Efficient liability assignment under shock propagation
Jens Gudmundsson, Jens Leth Hougaard · 2026
Read Efficient liability assignment under shock propagation by Jens Gudmundsson, Jens Leth Hougaard (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-14485.txt.
Introduction
Gudmundsson and colleagues study shocks propagating along a path chosen by network agents. When a shock hits an agent, that agent cancels one outgoing edge. This cancellation cascades along a chosen path to a terminal agent, giving a systemic cost. A liability rule determines payments for losses, and the team seeks efficient path selection. Their result characterises rules setting liability proportional to total losses, with weights depending only on network structure. A path-based procedure assigning equal importance to non-sink agents gives Shapley-value weights, fast to compute.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jens Gudmundsson, Jens Leth Hougaard |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 75402 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.14485
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Efficient liability assignment under shock propagation Thanks: We thank Jay Sethuraman and Lars Peter Østerdal for valuable comments. Financial support from the Independent Research Fund Denmark (grant no. 4260-00050B) is gratefully acknowledged. Jens Gudmundsson, Jens Leth Hougaard Abstract We study a model in which shocks propagate along a path chosen by agents embedded in a network. When a shock hits an agent, the affected agent cancels one of her outgoing edges. This cancellation cascades sequentially along a chosen path until reaching a terminal agent, resulting in a systemic cost equal to the sum of individual cancellation losses. A liability rule determines agent payments for realized losses, and we seek to implement efficient path selection in the induced sequential-move game. Our main axiomatic result characterizes a family of rules, which set each agent’s liability to be proportional to the system’s total realized losses with agent weights depending only on the network structure. We propose a way to set such weights based on a simple path-based procedure that assigns equal importance to all non-sink agents along each path and then aggregates these contributions across paths. These weights coincide with the Shapley value of an associated “path-counting” cooperative game and can be computed in polynomial time. A simulation study illustrates the mechanics of our approach. Keywords: Network externality, liability assignment, efficient implementation, supply-chain disruptions 1 Introduction Network disruptions may have severe economic consequences for affected stakeholders ( 16 , for an overview, see) with firm-level shocks propagating into adverse macroeconomic outcomes ( 9 ) . Examples range from disaster-induced production losses ( 23 ) and reallocation externalities in project networks ( 14 ) to cascading bankruptcies through trade credit chains ( 25 ) . A common theme across these settings is that individual node fragility can escalate into systemic network fragility. The extent of such escalation depends on factors such as network configuration, diversification strategies, agents’ risk-mitigation decisions, and the structure of liability agreements ( 6 ; 5 ; 7 , e.g.) . As network efficiency is influenced by decentralized decisions ( 28 ) , a central challenge is to align individual incentives with system-wide objectives. To address this challenge, we focus on the role of liability assignment in the context of cascading cancellations triggered by a disruptive event. Agents are connected in a directed acyclic network of, say, bilateral contracts in a supply chain. A shock forces the source node to cancel one of its contracts (e.g., a delivery); the agent affected by this cancellation must then cancel one of her own; and so on, until the process terminates at a final sink node (say, an end consumer). Each cancellation leads to an economic loss, which may vary with the agents involved. We do not impose any form of correlation between losses; for instance, low upstream losses may well be followed by much higher downstream losses. All losses are summarized in a loss function , which maps edges to losses. We take an axiomatic approach, designing a systematic procedure—a liability rule —to allocate the total path losses among the agents in the network. Such a rule is especially valuable as a rule-of-thumb for routine operations: rather than renegotiating liabilities following each disruption, agents commit upfront to a systematic liability scheme that can be applied immediately regardless of the canceled path and realization of losses. Formally, each liability rule and loss function induces an extensive-form game of perfect information. Our first and central axiom, efficient implementation , asserts that the equilibrium outcomes of this game should coincide with the set of efficient paths. Second, realized-loss dependence centers on a practical feature: only on-path losses, which are inherently easier to verify and contract on than off-path counterfactuals, should matter. Third, pairwise collusion-proofness strengthens individual incentive compatibility by ruling out profitable joint deviations. No agent’s unilateral deviation should make any pair strictly better off, as this would enable side payments that undermine efficient implementation. Finally, we impose a standard regularity condition, scale invariance . Theorem 1 shows that these four axioms jointly characterize the family of so-called fixed-weight rules. Such a rule is parameterized by a pre-set weight vector w and assigns to each agent i the fraction w_{i}\geq 0 of the total loss with \sum_{i}w_{i}=1 . Weights may depend on the network structure but not on the underlying loss function. For instance, weights will be positive for agents with multiple outgoing edges (this will be a consequence of efficient implementation ). Fixed-weight rules are reductionist ( 8 ) : liabilities are assigned in the same way as if off-path losses were such that all paths are efficient, at which point there is no reason to condition liabilities on the chosen path. Yet more, the way losses are distributed along the chosen path is irrelevant: liabilities depend solely on the total path loss. In practice, it thus suffices to verify total losses along the canceled path and there is no need to distinguish some agent i ’s individual loss from some other agent j ’s; especially if losses for some reason are contentious, where it is not objectively clear which cancellation to associate them to, liabilities work the same and we do not need to take a stance. These rules are very robust and achieve the desired alignment of incentives even in more general settings. 1 1 1 In Section 6 , we briefly discuss allowing for incomplete information on losses and extending to more general action sets of the agents such as fractional and multi-contract cancellations. In this way, a central insight of our analysis is that losses should be treated as a common, systemic responsibility. Agents must internalize the full downstream consequences of their decisions. More local liability assignments are inadequate, e.g., in which the agent pays an amount increasing in the “direct” loss they cause to their successor (such as the ones introduced in 17 and 20 ). Indeed, such rules may even generate unbounded inefficiency; see the example in Figure 1 . 2 2 2 In Appendix C , we provide a complementary impossibility result. Specifically, there are graphs for which no rule satisfies efficient implementation , realized-loss dependence , and “on-path only” liabilities. This echoes the observation by 6 , who note that “contracts whose terms are contingent only on individual outputs may be insufficient for dealing effectively with supply risk at higher tiers”. Even introducing solidarity among agents on the canceled path (e.g., sharing total losses equally among all on-path agents) generally fails to ensure efficient cancellations. Fixed-weight rules instead imply a broader notion of solidarity that extends beyond the realized path to off-path agents as well. s 1 \dots{} m t Figure 1: There are two paths from source s to sink t : one with many unit-loss edges and one (thick) single-edge path with loss 1+\varepsilon . If the source’s liability increases only with the direct loss associated to their choice, then s prefers canceling edge s\to 1 over s\to t , leading to an inefficient path with total loss m>1+\varepsilon . To single out one member of the class of fixed-weight rules, we suggest to set weights reflecting the fraction of source-sink paths that agents are part of. These weights possess a number of interesting features.