) implemented in the Python ABM framework Mesa ( 8 ) , replacing earlier 15 NetLogo prototypes. The Mesa codebase is open source and reproduces every figure in the paper from a clean checkout. A practical implication is that empirical premium-vs-discount findings depend strongly on the sample’s position along the underlying stochastic trajectory, which short-window studies cannot identify. Two studies that find opposite signs may both be correct characterisations of distinct epochs in the same process. A secondary implication concerns valuation algorithms: a machine-learning estimator trained on historical clearing prices inherits the bid-selection asymmetry and re-deploys it as a positively-biased point estimator, providing the market with a coordinating signal that can amplify the very bubble the algorithm was meant to price. Section 6.4 discusses this in connection with the 2021 wind-down of Zillow Offers ( 17 ) . The remainder of the paper is organised as follows. Section 2 reviews 11 and the divergence-of-opinion debate. Section 3 presents the EDEM framework formally and derives the order-statistic drift. Section 4 describes the Mesa implementation. Section 5 reports the eight primary experiments and their results. Section 6 discusses implications. Section 7 sketches extensions and Section 8 concludes. 2 Background: Divergence of Opinion 2.1 Miller’s static premium hypothesis 11 proposed a deceptively simple model of how heterogeneous beliefs determine an asset’s market price. Suppose any single investor can purchase only one share—perhaps because of limited funds—and there are N shares available. The shares will end up owned by the N investors with the highest valuations. The marginal investor, the one with the lowest valuation among the holders, sets the price. As the divergence of opinion about the asset’s value widens, this marginal valuation rises, pushing the price above the mean estimate of all potential investors. The implication is striking: when short selling is restricted, an asset’s price reflects the optimism of a minority, not the average view of the market. Greater disagreement among investors thus produces a premium , and because eventual returns must be earned against this elevated price, future returns on high-disagreement assets should be lower. This is the “divergence of opinion premium hypothesis”—or, equivalently, the overvaluation hypothesis ( 4 ) . Miller offered initial empirical support: stocks about which there is the greatest divergence of opinion at issuance experience smaller subsequent price appreciation than “seasoned” stocks over horizons of one to five years. Although Miller’s model was largely ignored for decades, its narrative remains unusually compelling. As 12 puts it, “although Miller’s model has largely been ignored, it has lost none of its relevance.” 2.2 The premium–discount debate The empirical literature that grew up around Miller’s hypothesis is remarkable for its inability to converge. 4 provide a careful overview of the half-century of contested findings, of which the broad outlines are as follows. The discount camp argues

Read the complete text