On the impossibility of observational confirmation of black holes

Thiago T. Bergamaschi · 2026

Read On the impossibility of observational confirmation of black holes by Thiago T. Bergamaschi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-13901.txt.

Introduction

Bergamaschi argues that no observation can conclusively confirm a black hole exists. Data from LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA, the Event Horizon Telescope and GRAVITY match Kerr black hole predictions closely, he notes, but they only support black hole candidates and rule out particular rival models. More deeply, general relativity itself sets limits on what observation can establish, so proof stays out of reach.

Catalog record

CREATORThiago T. Bergamaschi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE15816
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.13901

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the impossibility of observational confirmation of black holes Thiago T. Bergamaschi Abstract General relativity has achieved remarkable experimental and observational success. Critically, recent data from the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA, Event Horizon Telescope, and GRAVITY collaborations are often credited with demonstrating the existence of black holes, but in fact they only provide evidence for objects that should be regarded as black hole candidates. While current data are in striking agreement with the predictions for Kerr black holes, they can only rule out specific alternative models of compact objects rather than provide conclusive proof of black holes. More fundamentally, and independent of whether or not black holes exist, general relativity itself imposes limits on what can be observationally established. Essentially, no observational data is sufficient to confirm the existence of black holes. Essay written for the Gravity Research Foundation 2026 Awards for Essays on Gravitation. Introduction In general relativity, black holes are defined as causally disconnected regions, i.e., from which no information can escape to infinitely distant regions. Although this definition is inherently teleological, as it relies on global properties of spacetime Wald1984 , numerical simulations together with the uniqueness theorems Heusler1996 ; Chruściel2012 suggest that physical black holes (e.g., those resulting from the gravitational collapse of a star or compact-object mergers) should be described by the Kerr metric once they reach a stationary configuration. Essentially, observers outside a black hole can obtain information only about physics outside of it, which should consist of a perturbed Kerr spacetime due to gravitational-wave emission and nearby small matter-energy sources. While some have argued that this mathematical definition is unphysical in astrophysical contexts Frolov2014 ; Thorne1986 , black holes have nonetheless catalyzed major advancements in theoretical physics over the past fifty years, serving as a conceptual laboratory for the interplay of gravitation, thermodynamics, and quantum theory (see, e.g., Wald2001 ; Parker2009 ; Bergamaschi2026 ). Over the past decade, black holes have entered the observational spotlight, largely due to the efforts of the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA (see, e.g., Abbott2016 ; Abbott2018 ; Abac2025 ), Event Horizon Telescope (see, e.g., EHT2019 ), and GRAVITY collaborations (see, e.g., GRAVITY2018 ), which have analyzed gravitational and electromagnetic data with unprecedented precision. These observations have opened extraordinary prospects for testing fundamental physics, but it is imperative to understand what such data can probe, falsify, and confirm . This distinction is particularly salient for black holes because, while general relativity imposes no theoretical limit on how close one may approach a black hole’s boundary (i.e., the event horizon) and still communicate with the rest of the universe, practical observational thresholds quickly become relevant. The central challenge lies in distinguishing a black hole from an ultracompact object. When an ultracompact object is characterized by a sufficiently small closeness (or cutoff) parameter 1 1 1 This parameter is a measure of how “close” a compact object is to the Kerr black hole radius Wald1984 , r_{+} , such that r=r_{+}(1+\epsilon) is the object’s radius Cardoso2017 . For spherically symmetric objects r_{+}=r_{s} , where r_{s} is the Schwarzschild radius. , \epsilon , any measurable departures from the black hole geometry become inaccessible to a distant observer within a finite observation window 2 2 2 We consider infinite-time observations unphysical. . As in Popper’s black swan analogy Popper1959 , a single observation may rule out a specific model of an exotic compact object, yet no observational data is sufficient to confirm the existence of black holes . In this essay, we argue that the prevailing view that black holes have been definitely found in various astrophysical systems is epistemologically problematic. While we possess compelling black hole candidates in quasars, binary systems, and galactic nuclei, these remain exactly that: candidates. Observations may provide evidence consistent with black hole behavior, but they do not constitute confirmation of their existence. Certainly, black holes play an important role in several theoretical issues, and probing their properties is essential. Nonetheless, attention to what the data can truly reveal is critical to avoid an illusion of certainty and maintain scientific rigor. Critically, this issue is distinct from the question of whether black holes, as defined by general relativity, exist in our universe; it concerns the fundamental constraints general relativity places on what can be observationally confirmed. Gravitational waves and ringdown Even before the detection of gravitational waves, the literature often suggested that such observations would provide definitive proof of black hole existence. For example, ( Berti2009 , § 1) states: “While electromagnetic observations are already providing us with strong evidence of the astrophysical reality of black holes, gravitational wave observations will incontrovertibly show if these compact objects are indeed rotating (Kerr) black holes…” [Italics added] Indeed, the first paper on gravitational wave detection adamantly asserted ( Abbott2016 , § VI) : “GW150914 demonstrates the existence of stellar-mass black holes more massive than \simeq 25\;M_{\odot} , and establishes that binary black holes can form in nature and merge within a Hubble time.” Statements of this form are repeated for other events, e.g., GW170104 ( Abbott2018 , § I) : “Detailed analyses demonstrate that GW170104 arrived at Hanford \sim 3 ms before Livingston, and originated from the coalescence of two stellar-mass black holes…” The use of the word “demonstrate” in these contexts is epistemologically problematic; these compact coalescence events can, at most, serve as a profound investigation of merging binaries, rather than provide observational confirmation of black holes. The primary argument supporting the interpretation that the result of compact coalescence is a black hole follows from the ringdown signal, i.e., the signature gravitational-wave behavior characterized by damped sinusoids arising from the dynamics of the post-merger remnant (see, e.g., Berti2009 ; Berti2025 for reviews). Namely, one finds that the gravitational-wave signal coincides with the quasinormal modes of a Kerr black hole, i.e., the characteristic oscillations of spacetime outside a perturbed Kerr black hole. Physically, this corresponds to the black hole reaching a stationary configuration. A notorious difference between the quasinormal modes of a black hole and an extremely compact object is that, due to the presence of a surface on the latter, one expects echoes in the ringdown waveform. Naturally, one is interested in quantifying how subtle such a difference is. Notably, one finds that all black hole quasinormal data can be mimicked by an ultracompact object with an arbitrarily small closeness parameter Cardoso2016 ; Cardoso2017 . For a distant observer restricted to a finite observation window, the measurable differences between a black hole and a sufficiently compact horizonless model become inaccessible. Even if an observer could probe the near-horizon regime, the late-time modes of such objects typically carry insufficient energy to be distinguishable from the noise floor. Consequently, while the ringdown waveform is remarkably consistent with the Kerr hypothesis, it reinforces the theory’s predictive power rather than confirming the object’s identity. Any compact object possessing a light ring will exhibit a similar ringdown stage; thus, the data provide evidence for the existence of light rings, not necessarily event horizons. Although light rings have been argued to be proxy evidence for black holes based on nonlinear stability arguments for ultracompact objects Cardoso2014 , this does not alter the fundamental conclusion. Even if a black hole appears to be the only viable solution to simultaneously explain all current

Read the complete text