Not All Who Wander Are Lost: Early Excess Demographics in the Volume-limited ZTF DR2 SN Ia Sample
César Rojas-Bravo, Ning-Chen Sun, Mathew Smith, Chun Chen, Xiaohan Chen, Zexi Niu, Anyu Wang, Zi-Yang Wang, Yi-Han Zhao, Jifeng Liu · 2026
Read Not All Who Wander Are Lost: Early Excess Demographics in the Volume-limited ZTF DR2 SN Ia Sample by César Rojas-Bravo, Ning-Chen Sun, Mathew Smith, Chun Chen, Xiaohan Chen, Zexi Niu, Anyu Wang, Zi-Yang Wang, Yi-Han Zhao, Jifeng Liu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-14437.txt.
Introduction
Rojas-Bravo and colleagues, in a 2026 study, search Type Ia supernovae from Zwicky Transient Facility Data Release 2 for early-time flux excesses, clues to progenitor systems and explosion mechanisms. Coverage and quality rules yield 42 early-excess events and 110 no-excess events from 1,547 supernovae. Two-sample tests show the strongest differences in light-curve properties. Early-excess events show larger SALT2 stretch and r-band secondary-maximum flux, while colour differences are weak. Early-excess events favour bluer colours and lower stellar masses. The results link early excesses to diversity.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | César Rojas-Bravo, Ning-Chen Sun, Mathew Smith, Chun Chen, Xiaohan Chen, Zexi Niu, Anyu Wang, Zi-Yang Wang, Yi-Han Zhao, Jifeng Liu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 64375 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.14437
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Not All Who Wander Are Lost: Early Excess Demographics in the Volume-limited ZTF DR2 SN Ia Sample César Rojas-Bravo, Ning-Chen Sun, Mathew Smith, Chun Chen, Xiaohan Chen, Zexi Niu, Anyu Wang, Zi-Yang Wang, Yi-Han Zhao, Jifeng Liu Abstract Early-time flux excesses in Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) offer a unique insight into their progenitor systems and explosion mechanisms. Although individual early-excess events and larger searches have been reported, demographic studies remain limited by sample size. We present a systematic search for early-time excess emission in a volume-limited sample ( z < 0.06 z<0.06 ) of SNe Ia based on the Zwicky Transient Facility Data Release 2 (ZTF DR2). Using ZTF g g - and r r -band light curves, we identify candidates showing early-excesses shortly after the explosion time, and we apply conservative coverage and quality requirements to build reliable “excess” and “no-excess” bump and no-bump catalogs. From an initial sample of 1547 SNe Ia, our final catalogs contain 42 early-excess and 110 no-excess events. We compare the two populations using SN and host environment parameters from ZTF DR2 and quantify the differences using two-sample statistical tests. We find the strongest differences are in SN light-curve properties: early-excess events have larger SALT2 stretch x 1 x_{1} ( 7.91 σ 7.91\sigma ) and larger r r -band secondary-maximum flux ℱ r 2 \mathcal{F}_{r_{2}} ( 6.25 σ 6.25\sigma ), while differences in SALT2 color c c are weak ( 0.57 σ 0.57\sigma ). Early-excess events also favor bluer ( g − z ) local (g-z)_{\rm local} ( 3.41 σ 3.41\sigma ) and lower log 10 ( M ∗ / M ⊙ ) local \log_{10}(M_{*}/M_{\odot})_{\rm local} ( 2.73 σ 2.73\sigma ). Our results connect early excesses with SNe Ia diversity, and motivate further analyses of upcoming larger samples. \volnopage 20XX Vol. X No. XX , 000–000 keywords supernovae: general — transients: supernovae 1 Introduction Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia)—the thermonuclear explosions of white dwarf stars ( 28 ) — are essential tools in modern cosmology ( 4 ; 87 ) , enabling precision measurements of the accelerating expansion of the Universe ( 62 ; 68 ; 61 ) . As we now have thousands of these supernovae observed across a wide range of distances, it has become critical to better account for astrophysical sources of error—such as the diversity in progenitor and explosion physics ( 89 ; 49 ; 32 ; 75 ) , and correlations with host-galaxy environments ( 82 ; 38 ; 81 ; 43 ; 8 ; 34 ; 74 ; 69 ; 5 ; 84 ; 39 ; 92 ; 58 ; 67 ; 93 ; 20 ; 21 ; 77 ; 85 ) . However, these fundamental questions still remain unclear despite extensive efforts (e.g., 14 ; 86 ; 46 ). In recent years, numerous SNe Ia have shown early flux above a simple power-law rise (e.g., SN 2017cbv ( 27 ) , SN 2018oh ( 14 ; 45 ; 78 ) , SN 2023bee ( 90 ) ; for a full compilation, see 98 ). Several physical scenarios have been proposed to explain early-time excess emission in SNe Ia (see 46 for a recent review), such as (i) ejecta-companion interaction, in which the collision of the SN ejecta with a non-degenerate companion produces a viewing-angle-dependent shock-heated emission, strongest at blue/UV wavelengths ( 36 ) ; (ii) shallow radioactive heating (e.g., surface 56 Ni or outward mixing of radioactive material), which can increase the earliest optical flux with different early colors ( 64 ; 63 , e.g.,) ; (iii) circumstellar material (CSM) interaction, adding early luminosity with color/timescale signatures depending on the CSM mass, opacity and other parameters ( 63 ; 52 ) ; and (iv) double detonations in sub- M_{\rm Ch} progenitors (detonation of the Carbon-Oxygen white dwarf caused by a previous detonation of a thin surface layer of helium) ( 66 ; 65 ) . Therefore, the early excess emission serves as a powerful tool to investigate the progenitor system and explosion mechanism of SNe Ia. However, distinguishing these scenarios in individual events is challenging, since their early-time signatures can overlap, and many predicted observables are viewing-angle-dependent or affected by survey limitations such as cadence and filter coverage ( 36 ; 9 ; 11 ; 98 , e.g.,) . To this end, it is essential to build large, homogeneous samples to measure how often early-time excesses occur and what they correlate with. Recent analyses have systematically tried to identify early-time bumps in modern datasets ( 57 ; 33 ; 16 ; 7 ; 9 ; 17 ; 26 ; 98 ; 54 ; 95 ; 96 , e.g.,) . For example, 98 performed a search for early excesses in the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF) first data release DR ( 97 ; 11 ) using multi-band power-law and Gaussian fits. Their study allowed quantitative classification of bumps and their possible correlation with some light curves and host-galaxy parameters, such as the global host mass. Building on these investigations and recognizing the need for large, homogeneous samples to measure how often early-time excesses occur and their correlations, we here present, to our knowledge, the largest sample to date of SNe Ia with early-time excesses. A central aspect of our analysis is the use of the ZTF DR2 volume-limited subset ( 71 ) to minimize selection biases and support demographic comparisons using uniformly derived light-curve and host-galaxy parameters provided in ZTF DR2. This paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 we describe the ZTF DR2 sample, the volume-limited selection, and the SN/host parameters used in this work. In Section 3 , we present our early-time fitting framework, model comparison strategy, and detection/robustness criteria used to define the bump and no-bump catalogs. In Section 4 , we present the resulting bump and no-bump catalogs and report demographic comparisons between the two populations. In Section 5 , we discuss the implications, limitations, and connections to prior work. Finally, we conclude in Section 6 with a summary of this work and thoughts on future directions. 2 Data 2.1 ZTF DR2 The data used in this work were obtained from the ZTF Data Release 2 (ZTF DR2), as described fully in 71 . This data release consists of gri- band light curves of 3628 spectroscopically-classified SNe Ia up to redshift z\lesssim 0.2 , observed between March 2018 and December 2020 by the ZTF camera on the P48 Schmidt telescope at Mount Palomar Observatory, California, with a 5\sigma depth of 20.5 mag in 30 s exposures. The light curves have different sampling rates, with overall cadences of 2.9, 2.5, and 6 days for the g , r , and i bands, respectively. For further details on the ZTF DR2 and their photometry, we refer the reader to 71 . The ZTF DR2 data were downloaded directly from the dedicated ZTF SN Ia DR2 server 1 1 1 https://ztfcosmo.in2p3.fr/download/data . ZTF DR2 also includes light-curve parameters and host-galaxy properties. All the ZTF DR2light-curve and host-galaxy parameters used in this work are described in Table 1 and references therein, but we provide a summary here: • ZTF DR2 light curves are fit with SALT2 ( 23 ; 24 ;