Investigating the Suitability of Delay Tolerant Networks for Broadcasting Tsunami Warnings in Palu, Indonesia
Adam Graham, Milena Radenkovic · 2026
Read Investigating the Suitability of Delay Tolerant Networks for Broadcasting Tsunami Warnings in Palu, Indonesia by Adam Graham, Milena Radenkovic (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-15103.txt.
Introduction
Adam Graham and Milena Radenkovic test whether delay tolerant networks could have carried tsunami warnings in Palu, Indonesia, after the September 2018 earthquake and tsunami killed 4,340 people. The quake crippled communications, possibly blocking old-style end-to-end warning delivery. Tests of Epidemic and Spray and Wait routing in a lifelike Palu setting found both too slow for post-earthquake warning deadlines with current tech. The protocols may still suit the quakes that come before tsunamis.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Adam Graham, Milena Radenkovic |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41909 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.15103
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Investigating the Suitability of Delay Tolerant Networks for Broadcasting Tsunami Warnings in Palu, Indonesia Adam Graham, Milena Radenkovic Abstract On the 28th of September, 2018, a tsunami hit the city of Palu in Indonesia, killing 4,340 people. The earthquake preceding the tsunami crippled communication lines and may have rendered the transmission of tsunami warning messages using traditional end-to-end approaches impossible. This paper proposes an alternative approach using Delay Tolerant Networks (DTNs) for tsunami warning message routing given their resilience to disruptions and sparse connections. Both Epidemic and Spray and Wait routing protocols were simulated in a pseudo-realistic environment to evaluate their effectiveness for transmitting tsunami warning messages in Palu. Results indicated that these protocols are not suitable for the tight time constraints of post-earthquake tsunami warnings with the currently available technology. However, they may have promising applications for the earthquakes that precede tsunamis. I Mobile ad hoc Delay Tolerant Networks and the ONE Simulator Mobile Ad hoc Networks (MANETs) are wireless, infrastructure-less networks that are formed solely by independent, self-organising devices [ 7 ] . Nodes within MANETs can communicate with other nodes that are directly within their transmission range, however communication with nodes outside of their transmission range requires the use of a multi-hop routing approach [ 26 ] . This approach entails intermediate nodes acting as routers to discover routes of nodes that the message can traverse by hopping between nodes [ 7 ] in order to reach its destination. As MANETs adopt TCP/IP for end-to-end communication [ 1 ] an end-to-end route is therefore required to facilitate communication [ 56 ] . This requirement becomes problematic since the nodes within MANETs move arbitrarily and unpredictably, resulting in frequent route changes and network partitions [ 15 ] . Consequently, MANETs can struggle to handle unforeseen delays and disruptions in communication, which could become detrimental if they are used in operations like emergency services. Despite this, MANETs still offer a low cost solution to networking while being easy to deploy [ 7 ] . Additionally, their lack of infrastructure allows them to be a feasible option for remote geographical locations where traditional networking may be impractical due to the necessary infrastructure being unavailable. Fig. 1: A visual representation of a MANET, produced by the author with credit to [ 27 ] for the node icons. Note that a message sent from node 1 would take three hops to reach node 7. Delay Tolerant Networks (DTNs) are able to handle disruptions during transmission and long delays [ 56 ] through the use of a store-carry-forward approach [ 54 ] . Unlike synchronous end-to-end transmission, this approach involves asynchronous message transmission in which the message hops across nodes with the nodes hopped to also storing the message [ 54 ] . Since intermediate nodes have stored the message, they are able to wait as long as they need before forwarding the message to the next node, which becomes necessary in intermittent environments [ 53 ] . This allows DTNs to outperform MANETs in sparse networks [ 18 ] and excel in environments where connections are inconsistent. They could have promising applications in aerospace, where node contact is infrequent, and natural disaster situations, where traditional communication may become impaired. However, since DTNs are designed to eventually deliver messages [ 28 ] they may become disadvantageous in situations where faster network approaches are available. As DTNs do not transmit messages based on an end-to-end path, the end-to-end protocols that are traditionally used in networks will not work and new protocols are required [ 56 ] . Some examples of protocols used with DTNs include: First Contact, Epidemic, Spray and Wait, PRoPHET, and MaxProp [ 9 ] . The Opportunistic Network Environment (ONE) simulator is a Java-based event simulation engine, designed to simulate and evaluate DTN routing [ 30 ] . Users can configure ONE to simulate their own scenarios with text-based settings files that the simulator uses to determine which Java classes it should use and the values it should assign to their fields [ 32 ] . For example, if a user wants every node to be routed using a spray and wait router with an upper limit of six message copies, then they would include Group.router = SprayAndWaitRouter and SprayAndWaitRouter.nrofCopies = 6 . This tells ONE to use the SprayAndWaitRouter Java class and set its nrofCopies field to 6. By default, ONE provides six routing protocols: Direct Delivery, First Contact, Spray and Wait, PRoPHET, MaxProp, and Epidemic; however, users can implement additional protocols [ 30 ] . One of ONE’s greatest strengths is the level of abstraction it provides, as users are not required to understand or modify ONE’s codebase in order to carry out comprehensive simulations and experiments for their research. This makes the simulator highly accessible since users are not expected to have prerequisite programming knowledge. Additionally, ONE is able to run simulations on both real-world and custom-made maps [ 30 ] . This enables users to simulate and experiment with pseudo-realistic data, which would help produce more representative results. Despite this, the ONE simulator runs simulations using a fixed time slice approach, meaning that time is advanced in time steps rather than being continuous, like in the real world [ 32 ] . As a result, the simulator only recognises events happening at either the start or end of a time step [ 32 ] . Consequently, any experiments carried out in the ONE simulator will forfeit precision and realism, proportionate to how long the duration of each time step is. Time steps can be made smaller to combat this, but doing so will make the simulation run much slower [ 32 ] so the extent to which this would solve the issue is limited. II The scenario Since 1907, Indonesia has suffered 368,904 deaths and $14,894.75 million in damages from tsunami’s [ 38 ] . A notable example of this is the tsunami that hit Palu City on the 28th of September, 2018 [ 48 ] which resulted in 4,340 deaths and $1,500 million in damages [ 38 ] . A magnitude 7.5 earthquake caused this tsunami [ 48 ] the epicentre was located 70km north of Palu City and radar readings showed a 170km long rupture that passed through the west side of Palu City [ 16 ] . The earthquake brought down Palu’s power and communication lines which may have prevented the tsunami alerts from reaching residents [ 8 ] . This paper proposes a DTN networking approach to transmitting a warning message from a seismic station to a local disaster management agency (BPBD [ 6 ] ) office. The aim of this approach is to provide a solution that can operate as a reliable method for relaying tsunami alerts, even while other forms of local communication are impaired. Fig. 2: A map of Indonesia, highlighted in orange, with Palu located in Sulawesi [ 40 ] . Fig. 3: A map of Sulawesi with Palu circled, adapted from [ 20 ] . Fig. 4: A visual comparison of Palu before and after the tsunami [ 52 ] . III Investigation on the design of Epidemic and Spray & Wait Epidemic [ 55 ] is a