Uniqueness of synchronized stationary equilibria in the Kuramoto mean field game
Sebastian Munoz · 2026
Read Uniqueness of synchronized stationary equilibria in the Kuramoto mean field game by Sebastian Munoz (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-13783.txt.
Introduction
Sebastian Munoz proves oneness of synced still rests in the Kuramoto mean field game. The still game models a crowd of phase swingers forming synced Nash rests above a key coupling strength. He proves the synced branch is one smooth family of Nash rests rising from the uniform state at the split. Both follow from the main key result that the scalar self-match map is strictly concave, closing a guess of Carmona, Cormier and Soner.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sebastian Munoz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54575 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.13783
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Uniqueness of synchronized stationary equilibria in the Kuramoto mean field game Sebastian Munoz Abstract . The stationary Kuramoto mean field game models a population of phase oscillators that form synchronized Nash equilibria above a critical interaction strength. We prove that the synchronized branch is a unique smooth family of Nash equilibria emerging from the uniform state at the bifurcation: at each supercritical interaction strength the synchronized equilibrium is unique up to rotation of the torus, and converges smoothly to the uniform distribution as the interaction parameter decreases to the critical threshold. Both follow from our main technical result: the scalar self-consistency map is strictly concave, settling a conjecture of [ CCS23 ] . The proof decomposes the second derivative of the self-consistency map into two sign-indefinite moments of the equilibrium—a cubic moment and a gradient moment—and controls their signs through sharp shape estimates for the value function, a pointwise geometric-mean monotonicity that determines the sign of the cubic moment via a cosine-skewness inequality, and a reflection argument combined with a correlation inequality for the gradient moment. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 91A16, 35Q89, 49N80, 35B32, 35J60, 60H30 1. Introduction In a non-monotone mean field game, multiple nontrivial Nash equilibria can a priori coexist, and a central structural question is whether a given phase transition selects a unique branch organized by the model parameters. We resolve this question for the Kuramoto mean field game studied by Carmona, Cormier, and Soner [ CCS23 ] , a mean field game model of phase synchronization. The underlying Kuramoto model [ Kur75 , Str00 , ABPVS05 ] is a paradigm of phase-transition synchronization: a population of coupled phase oscillators that remains incoherent below a critical coupling strength and self-organizes into a synchronized state above that threshold. In the classical mean-field limit, where the population evolves according to a prescribed McKean–Vlasov dynamics, the phase transition and the stability of the incoherent state are by now well understood at the level of both the nonlinear Fokker–Planck equation [ GPP12 ] and the fluctuations of the underlying interacting particle system [ BGP14 ] . A mean field game [ LL07 , HMC06 , CD18 ] version of the model, in which each oscillator chooses its dynamics to minimize a cost rather than following a prescribed law of motion, was studied formally in [ YMMS12 ] and used in [ CG20 ] for an analysis of jet-lag recovery. Related bifurcation-theoretic and global techniques for non-monotone mean field games appear in [ Cir19 ] . The first rigorous analysis of the resulting stationary mean field game was given in [ CCS23 ] , where it was shown that the synchronization phase transition survives in the game-theoretic setting as a bifurcation of the Nash equilibria, with full synchronization in the strong-coupling limit \kappa\to\infty . This framework has since been extended to heterogeneous populations with random intrinsic frequencies [ CCS25 ] , and adapted in [ HS25 ] to a finite-state synchronization mean field game exhibiting the same phase-transition phenomenology. In the model we study, the representative oscillator is a controlled diffusion on the torus \mathbb{T}:=\mathbb{R}/2\pi\mathbb{Z} , dX_{t}=\alpha_{t}\,dt+\sigma\,dB_{t}, in which the agent chooses the drift \alpha to minimize the discounted cost J(\alpha):=\mathbb{E}\!\left[\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-\beta t}\Bigl(\kappa\,c(X_{t},\mu_{t})+\tfrac{1}{2}\alpha_{t}^{2}\Bigr)dt\right] against the prevailing population distribution \mu_{t}\in\mathcal{P}(\mathbb{T}) . Here \beta>0 is the discount rate, \sigma>0 the noise level, \kappa>0 the interaction strength, and c(\theta,\mu):=\int_{\mathbb{T}}2\sin^{2}\!\tfrac{\theta-\theta^{\prime}}{2}\,\mu(d\theta^{\prime})=1-\mu\bigl(\cos(\theta-\cdot)\bigr) is the classical Kuramoto coupling, which penalizes misalignment of the agent’s phase with the population. For a prescribed time-dependent population flow (\mu_{t})_{t\geq 0} , let X^{t,x,\alpha} denote the controlled process started from x at time t , and define the value function \Phi(t,x):=\inf_{\alpha}\mathbb{E}\!\left[\int_{t}^{\infty}e^{-\beta(s-t)}\Bigl(\kappa\,c(X_{s}^{t,x,\alpha},\mu_{s})+\tfrac{1}{2}\alpha_{s}^{2}\Bigr)ds\right], where dX_{s}^{t,x,\alpha}=\alpha_{s}\,ds+\sigma\,dB_{s} and X_{t}^{t,x,\alpha}=x . Dynamic programming gives the feedback \alpha_{s}^{*}=-\Phi_{x}(s,X_{s}) and the Hamilton–Jacobi–Bellman (HJB) equation -\Phi_{t}+\beta\Phi-\frac{\sigma^{2}}{2}\Phi_{xx}+\tfrac{1}{2}\Phi_{x}^{2}=\kappa\,c(x,\mu_{t}). A Nash equilibrium is a population flow (\mu_{t})_{t\geq 0} such that, when the representative oscillator uses this optimal feedback, the law of the optimally controlled state is exactly the prescribed population flow: \mathcal{L}(X_{t}^{*})=\mu_{t} for all t\geq 0 . The full time-dependent equilibrium problem is therefore a forward–backward fixed point: the HJB equation couples \Phi at time t to the future of (\mu_{s})_{s\geq t} , while the controlled law \mathcal{L}(X_{t}^{*}) propagates forward in t . In this paper we focus on stationary equilibria, of the form \mu_{t}\equiv\mu . These are the game-theoretic analogue of the incoherent and synchronized phases of the classical Kuramoto model: they describe possible long-run organized states of the population, and the phase transition observed in [ CCS23 ] occurs through a bifurcation of such stationary Nash equilibria. Uniqueness and continuity of the stationary synchronized branch are thus basic structural questions, prior to any analysis of stability or non-stationary selection. In the stationary case the infinite-horizon control problem is time-homogeneous, so \Phi(t,x)=\phi(x) , where \phi\in C^{\infty}(\mathbb{T}) solves the stationary HJB equation \beta\phi-\frac{\sigma^{2}}{2}\phi_{xx}+\tfrac{1}{2}\phi_{x}^{2}=\kappa\,c(\cdot,\mu), and the optimal feedback is \alpha_{t}^{*}=-\phi_{x}(X_{t}) . The stationary equilibrium condition is that \mu be invariant for the optimal diffusion dX_{t}=-\phi_{x}(X_{t})\,dt+\sigma\,dB_{t} , meaning that X_{0}\sim\mu implies X_{t}\sim\mu for all t\geq 0 . This invariant law has density \mu(dx)\propto\exp(-2\phi(x)/\sigma^{2})\,dx\qquad\text{on }\mathbb{T}. The interaction c is rotation-invariant, so any rotation of an equilibrium is itself an equilibrium. Rotating so that \mu(\sin)=0 and \mu(\cos)\geq 0 (with \mu(\cos)>0 in the synchronized case), and absorbing the constant \kappa on the right-hand side of the HJB into \phi , the self-consistency condition reduces to (1) \mu=\mu^{\kappa\,\mu(\cos)}, where, for each \gamma\geq 0 , \mu^{\gamma} is the probability measure on \mathbb{T} defined analogously from \phi^{\gamma}\in C^{\infty}(\mathbb{T}) , the unique smooth solution of (2) \beta\phi^{\gamma}-\frac{\sigma^{2}}{2}\phi^{\gamma}_{xx}+\tfrac{1}{2}(\phi^{\gamma}_{x})^{2}=-\gamma\cos x,\qquad x\in\mathbb{T}. With this normalization, ( 1 ) is the fixed-point equation \gamma=F_{\kappa}(\gamma) on [0,\infty) for the scalar self-consistency map F_{\kappa}(\gamma):=\kappa\,\mu^{\gamma}(\cos), whose value at the order parameter \gamma=\kappa\mu(\cos) measures the population-averaged force pulling each agent toward synchrony. The choice \gamma=0 recovers the uniform measure, which is therefore a stationary equilibrium for every \kappa . We refer to non-uniform stationary equilibria as synchronized . A short calculation, carried out in Section 2 , gives F_{\kappa}(0)=0 , F_{\kappa}^{\prime}(0)=\kappa/\kappa_{c} , and |F_{\kappa}|\leq\kappa , where the critical interaction parameter is \kappa_{c}:=\beta\sigma^{2}+\frac{\sigma^{4}}{2}. In [ CCS23 ] it is shown that a synchronized stationary equilibrium exists for every \kappa>\kappa_{c} , and that any sequence of such equilibria converges up to rotation to \delta_{0} (full synchronization) as \kappa\to\infty . In the subcritical regime, global attraction of the uniform state is established in the smaller weak-interaction regime \kappa<\beta\sigma^{2}/4 , while for all \kappa<\kappa_{c} , they construct equilibrium flows, starting from initial laws sufficiently close to the uniform distribution, that converge exponentially to the uniform state. In the numerical experiments of [ CCS23 ] , F_{\kappa} was always concave and the synchronized equilibrium was unique up to rotation. On this basis it was conjectured [ CCS23 , Rem. 7.4] that F_{\kappa} is concave on [0,\infty) for every \beta,\sigma,\kappa>0 . Two structural consequences sought there follow at once from this concavity: the synchronized equilibrium would be unique up to rotation, and would converge to the uniform measure at the bifurcation \kappa=\kappa_{c} . The first partial result toward this conjecture was obtained by Cesaroni and Cirant [ CC24 ] , who work with a closely related model: the ergodic Kuramoto mean field game, in which the discount factor \beta>0 of ( 2 ) is replaced by an ergodic constant determined together with the value function and the equilibrium measure.