ScioMind : Cognitively Grounded Multi-Agent Social Simulation with Anchoring-Based Belief Dynamics and Dynamic Profiles

Yitian YangThe University of Sydney [email protected], Yiqun DuanMeta [email protected], Linghan HuangThe University of Sydney [email protected], Yiqi ZhuThe University of Sydney [email protected], Francesco BailoThe University of Sydney [email protected], Chunmeizi SuThe University of Sydney [email protected], Huaming ChenThe University of Sydney [email protected] · 2026

Read ScioMind : Cognitively Grounded Multi-Agent Social Simulation with Anchoring-Based Belief Dynamics and Dynamic Profiles by Yitian YangThe University of Sydney [email protected], Yiqun DuanMeta [email protected], Linghan HuangThe University of Sydney [email protected], Yiqi ZhuThe University of Sydney [email protected], Francesco BailoThe University of Sydney [email protected], Chunmeizi SuThe University of Sydney [email protected], Huaming ChenThe University of Sydney [email protected] (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-13725.txt.

Introduction

Yitian Yang and six colleagues introduce ScioMind, a mind-based multi-agent social sim frame mixing opinion flows with language-model reasoning. ScioMind joins a memory-tied belief update rule tuning sway via trait-set tie strength. It adds layered memory for lasting belief growth, and dynamic cards from corpus-grounded lookup. Across case studies from a real-world policy debate, the parts improve realism. Dynamic cards raise opinion spread, memory and review cut wobbly swings, and ties yield lasting belief paths matching party mind-study patterns.

Catalog record

CREATORYitian YangThe University of Sydney [email protected], Yiqun DuanMeta [email protected], Linghan HuangThe University of Sydney [email protected], Yiqi ZhuThe University of Sydney [email protected], Francesco BailoThe University of Sydney [email protected], Chunmeizi SuThe University of Sydney [email protected], Huaming ChenThe University of Sydney [email protected]
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66821
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.13725

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

ScioMind : Cognitively Grounded Multi-Agent Social Simulation with Anchoring-Based Belief Dynamics and Dynamic Profiles Yitian YangThe University of Sydney [email protected], Yiqun DuanMeta [email protected], Linghan HuangThe University of Sydney [email protected], Yiqi ZhuThe University of Sydney [email protected], Francesco BailoThe University of Sydney [email protected], Chunmeizi SuThe University of Sydney [email protected], Huaming ChenThe University of Sydney [email protected] Abstract Large language model (LLM)-based multi-agent simulation offers a powerful testbed for studying social opinion dynamics. Yet current approaches often adopt two contrasting methods: either relying on fixed update rules with limited cognitive grounding or delegating belief change largely to unconstrained LLM interaction. We introduce ScioMind , a cognitively grounded simulation framework that bridges these paradigms by combining structured opinion dynamics with LLM-based agent reasoning. ScioMind integrates three key components: 1) a memory-anchored belief update rule that modulates susceptibility to influence via personality-conditioned anchoring strength; 2) a hierarchical memory architecture that supports persistent, experience-driven belief formation; and 3) dynamic agent profiles derived from a corpus-grounded retrieval pipeline, enabling heterogeneous personalities, rationales, and evolving internal states. We evaluate ScioMind on multiple case studies in a real-world policy debate scenario. Across metrics including polarisation, diversity, extremization, and trajectory stability, the proposed components consistently yield improvements in behavioural realism. In particular, dynamic profiles increase opinion diversity, memory and reflection reduce unstable oscillation, and anchoring induces persistent belief trajectories that better align with patterns reported in political psychology. These results suggest that our cognitively grounded design provides a novel solution to LLM-based social simulation that improves both stable and behavioural realism. 1 Introduction In computational social science, understanding how beliefs form, persist, and evolve in social networks remains a central challenge. Classical agent-based models (ABMs) such as the DeGroot consensus model ( 6 ) , bounded confidence models ( 5 ; 10 ) , and Axelrod’s culture dissemination model ( 3 ) , have provided foundational insights into opinion dynamics. However, these models generally rely on simplified update rules, often based on weighted averaging of scalar opinions, which limits their ability to capture the nuanced reasoning process, persuasive interactions, and belief updating process that characterize real human belief formation. The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has opened new possibilities for simulating opinion evolution in social systems. Generative Agents ( 19 ) demonstrated that memory and reflection can support believable social behaviour, while subsequent systems,including S 3 ( 8 ) , AgentSociety ( 20 ) , and OASIS ( 23 ) , have extended LLM-based social simulation to larger populations. Compared with traditional ABMs, these approaches improve the expressiveness and interpretability of how opinions and beliefs evolve through interaction. However, they typically treat belief updating as an emergent outcome of open-ended interaction, which introduces several limitations. First, these methods lack explicit and structured representations of belief influence dynamics, making it difficult to identify what drives an agent’s opinion update. Second, they do not incorporate cognitively grounded mechanisms of resistance to change. Third, agent diversity is often limited to static demographic or role-based descriptions, rather than dynamically evolving internal traits, rationales and memories. Finally, on controversial topics, these systems often exhibit over-smoothing, in which agents normally converge too quickly toward neutral or consensual positions, failing to preserve the persistent disagreement and bounded polarisation commonly observed in real human debates. Our work is motivated by the anchoring effect , a well-established concept in cognitive psychology and opinion change research, whereby judgments are disproportionately shaped by initial reference points and adjusted only insufficiently thereafter ( 22 ) . Recent work suggests that this mechanism is particularly salient in political preference formation, where the status quo can act as a cognitive anchor that resists change even under persuasive pressure ( 1 ) . Importantly, these effects are stronger when anchors are personally relevant , such as existing policy positions, suggesting that belief persistence arises not from arbitrary inertia but from accumulated experience. This observation directly motivates our core design of a memory-anchored belief update mechanism, where each agent’s resistance to opinion change is shaped by experience-based anchors maintained in long-term memory. Contributions. We introduce ScioMind , a cognitively grounded framework for LLM-based social simulation with four main contributions: 1. Anchoring-based belief dynamics (§ 3.1 ): We model belief updating as a memory-anchored influence process, where agents revise opinions related to topic-specific anchors derived from memory. Anchoring strength is mapped from agents’ personality traits, introducing cognitively grounded heterogeneity in persuadability. 2. Cognitive memory architecture (§ 3.2 ): We design a four-layer memory system comprising episodic, semantic, reflection, and working memory, which supports the formation and retrieval of belief anchors and explicitly links memory mechanisms to belief dynamics. 3. Dynamic agent profiles (§ ): We replace static demographic profiles with narrative identities retrieved from a social-media-grounded corpus, combined with group-conditioned OCEAN priors and rationale clusters to produce diverse agents with evloving and internally grounded profiles. 4. Human-in-the-loop simulation design and evaluation : We incorporate domain expert feedback to calibrate anchoring strength and bounded confidence, using observed patterns such as polarisation, clustering, and convergence to iteratively improve the simulation’s behavioural realism and interpretability. We evaluate these contributions through case studies on real-world policy debate scenarios, assessing both component effects and the extent to which the agents’ behaviours align with human patterns. 2 Related Work Classical opinion dynamics. Classical opinion-dynamics research studies how individual beliefs evolve through repeated social interaction on a network, typically using explicit update rules over low-dimensional opinion states. One foundational influence dynamic model is the DeGroot model ( 6 ) , which formalizes opinion formation as iterative weighted averaging. Building on this, the Friedkin–Johnsen model ( 7 ) introduces stubbornness , whereby agents retain partial attachment to their initial opinions, providing a mathematical precursor to our anchoring formulation. Bounded confidence models ( 5 ; 10 ) further show that how polarisation can emerge through selective interaction. Despite mathematically tractable, these models operate over scalar opinions states and offer limited ability to capture the argumentative richness involved in human belief formation. LLM-based social simulation. The emergence of LLMs has made social simulation a promising direction for modelling complex human behavior. Compared with traditional agent-based modelling, LLM-based simulations enable more behaviourally realistic agents, providing interpretable rationales for agents’ actions beyond numerical update rules, and supporting reproducible experimental settings. 19 introduces generative agents with observation–reflection–planning loops. S 3 ( 8 ) models social networks with emotion tracking. OASIS ( 23 ) scales simulations to one million agents. AgentSociety ( 20 ) examines polarisation with LLM agents, while MOSAIC ( 16 ) focuses on simulating belief dynamics in misinformation communication. 24 shows that LLM agents operating under DeGroot protocols exhibit convergence patterns consistent with graph-theoretic predictions, albeit with topic-dependent biases. 18 further investigates the dynamics of social influence. However, existing LLM-based social simulation frameworks still lack an explicit, cognitively grounded account of how beliefs persist and update through social interaction, particularly in ways shaped by opinion dynamics, diverse personality, and prior experience. Table 1 positions ScioMind relative to prior work across six dimensions. Our framework provides a novel solution to enable more behaviourally grounded and structurally explicit simulations of social opinion dynamics. Table 1: Comparison of LLM-based social simulation systems. Belief : structured belief states; Mem. : memory mechanism; Dyn. Prof. : dynamic agent profiles; Refl. : reflection mechanism;

Read the complete text