The Very Late Time Afterglow of GW170817 Favors a Wobbling Jet

Hao Wang, Ore Gottlieb, Aman Katira, Muskan Yadav, Lei Lei, Yi-Zhong Fan, Da-Ming Wei · 2026

Read The Very Late Time Afterglow of GW170817 Favors a Wobbling Jet by Hao Wang, Ore Gottlieb, Aman Katira, Muskan Yadav, Lei Lei, Yi-Zhong Fan, Da-Ming Wei (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-13719.txt.

Introduction

Hao Wang and six colleagues argue the very late-time glow of GW170817 favours a wobbling jet over a narrow shaped jet. The slow decay of the very late-time glow defies narrow jet guesses. A tilted ring-shaped jet thus explains the multi-signal data without extra parts. Bayes study favours a ring-shaped jet over a narrow jet at 4.8 sigma, giving a wobbling angle near 27 degrees. Such a large angle points to big disk tilt, maybe from disk-falling gas mixing or uneven angular spin loss.

Catalog record

CREATORHao Wang, Ore Gottlieb, Aman Katira, Muskan Yadav, Lei Lei, Yi-Zhong Fan, Da-Ming Wei
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31138
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.13719

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Very Late Time Afterglow of GW170817 Favors a Wobbling Jet Hao Wang, Ore Gottlieb, Aman Katira, Muskan Yadav, Lei Lei, Yi-Zhong Fan, Da-Ming Wei Abstract GW170817 remains the only binary neutron star merger detected through multimessenger emission. Its afterglow has been monitored for nearly a decade, offering an unprecedented opportunity to probe the properties of the outflow. The shallow decay of the very late-time afterglow challenges the prediction of a collimated structured jet. Motivated by recent general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic simulations, we propose that the GW170817 afterglow is powered by a wobbling jet that drags a ring on the sky. This structure predicts a post-break decay rate shallower than that of a collimated jet, as observers will see a progressively longer emitting arc after the break. A misaligned ring-shaped jet can therefore self-consistently explain the multimessenger data without invoking any extra component. Through a Bayesian analysis of the multimessenger data, we find a ring-shaped jet is favored over a collimated jet at a significance level of 4.8 σ \sigma . Our results imply a wobbling angle of ∼ 27 ∘ \sim 27^{\circ} . Such a large angle points to a significant disk tilt, potentially arising from disk-infalling gas interaction or asymmetric angular momentum ejection. Similar shallow decays have also been found in other GRB afterglows, raising the possibility that wobbling jets are common among GRBs. Introduction. —GW170817 is the only binary neutron star (BNS) merger event in which gravitational waves, Gamma-ray burst (i.e., GRB 170817A), and kilonova have been simultaneously detected 3 ; 4 ; 2 . GRB 170817A is also the first one evidently observed from a misaligned direction 51 ; 18 ; 32 ; 36 . In this scenario, the jet structure becomes important, because its afterglow is initially dominated by the jet “wing” component outside the core ( 27 ; 31 ) . A collimated structured jet has successfully explained the rising phase of the afterglow as well as the apparent superluminal motion measured by Very Long Baseline Interferometry 37 ; 12 ; 38 . It also provides an independent constraint on the jet inclination angle, which helps break down the degeneracies in the gravitational wave parameter estimation, and enhances the standard siren measurement of the Hubble constant 1 ; 25 ; 55 . This remarkable event has been continuously monitored in multiple wavebands for nearly a decade ( 22 ; 51 ; 6 ; 5 ; 50 ; 52 ; 53 ; 7 ; 39 ; 49 ; 8 ; 29 ) , making it one of the few GRBs with well-measured afterglow emission lasting \geq 5 years after the burst, providing an unprecedented opportunity to test jet models. Latest studies have shown that a collimated and structured jet (hereafter a collimated jet) has difficulty explaining the very late time afterglow (e.g., 13 ; 54 ; 29 ). In the standard afterglow model, a jet will be fully visible and start to spread sideways after the jet break 43 , leading to a temporal decay F_{\nu}\propto t^{-p} , where p>2 is the electron power index. A broken power-law fitting to the GW170817 afterglow shows that the temporal decay after the peak follows t^{-\alpha} where \alpha\lesssim 1.8 29 . This decline rate is much shallower than the prediction and is only possible for either a very wide jet or a very shallow wing 14 . On the other hand, a collimated jet with a steep wing is strongly supported by the observation of the apparent superluminal motion 38 . This inconsistency challenges our understanding of the jet structure and the sideways spreading process. Recent jet-launching general-relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) simulations provide clues to this problem. In both collapsar and neutron star black hole (NSBH) merger simulations 16 ; 15 ; 23 , the accretion disk around the black hole is found to be tilted. In collapsars it originates from the interaction between the infalling gas and the disk, while in binary mergers it comes from asymmetric angular momentum ejection. As a result, the jet associated with a tilted disk wobbles. In this work, we propose that accretion disks in BNS mergers are also tilted as in collapsars and NSBH mergers, though a self-consistent jet-launching GRMHD simulation in a BNS merger remains a subject for future studies. Depending on the intermittency of the central engine, a wobbling jet may drag a “band” on the sky or break into many jet elements. This complicated outflow structure is expected to produce distinct afterglow signatures compared to a collimated jet, since many outflow components are inevitably misaligned. Likewise, 19 recently proposed that the multiple-jet scenario may be responsible for the rebrightening seen in the afterglow of Einstein Probe (EP) transients 19 . In this letter, we propose that the GW170817 afterglow is produced by the misaligned observation of a wobbling jet that drags a continuous band in the sky. To build a toy model, we approximate it using a ring-shaped jet structure. This structure leads to a distinct post-jet break decay since observers will see a progressively longer “arc” of the jet as the beaming angle increases, resulting in a shallow temporal decay. We find that the analytic decaying rate agrees well with the observations. Meanwhile, the superluminal motion is not affected as long as the “wing” structure surrounding the ring remains similar to that of a collimated jet. Therefore, this model provides a compelling explanation for the multimessenger data as it does not invoke any additional components or physical processes beyond the standard GRB afterglow. The afterglow of a wobbling jet. —Jet precession is widespread across many astrophysical systems in the Universe, such as supermassive black holes 9 and tidal disruption events. It has long been proposed that GRB jets have precession as well 41 ; 42 ; 33 ; 48 . Indeed, first-principle collapsar and NSBH merger simulations have found that GRB jets wobble during their launch 16 ; 15 ; 23 . Unlike other jet systems, these simulations show that the wobbling of the GRB jet is mainly caused by the disk tilt due to the interaction between the accretion disk and the infalling gas. The wobbling jet may yield different observational signatures, depending on the relation between the wobbling angle \theta_{\rm wo} , the jet half-opening angle \theta_{c} , and the intermittency of the central engine. i) If the wobbling angle is smaller than the jet half-opening angle, \theta_{\rm wo}<\theta_{c} , the wobbling motion is not important, and the jet structure resembles a collimated jet. ii) If the wobbling angle is larger than the opening angle but the central engine is highly intermittent, the jet will break into many jet elements launched in different directions (see 19 ). The jet structure can then be approximated by multiple independent jets. iii) If the central engine activity is continuous relative to the baryon mixing timescale, the jet will drag a band in the sphere. Figure 1 illustrates the last scenario. The typical size of the band depends on the wobbling angle \theta_{\rm wo} , and the thickness of the band depends on the half-opening angle \theta_{c} of the initially launched jet. An observer is considered aligned or misaligned depending on whether the line of sight points to the band. In practice,

Read the complete text