Multiscale order, flocking and phenotypic hysteresis in the cellular Potts model of epithelia
Calvin C. Bakker, Marc Durand, François Graner, Luca Giomi · 2026
Read Multiscale order, flocking and phenotypic hysteresis in the cellular Potts model of epithelia by Calvin C. Bakker, Marc Durand, François Graner, Luca Giomi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-15159.txt.
Introduction
Calvin C. Bakker and three others simulate epithelial tissue with the cellular Potts model, tracking both cell shape and cytoskeletal activity. The runs reveal a rich phase diagram of orientational orders coexisting across scales. Raising the actin polymerization rate drives a transition into long-range flocking, while quasi-long-range nematic order emerges at large scales. Near cell size, roughly hexagonal cells produce hexanematic order like that seen in kidney-cell monolayers.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Calvin C. Bakker, Marc Durand, François Graner, Luca Giomi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23176 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.15159
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Multiscale order, flocking and phenotypic hysteresis in the cellular Potts model of epithelia Calvin C. Bakker, Marc Durand, François Graner, Luca Giomi Abstract In epithelia, how do collective cell migration and tissue spatial organization feedback on each other? We address this question through large-scale numerical simulations of the cellular Potts model. By accounting for both cell morphology and cytoskeletal activity, we uncover a remarkably rich phase diagram featuring multiple types of orientational order, either as distinct phases or coexisting across length scales. We identify a specific pathway in parameter space along which a gradual increase in the actin polymerization rate drives a phase transition into a long-range flocking state. Simultaneously, quasi-long-range nematic order emerges at length scales much larger than the cell size due to the combined effects of directed motion and lateral cell-cell interactions. At length scales comparible to cell size, however, cells adopt an approximatively hexagonal morphology, resulting in hexanematic order, similar to that observed in reconstituted Madin-Darby Canine Kidney (MDCK) cell monolayers. With further increases in actin polymerization, nematic order becomes fully long-range, while hexatic order remains quasi-long-range and confined to short length scales, but independent of cytoskeletal activity. When noise is sufficiently low to allow crystallization at finite actin polymerization rate, cycling the cell-monolayer across the melting transition yields an example of phenotypical hysteresis, reminiscent of that observed across the epithelial-mesenchymal transition. The attempt of deciphering ordered structures in the seemingly structureless organization of epithelial tissues has recently led to the notion of multiscale order (MsO): i.e. the coexistence of different non-equilibrium phases of matter across length scales Armengol-Collado et al. 2023 ; Eckert et al. 2023 . While this program inevitably requires extending the conventional definition of “phase”, as inherited from equilibrium thermodynamics, recent numerical and experimental studies have progressively indicated that aspects of this complexity can be captured using the powerful language of liquid crystal hydrodynamics, with thermal equilibrium marking one end of a potentially large spectrum of novel out-of-equilibrium behaviors Armengol-Collado et al. 2024 ; Carenza et al. 2025 . The role of hexatic order, in particular, has drawn the most attention by virtue of its manifest connection with the honeycomb structure of cellular networks Li and Pica Ciamarra 2018 ; Durand and Heu 2019 ; Pasupalak et al. 2020 ; Li and Ai 2021 ; Nemati and de Graaf 2024 . Hexatic liquid crystals are two-dimensional fluids characterized by quasi long-range 6 -fold orientational order, generally quantified in terms of the complex function \psi_{6}=e^{6i\vartheta} , with \vartheta the local orientation of building blocks. Unlike in long-range ordered systems, where orientational correlations remains finite even at an infinite distance, quasi long-range order (QLRO) implies an algebraically decaying orientational correlation function – i.e. \langle\psi_{6}(\bm{r})\psi_{6}^{*}(\bm{0})\rangle\sim|\bm{r}|^{-\eta_{6}} – and a scale-dependent order parameter: i.e. \Psi_{6}(\ell)=\langle\psi_{6}\rangle_{\ell}\sim\ell^{-\eta_{6}/2} , where \langle\cdots\rangle_{\ell} denotes an ensemble average over the length scale \ell and \eta_{6} a non-universal exponent (or anomalous dimension). At equilibrium, this exponent varies in the range 0<\eta_{6}\leq 1/4 , with the lower bound corresponding to long-ranged order (LRO) and the upper bound setting the threshold above which a homogeneous hexatic phase is unstable to the unbinding of 5 – 7 dislocations into pairs of 5 - and 7 -fold disclinations Halperin and Nelson 1978 ; Nelson and Halperin 1979 ; Young 1979 . In epithelia, this process occurs through the proliferation of topological rearrangements of the first kind (i.e. T1), thus leading to cell intercalation and collective but undirected migration (i.e. swarming). In this regime, 1/4<\eta_{6}\leq 2 , with the upper bound corresponding an ensemble of uniformly distributed random orientations. Furthermore, well in the migrating phase, the interplay between lateral interactions and motion results into the emergence of nematic order at large length scales. By contrast, hexatic order remains dominant over intermediate length scales that are typically one to two orders of magnitude above the average cell size. This particular example of multiscale organization, named hexanematic in Ref. Armengol-Collado et al. 2023 , was observed in reconstituted layers of MDCK cells, as well as in numerical simulations of the multi phase-field model Armengol-Collado et al. 2023 ; Eckert et al. 2023 . Yet, how nematic order develops at the large scale and what hexanematic organization entails in practice is presently unknown. On the other hand, large-scale directed migration (i.e. flocking) appears prominent in fluidized layers of epithelial cells, both in bulk and under confinement Carmona-Fontaine et al. 2008 ; Doxzen et al. 2013 ; Malinverno et al. 2017 ; Giavazzi et al. 2017 ; Glentis et al. 2022 . This ability of moving collectively and coherently in space is instrumental to a large variety of developmental process, such as gastrulation Scarpa and Mayor 2016 and neural crest migration Szabó and Mayor 2018 , as well as in cancer invasion Carrillo et al. 2022 ; Argento et al. 2025 . In these processes, the typical scale of collectively moving structures ranges from a dozen of border cells, as in the development of the egg chamber in Drosophila , to several hundred thousand cells, as in Dictyostelium slug development Weijer 2009 . Now, because of its resemblance with flocking in active systems, various active matter models – i.e. generically inspired by Vicsek’s foundational work Vicsek et al. 1995 – have been used to rationalize the origin of large-scale directed migration in epithelia (see e.g. Refs. Giavazzi et al. 2017 ; Giavazzi et al. 2018 ). In these models, flocking is recovered in the presence of self-alignment – i.e. the property of polar active particles to align their velocity with respect to their polar axis (see Ref. Baconnier et al. 2025 for a recent review) – while the role of orientational order is generally ignored. The latter rises questions on how flocking occurs in tissues, where self-alignment is itself an emergent property rooted in more fundamental physical mechanisms and biochemical pathways, and how these two distinct classes of migratory patterns – i.e. directed and flocking-based or undirected and intercalation-based – alternate along the epithelial-mesenchymal spectrum Zhang and Weinberg 2018 . In this article we address these questions, and more broadly the feedback between collective cell migration and spatial cell organization Yu et al. 2025 , via large-scale cell-based numerical simulations of the cellular Potts model (CPM) Graner and Glazier 1992 ; Glazier and Graner 1993 . Combining a recent implementation of the CPM on Graphical Processing Units (GPUs) Sultan et al. 2023 with an explicit model of the actin cytoskeleton Niculescu et al. 2015 , allows us to map out the complete phase diagram of epithelial migration in silico and correlate the resulting migratory patterns – comprising both directed and undirected motion – with two distinct manifestations of MsO. In the CPM, cells are represented as connected sets of pixels in a two-dimensional L\times L array (Fig. 1 a–c). Each pixel stores two integer-valued fields. One is the cell label number, \sigma_{i}\in\{1,\,2\ldots\,N\} , with N the total number of cells: a cell is defined as the set of pixels which share a common label. The other, \phi_{i}\in\{1,\,2\ldots\Phi\} , with \Phi a pre-defined constant. The former assigns a common label to the pixels comprising a given cell, while the latter, introduced in Ref. Niculescu et al. 2015 as part of the so-called Act-model, reflects