Interference of dynamical arrest, thermodynamic instabilities and energy-scale competition in symmetric binary mixtures

R. Peredo-Ortiz, E. Lázaro-Lázaro, M. Medina-Noyola, L.F. Elizondo-Aguilera · 2026

Read Interference of dynamical arrest, thermodynamic instabilities and energy-scale competition in symmetric binary mixtures by R. Peredo-Ortiz, E. Lázaro-Lázaro, M. Medina-Noyola, L.F. Elizondo-Aguilera (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-14064.txt.

Introduction

Peredo-Ortiz and three co-authors explore how dynamical arrest tangles with phase separation in symmetric binary mixtures. Energy-scale rivalry sets equilibrium phases, yet kinetic barriers often freeze soft-matter mixes into arrested states that plain phase diagrams miss. The paper extends the map of binary systems into zones of thermodynamic instability. Strong cross-attraction kinetically blocks demixing, while rival energy scales yield amorphous states driven by condensation or demixing. A structural order parameter, chi, ties the crossover into one non-equilibrium frame.

Catalog record

CREATORR. Peredo-Ortiz, E. Lázaro-Lázaro, M. Medina-Noyola, L.F. Elizondo-Aguilera
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25361
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.14064

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Interference of dynamical arrest, thermodynamic instabilities and energy-scale competition in symmetric binary mixtures R. Peredo-Ortiz, E. Lázaro-Lázaro, M. Medina-Noyola, L.F. Elizondo-Aguilera Abstract The equilibrium behavior of binary mixtures can be understood through the competition of energy scales, which classifies their corresponding phase diagrams into distinct topological regimes (Types I-IV). However, in many soft-matter mixtures, strong competing interactions and kinetic barriers often promote dynamical arrest, disrupting the formation of equilibrium and metastable states, and thus rendering conventional phase diagrams incomplete. Here we extend the description and classification of binary systems inside regions of thermodynamical instability. Specifically, we discuss how the interplay between two kinds of instabilities and kinetic arrest generates a variety of amorphous states driven by different underlying mechanisms. For strong cross-attraction, for example, dynamical arrest suppresses demixing, whereas in competitive regimes, a mixture may display either condensation-driven or demixing-induced arrested states. The crossover between these regimes can be described by a structural order parameter χ \chi , providing a unified non-equilibrium description that reconciles theoretical predictions with experimentally observed arrested states. The formation of amorphous, dynamically-arrested states in binary mixtures is governed by the interplay of competing physical scales. For instance, in the paradigmatic case of size-asymmetric systems – such as colloid-polymer, or hard-sphere binary mixtures – the physical mechanisms underlying dynamical arrest emerge from competition in length scales. As the size-ratio \delta=\sigma_{A}/\sigma_{B} decreases, the increasing disparity in geometric packing induces a bifurcation of the glass transition (GT), giving rise to the formation of different dynamically-arrested states such as repulsive (caging-driven) glasses, attractive (depletion-driven) glasses, and double glasses, in which the two species may arrest sequentially 39 ; 20 ; 40 ; 50 ; 24 . Thus, in these mixtures, size-asymmetry determines the nature of the resulting amorphous states, which is explicitly governed by steric frustration between its components 2 ; 36 ; 35 ; 10 ; 12 ; 37 ; 23 . In parallel, the description and classification of equilibrium phases in binary mixtures with attractive interactions stand as a foundational achievement of statistical thermodynamics. As first established by van Konynenburg and Scott 48 ; 22 ; 44 – and later formalized by Chen and Forstmann 6 – the topology of the phase diagram is dictated by the energy-scale competition between self-species ( \epsilon_{ii} ) and cross-species ( \epsilon_{ij} , i\neq j ) attraction. Depending on the energy-ratio \alpha=\epsilon_{ij}/\epsilon_{ii} , the landscape of thermodynamic instability is fully determined: high \alpha favors gas-liquid (GL) condensation, while low \alpha favors liquid-liquid (LL) demixing. From a purely thermodynamic point of view, this discussion is well established: the instability temperatures – the spinodal, describing GL condensation ( T_{s} ), and the \lambda -line, for LL demixing ( T_{\lambda} ) – strictly delimit the boundaries of the stable fluid phase 31 ; 17 ; 22 ; 21 ; 44 ; 6 ; 9 ; 8 ; 7 . However, in many soft matter mixtures – such as colloidal suspensions and protein solutions – the thermodynamic phase diagram represents only an idealized limit of a more general non-equilibrium scenario. Experimental evidence 25 ; 45 ; 53 ; 16 ; 49 ; 19 ; 18 , for example, demonstrates that when such mixtures are quenched into their metastable regimes, the thermodynamic driving forces responsible for phase separation and demixing are often hindered by dynamical arrest mechanisms. Consequently, standard equilibrium phase diagrams are insufficient to represent the experimental reality of these arrested mixtures, where the observed “final states” are the result of an intricate competition between instability and kinetic constraints 24 ; 3 ; 1 . To bridge this gap in the characterization of such binary systems, thus, one requires a theoretical framework capable of extending their physical description into the non-equilibrium regime, particularly below the aforementioned instability surfaces. To this end, here we employ the non-equilibrium self-consistent generalized Langevin equation (NESCGLE) theory 27 ; 38 ; 42 ; 34 ; 33 (summarized in Sec. S1 of the Supplementary Material (SM)) to characterize the irreversible evolution of binary mixtures quenched into different metastable domains. Conventional equilibrium theories of dynamic arrest usually treat thermodynamic instability surfaces only as singularities delimiting inaccessible domains in the control-parameters space 13 ; 15 ; 52 . The NESCGLE, in contrast, identifies these surfaces as boundary conditions for the competence of thermodynamical instability, dynamical arrest, and out-of-equilibrium structural relaxation 29 ; 54 ; 5 ; 3 ; 1 . In this work, we employ this framework to characterize symmetric binary mixtures (SBM, \sigma_{A}=\sigma_{B} ) driven by attractive forces, and with different energy ratio \alpha . In particular, we elucidate the resulting thermodynamic instability and dynamical arrest surfaces within the full concentration-density-temperature ( c,\rho ,T) space (see Secs. S2 and S3 of the SM for details). A central finding here is that energy-scale competition generates a rich variety of non-equilibrium amorphous states in SBM, as a result of the interference between GL separation, LL demixing and dynamical arrest transitions, ultimately determined by the energy-ratio \alpha . Hence, just as size asymmetry ( \delta ) partitions the glassy-states diagrams into repulsive, mixed, and attractive glasses domains 50 ; 20 ; 24 , here we show that energy competition ( \alpha ) partitions the SBM diagrams into distinct kinetic regimes. In fact, we developed a “Kinetic Atlas” (detailed in Sec. S3 of the SM) that comprehensively depicts the interplay between thermodynamic instabilities (GL and LL) and different kinetic arrest mechanisms for different \alpha . This explicitly highlights how the complex interplay between the spinodal surface T_{s}(\rho,c) (density-driven instability), the \lambda -surface T_{\lambda}(\rho,c) (concentration-driven instability), and the dynamic arrest surface T_{c}(\rho,c) is dictated by the energy scale ratio \alpha . Importantly, our analysis of the asymptotic localization lengths reveals that the GT surface T_{c} does not end at the intersection with the spinodal surface – nor at the intersection with the surface T_{\lambda}(\rho,c) ) – instead, it penetrates deep into the metastable regions, extending the scenario already found for monodisperse cases 29 ; 54 ; 5 . As detailed in Sec. S4 of the SM (see Fig. S7), this extension of T_{c} manifests itself as a “gel-glass” transition line: a dynamic boundary separating the region of microscopically caged “attractive glasses” from that of mesoscopically arrested “gels” formed via interrupted spinodal decomposition 29 ; 28 ; 30 ; 54 . In turn, this transition line defines the kinetic evolution and final state of a mixture after quenching below the instability surface. Since the complete three-dimensional phase/arrest topology of an SBM is somehow intricate, we shall restrict ourselves here – without loss of generality – to the case of equimolar concentrations ( c=0.5 ), to highlight the most distinctive outcomes introduced by energy competition. For concreteness, in what follows we will consider a SBM described by hard-sphere plus square-well (HSSW) potential specified in Sec. S2 of the SM. Figure 1: The competition between thermodynamic instability and dynamical arrest. (a) Demixing frustration ( \alpha=0.8 ): Strong cross-attraction causes the arrest line T_{c} (blue) to detach from and remain strictly above the demixing instability (green). The system vitrifies into a homogeneous glass, kinetically masking the demixing region. (b) Emergent Demixing ( \alpha=0.5 ): Weaker cross-attraction allows the demixing line to pierce the arrest line, creating a window for gelation. For

Read the complete text