Benchmarking State-of-the-Art Theory and Empirical Models of Pionless Neutrino-Argon Scattering in GENIE Preprint: FERMILAB-PUB-26-0211-CSAID

Liang Liu, Steven Gardiner, Steven Dytman · 2026

Read Benchmarking State-of-the-Art Theory and Empirical Models of Pionless Neutrino-Argon Scattering in GENIE Preprint: FERMILAB-PUB-26-0211-CSAID by Liang Liu, Steven Gardiner, Steven Dytman (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-14196.txt.

Introduction

Liu, Gardiner and Dytman benchmark theory and empirical models of pionless neutrino-argon scattering inside the GENIE event code. New trials demand better scattering models. The paper tests many interaction models against recent MicroBooNE data of pionless charged-current interactions. GENIE's modular design swaps parts freely, including nucleon form factor parameterizations, quasielastic cross-sections, nuclear ground state treatments and hadronic final-state interactions. The most sophisticated parts are weighed against more empirically driven alternatives.

Catalog record

CREATORLiang Liu, Steven Gardiner, Steven Dytman
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE23846
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.14196

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Benchmarking State-of-the-Art Theory and Empirical Models of Pionless Neutrino-Argon Scattering in GENIE Preprint: FERMILAB-PUB-26-0211-CSAID Liang Liu, Steven Gardiner, Steven Dytman Abstract Upcoming experiments need improved simulations of neutrino scattering. This work uses the popular GENIE event generator to test a variety of neutrino interaction models against recent MicroBooNE measurements of pionless charged-current interactions. The GENIE code can easily interchange model components, including nucleon form factor parameterizations, quasielastic cross-section calculations, treatments of the nuclear ground state and hadronic final-state interactions. Leveraging this software capability in comparisons with MicroBooNE data, the performance of some of GENIE’s most theoretically sophisticated model components is evaluated and contrasted with more empirically-driven alternatives. Neutrino oscillations and cross sections in the GeV region of neutrino energy are a central part of the frontier of high energy physics 13 . Next-generation experiments, e.g., DUNE 4 ; 5 , Hyper-Kamiokande 2 , and JUNO 10 , will seek much improved resolution. Present experiments, e.g., MicroBooNE 12 , SBN 11 , NOvA 17 , and T2K 1 , are providing data to move the field forward. Neutrino interaction simulations, e.g., GENIE 16 ; 15 ; 14 , must provide accurate descriptions of those data. MicroBooNE is currently providing high-quality data for neutrino-argon scattering that challenge existing cross-section calculations. The mean energy of the Booster Neutrino Beam used by MicroBooNE is \sim 800 MeV. The experiment is therefore primarily sensitive to nuclear models and reaction models of quasielastic (QE) and 2 particle–2 hole (2p2h, also commonly labeled meson exchange current (MEC)) processes. Full calculations must include pion production and final state interactions (FSI) of the outgoing hadrons in the residual nucleus. Because the QE process is difficult to isolate using a neutrino beam, relevant data are typically called “QE-like” and usually specify a pionless (CC 0\pi ) final state. GENIE is a leading event generator that provides interaction simulations for most neutrino experiments. As much as possible, modern calculations are included, and it has recently obtained important additions for QE-like interactions. Here, GENIE’s latest models are compared with recent CC 0\pi measurements from MicroBooNE 9 ; 7 ; 8 . The original MicroBooNE papers already featured a variety of generator comparisons, and no model was found that could simultaneously describe all of the data. In this work, more attention is paid to disentangling the impact of different model ingredients. Our focus is on lower-energy data where pion production is a minor contribution. Filali, Munteanu, and Dolan published a similar comparison 29 with MicroBooNE 7 ; 8 and other data using a combination of the NEUT 33 and NuWro 30 event generators. Focusing on transverse kinematic imbalance (TKI) observables 37 , they emphasized the role of nuclear models and had a limited examination of 2p2h and FSI models. Nikolakopoulos et al. 48 also focused on TKI variables and studied nuclear models and FSI with the NEUT, NuWro, and ACHILLES 34 codes. Neither of these studies observed satisfactory agreement with MicroBooNE TKI data for various reasons. Our goal here is to extend these comparisons using GENIE by adding more recent models, doing comparisons within a single program, and broadening the data examined to include a CC 0\pi measurement that allows for multiple detected protons 9 . GENIE has a more flexible structure that features straightforward interchange of model components. This facilitates controlled comparisons in which model ingredients are modified one at a time. Using both popular empirically-driven GENIE components as well as recently-added models with more sophisticated theory, we examine the sensitivity of the MicroBooNE data to modeling of the nuclear ground state, the nucleon axial-vector form factor, and hadronic FSI. The AR23 configuration 1 1 1 AR23 is an abbreviation of the full GENIE model set specifier AR23_20i_00_000. This configuration is available in code versions from v3.4.0 up to the current v3.6.2 release. of GENIE version 3.6.2 is our starting point. It is presently used by both SBN and DUNE. For QE-like processes, AR23 model ingredients include the Nieves et al. QE 46 and SuSAv2 MEC 24 cross-section calculations, a z -expansion axial form factor fit to neutrino-deuterium data 43 ( F_{A}^{\rm Deu} ), and a modified local Fermi gas (LFG) nuclear model inspired by spectral function (SF) approaches 19 ; 18 . Other relevant processes include pion production, but they contribute less than 14% of the MicroBooNE events. This set of models uses the Berger-Sehgal 20 model for resonance processes and a scaled result from Bodek-Yang 22 for nonresonant processes. FSI are modeled with the hA2018 25 model. The GENIE treatment of pion production is kept the same throughout this work. To obtain a good description of the MicroBooNE data, a variety of nuclear effects must be considered. QE processes depend on a detailed description of the neutrino-nucleon vertex in the nuclear medium 13 . The full description of that vertex comes from electron scattering (vector current), and neutrino scattering (adding the axial current). The importance of the nuclear model is well-established and has been examined many times. Relevant dynamics are complicated and a variety of solutions have been proposed. Here, we study two QE/nuclear models. In GENIE, the Nieves et al. model was adapted to use an LFG model for scattering from an off-shell nucleon 14 . Although AR23 adds SF-like modifications to the original LFG model 46 , we omit these in all of our other LFG-based GENIE configurations. The SF 19 ; 18 ; 21 model comes from a description of (e,e^{\prime}\,p) data and has more sophisticated nuclear structure. While the SF model provides a joint distribution of nucleon binding energy and momentum, the Nieves et al. model with LFG uses an empirical nucleon momentum and an empirical constant for the binding energy 45 . In this work, a fit to JLab (e,e^{\prime}p) data 35 ; 36 is used for the SF nuclear model. We consider two treatments of the nucleon axial-vector form factor: F_{A}^{\rm Deu} from AR23 and a result from recent lattice quantum chromodynamics ( F_{A}^{\rm LQCD} ) calculations 44 . An accurate description of the data also requires a model of MEC processes. The SuSAv2 model 41 is used in all new comparisons. Historically, MEC contributions have been hard to separate from axial form factor effects in neutrino measurements. An FSI treatment is also required to describe the MicroBooNE data. In recent years, the default GENIE FSI model has been hA2018 25 . It is a data-based, empirical model that provides a reasonable fit to a variety of hadron-nucleus data. A recent addition to GENIE is an interface with the more theoretical Liège intranuclear-cascade model (INCL v6.33.1) 23 ; 38 ; 28 . This model was developed to describe hadron-nucleus scattering, especially low-energy nucleon-nucleus processes of interest for MicroBooNE. In addition to variations of AR23 in which we change the model components discussed above, we also consider the unaltered AR23 configuration and the MicroBooNE Tune. The MicroBooNE Tune 6 starts with the G18_10a_02_11a model set from GENIE v3.0.6. This configuration is largely similar to AR23, but it uses the Valencia MEC model, a dipole axial form factor, and an LFG nuclear model without SF-like modifications. Magnitude and shape parameters for QE and MEC interactions were then fit to T2K data 3 . The primary fit

Read the complete text