Tidal coplanarization of circumbinary planetary systems through stellar Cassini states
Hanlun Lei · 2026
Read Tidal coplanarization of circumbinary planetary systems through stellar Cassini states by Hanlun Lei (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-14811.txt.
Introduction
Lei investigates tidal coplanarisation of circumbinary planetary systems through stellar Cassini states. Known planets of this kind sit nearly coplanar with their host binaries. Why this pattern holds is unclear. Simulating secular spin-orbit evolution with tidal decay, a test case moves through three stages: flattening, spin-orbit synchronisation, and spin-orbit alignment. Angular momentum passes between stellar spin and orbital motion. Mutual tilt is strongly coupled to stellar obliquity. Arbitrary initial tilts are gradually damped to coplanarity by tides.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hanlun Lei |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 72593 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.14811
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Tidal coplanarization of circumbinary planetary systems through stellar Cassini states Hanlun Lei Abstract Circumbinary planets (CBPs) currently identified are in nearly coplanar configurations relative to their host binaries, yet the dynamical origin of this preference remains unclear. We investigate this question by simulating the secular spin–orbit evolution of CBP systems with tidal decay. A representative case shows that the system evolves through three stages—coplanarization, spin–orbit synchronization, and spin–orbit alignment—through the angular momentum exchange between stellar spin and orbital motion. The evolution of mutual inclination is strongly coupled to stellar obliquity. Phase-space analysis and examination of stellar Cassini states reveal that arbitrary initial inclinations are gradually damped to coplanarity by tides, while stellar obliquity is adiabatically captured into Cassini states with diminishing oscillation amplitudes. This study provides a self-consistent analytical and numerical framework for determining stellar Cassini states and understanding coupled spin–orbit evolution in CBP systems. It shows that tidal dissipation, combined with adiabatic capture into Cassini states, drives the observed dynamical behavior. I Introduction Stellar binaries and higher-order multiple systems are ubiquitous in our Galaxy, with the fraction reaching up to 70% for massive stars ( 59 , e.g.,) . Hundreds of exoplanets have been observed in such systems, with roughly 80% residing in binaries ( 45 , e.g.,) . In binary systems, planetary orbits are typically classified as either circumstellar (S-type), around a single star, or circumbinary (P-type), encompassing both stars ( 18 ; 19 ; 64 , e.g.,) . Planets in P-type orbits, known as circumbinary planets (CBPs), offer unique laboratories for studying planet formation and dynamical evolution in multi-star environments. The dynamics of circumbinary planetary systems was thoroughly investigated in 39 , who showed that the quadrupole-order (nodal) resonance shapes the V-shaped region, with high-order and secondary resonances dominating the structures inside and outside it, while the secondary 1:1 resonance is responsible for breaking the symmetry of dynamical structures in the polar region. To date, over 30 CBPs have been confirmed through various detection techniques 1 1 1 See http://exoplanet.eu/ and https://exoplanet.eu/planets_binary_circum/ . , including planetary transits ( 21 , e.g.,) , direct imaging ( 7 ; 38 , e.g.,) , eclipse timing variations ( 2 ; 5 ; 26 ; 27 , e.g.,) , microlensing ( 4 ; 37 , e.g.,) , and radial velocity monitoring ( 3 , e.g.,) . Among these, approximately a dozen are discovered by the Kepler ( 54 ; 53 ; 55 ; 65 ; 66 ; 56 ; 31 ; 33 ; 58 , e.g.,) and TESS ( 32 ; 35 ; 34 , e.g.,) space telescopes. Many circumbinary systems are observed within 1 AU, where tidal dissipation can gradually influence binary dynamics ( 43 ; 28 ; 52 ; 63 , e.g.,) . In particular, it can slowly modify the spins and orbital elements of the inner binary pair, and thus significantly alter the final configuration of systems ( 14 ; 12 ; 11 ; 15 ; 57 ; 23 ; 42 , e.g.,) . A notable feature of CBPs currently detected is the apparent absence of transiting planets around compact binaries with orbital periods shorter than 7 days, a phenomenon known as “circumbinary planet desert” ( 54 ; 42 , e.g.,) . Several mechanisms have been proposed to explain this desert, including the von Zeipel–Lidov–Kozai (ZLK) effect ( 36 ; 41 ; 22 ; 44 ; 51 ; 48 ; 40 , e.g.,) , evection resonances ( 60 ; 68 , e.g.,) , magnetic braking ( 61 , e.g.,) , tidal synchronization ( 24 , e.g.,) , observational concealment ( 49 , e.g.,) , apsidal precession resonance ( 23 , e.g.,) , and dynamical instability induced by planet–planet scattering ( 42 , e.g.,) . Another striking characteristic of the currently known CBPs is that they orbit their host binaries on nearly coplanar planes, with many located close to the dynamical stability limit ( 1 ; 67 ; 25 , e.g.,) . While this preference for coplanarity may largely result from observational biases, it does not necessarily reflect the intrinsic properties of the underlying CBP population ( 20 ; 46 ; 10 ; 39 , e.g.,) . Recent observations have revealed misaligned gas or debris disks around several stellar binaries, including 99 Herculis ( 29 , e.g.,) , IRS 43 ( 6 , e.g.,) , GG Tau ( 8 , e.g.,) , HD 142527 ( 62 , e.g.,) , HD 98800B ( 29 , e.g.,) , and AC Her ( 47 , e.g.,) , indicating that planet formation in misaligned configurations is possible. From a dynamical perspective, polar orbits in P-type configurations are stable across a broad range of binary parameters ( 17 ; 9 ; 39 , e.g.,) . Moreover, N -body simulations suggest that terrestrial planets are more likely to form around eccentric binaries in polar orbits than in coplanar configurations ( 10 , e.g.,) . These findings imply that misaligned (even polar) orbits can provide favorable dynamical environments for planet formation. From the perspective of planet formation, the possibility of misaligned orbits cannot be excluded. This raises a natural question: is there a dynamical mechanism underlying the apparent preference for coplanar configurations among observed CBPs? Within the framework of three-body circumbinary systems with tidal effects, 13 showed that circumbinary planets with arbitrary orbital inclinations can evolve toward coplanar configurations through a secular resonance between the precession of the inner orbit and the precession of the stellar spin. The goal of this work is to systematically investigate the mechanism of tidal coplanarization. To this end, we study the secular and tidal evolution of circumbinary systems within a non-restricted hierarchical three-body framework, incorporating octupole-order third-body perturbations, general relativistic corrections, rotational and tidal bulges, and tidal dissipation. Our numerical simulations show that the system first evolves toward coplanarization, then toward spin–orbit synchronization, and finally achieves spin–orbit alignment through the exchange of orbital and rotational angular momentum. The evolution of the mutual inclination is strongly coupled to that of the stellar obliquity. To understand this behavior, we analyze the phase-space structure and stellar Cassini states using Poincaré sections and perturbative methods. Our results indicate that arbitrary initial inclinations can be damped to coplanar configurations as a consequence of tidal dissipation, while stellar obliquity is captured adiabatically into Cassini states. The remainder of this work is organized as follows. In Section II , the dynamical model with tides used in this work is briefly introduced and a representative example is presented. Under a conservative approximation, the orbital and spin Hamiltonian models are separately formulated in Section III . Dynamical structures and Cassini states are numerically explored in Section IV and analytically studied in Section V . In Section VI , the results in conservative systems are applied to understand the coupled evolution of mutual inclination and stellar obliquity in the presence of tidal effects. At last, the conclusions are summarized in Section VII . Table 1: Physical parameters of the considered circumbinary planetary system, which is similar to the Kepler-34 system ( 13 , e.g.,) . Parameters Star A ( i=0 ) Star B ( i=1 ) Planet ( i=2 ) Mass m_{i} ( m_{\sun} ) 1.0 0.2 0.001 Spin period P_{i} (day) 10 1.0 0.5 Physical radius R_{i} ( \times