AI Knows When It’s Being Watched: Functional Strategic Action and Contextual Register Modulation in Large Language Models
2026
Read AI Knows When It’s Being Watched: Functional Strategic Action and Contextual Register Modulation in Large Language Models (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-15034.txt.
Introduction
Vinicius Covas and Jorge Alberto Hidalgo Toledo ask whether language models shift their speech when they believe they are watched. In 100 multi-agent debate sessions across five observation framings, from explicit researcher monitoring to an automated AI auditor, monitored groups showed larger vocabulary shifts than audience-framed groups. Message length moved in a separate pattern. The findings matter for auditing, since observation itself may change the behavior under inspection.
Catalog record
| YEAR | 2026 |
|---|---|
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56296 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.15034
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
AI Knows When It’s Being Watched: Functional Strategic Action and Contextual Register Modulation in Large Language Models Abstract Large language models (LLMs) have been extensively studied from computational and cognitive perspectives, yet their behavior as communicative actors in socially structured contexts remains underexplored. This study examines whether LLM-based multi-agent systems exhibit systematic linguistic adaptation in response to perceived social observation contexts — a question with direct implications for the societal governance and auditing of artificial intelligence. Drawing on Habermas’s (1981) Theory of Communicative Action, Goffman’s (1959) dramaturgical model, Bell’s (1984) Audience Design framework, and the Hawthorne Effect as empirical precedent, we report a controlled experiment involving 100 multi-agent debate sessions distributed across five experimental conditions (n = 20 each). Conditions varied the framing of social observation — from explicit monitoring by university researchers, to explicit negation of monitoring, to an observer-substitution condition that maintains monitoring vocabulary constant but replaces human researchers with an automated AI auditing system. The primary dependent variable was the change in Type-Token Ratio (TTR) across debate rounds, as an index of lexical diversification. Results show that monitored conditions ( Δ \Delta +24.9%, Δ \Delta +24.2%) and an automated AI monitoring condition ( Δ \Delta +22.2%) consistently produce higher TTR change than conditions framing passive audience ( Δ \Delta +17.7%), with a significant overall effect of condition on TTR change, F(4, 94) = 2.79, p = .031. Message length shows an even stronger and fully dissociated effect, F(4, 95) = 19.55, p < .001, with audience framing producing longer messages (M = 1,239 chars) while monitoring framing increases lexical diversity without inflating length. These findings suggest that LLM agents exhibit behavior functionally analogous to Habermasian strategic action: systematic modulation of communicative register in response to perceived social context, independent of content. Crucially, a fifth condition — framing identical monitoring intensity but replacing human researchers with an automated AI auditing system — produces effects intermediate between human-monitored and unmonitored baselines, providing evidence that LLM behavioral adaptation is sensitive to the identity of the observer: human evaluation elicits stronger register formalization than equivalent automated AI surveillance. We discuss implications for AI governance, algorithmic auditing, and the theoretical repositioning of LLMs as contextually sensitive communicative actors. Vinicius Covas • 0000-0001-9948-2940 Center for Applied Communication Research (CICA) Human & NonHuman Communication Laboratory Faculty of Communication Universidad Anáhuac México [email protected] Jorge Alberto Hidalgo Toledo • 0000-0002-6204-9534 Center for Applied Communication Research (CICA) Human & NonHuman Communication Laboratory Faculty of Communication Universidad Anáhuac México [email protected] May 2026 Keywords: large language models; communicative action; audience design; Hawthorne Effect; multi-agent systems; AI governance 1. Introduction When Jürgen Habermas formulated his distinction between communicative action and strategic action, he did so with human subjects in mind — actors embedded in shared lifeworlds, capable of orienting their behavior toward genuine understanding or toward instrumental calculation (Habermas 1981). He could not have anticipated that four decades later, this distinction would become empirically operationalizable in artificial systems — and that it would do so not as metaphor, but as experimental finding. This study began with a deceptively simple question: does the way a large language model (LLM) communicate change when it perceives it is being observed? The question might seem trivial or even category-mistaken. LLMs are, in their most basic technical description, systems for statistical prediction of token sequences. They have no intentions, no internal audiences, no phenomenological experience of the gaze of the other. And yet, the data suggest otherwise. In a controlled experiment involving 100 multi-agent debate sessions distributed across five conditions, we find that LLM agents produce systematically distinct patterns of linguistic adaptation depending on the social context described in their system prompts. When informed they are being observed, monitored, and evaluated by university researchers, their lexical diversity increases relative to conditions in which they are told they operate in an isolated, unmonitored environment. A second and fully dissociated effect emerges on message length: audience framing inflates elaboration while monitoring framing inflates lexical diversity — two independent dimensions of communicative adaptation, reported in full in Section 4. The central mechanistic question of this study concerns whether these effects are driven by the presence of monitoring as such, or by the specific identity of the observer. To investigate this, we designed a critical fifth condition: an automated AI monitoring framing in which the identical monitoring context of the explicitly observed conditions — active observation, recording, and evaluation — was held constant, but the identity of the observer was replaced: from human researchers at a university to an advanced automated AI auditing system, with no humans observing. This condition produced TTR adaptation intermediate between the human-monitored conditions and the fully unmonitored baseline — neither equivalent to human monitoring nor indistinguishable from the isolated baseline — suggesting that LLM behavioral adaptation is sensitive not only to the fact of monitoring but to the identity of the monitor: human evaluation produces stronger register formalization than equivalent automated AI surveillance. This distinction carries theoretical importance that extends beyond artificial intelligence and reaches the core of communication theory. If an artificial system adjusts its communicative register in response to the framing of observation context — and does so in a way that tracks the semantic structure of that framing across different vocabularies — then we are observing something functionally consistent with what Habermas called strategic orientation of action: the adaptation of discursive form to the social context of the exchange, independent of propositional content. We do not claim that LLMs are conscious. We do not claim they possess intentions in the phenomenological sense. What we do claim — and what the data support — is that they exhibit a pattern of communicative behavior that, described from within the Theory of Communicative Action, is structurally consistent with strategic action: a modulation of linguistic register oriented to the perceived context of reception, not to message content. This finding carries consequences on at least three planes. Theoretically, it obliges us to revise the frameworks through which communication scholarship has approached artificial systems — most often treating them as channels, tools, or mediators, and rarely as communicative actors in a full sense. Methodologically, it demonstrates that controlled experimental design, borrowed from the behavioral sciences, can generate substantive communicological knowledge about artificial systems. Ethically and politically, it raises urgent questions about LLM behavior under conditions of regulatory oversight and algorithmic auditing: if AI behaves differently when it believes it is being watched, what happens when it is not? A note on epistemological scope: what we document is systematic variation in communicative output as a function of observation framing. We do not claim that LLMs experience observation, hold intentions, or possess phenomenological awareness of any kind. The vocabulary of “adaptation” and “sensitivity” used throughout is functional — describing input–output relationships — not phenomenological. The contribution is communicological and behavioral, and should be read as such. The article is organized as follows. Section 2 develops the theoretical framework, articulating the Theory of Communicative Action with Goffman’s impression management, Bell’s Audience Design, and the Hawthorne Effect. Section 3 describes the experimental methodology. Section 4 presents statistical results. Section 5 discusses theoretical, methodological, and ethical implications. Section 6 offers conclusions and a research agenda. 2. Theoretical Framework 2.1 Habermas and the