Causal Discovery via Statistical Power (CDSP)
Shreya Prakash, Fan Xia, Elena A. Erosheva · 2026
Read Causal Discovery via Statistical Power (CDSP) by Shreya Prakash, Fan Xia, Elena A. Erosheva (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-13550.txt.
Introduction
Shreya Prakash, Fan Xia and Elena Erosheva present Causal Discovery via Statistical Power, linking causal direction calls to statistical power. Working causal discovery methods use structural asymmetries but rest on strong model assumptions and give few uncertainty tools. CDSP treats two-way data, using power-like and effect-size quantities to judge when data favour one direction. Its effect-size asymmetry assumption marks when correct detection beats reverse error. Tests on 100 cause-effect pairs show it cuts false discovery rates by about 18 percent against a common method.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shreya Prakash, Fan Xia, Elena A. Erosheva |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 89132 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.13550
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Causal Discovery via Statistical Power (CDSP) Shreya Prakash, Fan Xia, Elena A. Erosheva Abstract Causal discovery methods aim to infer causal direction from observational data. Functional causal discovery approaches use structural asymmetries to identify causal directionality but rely on strong modeling assumptions and provide limited tools for uncertainty quantification. We introduce Causal Discovery via Statistical Power (CDSP), a statistical inference framework that connects causal direction estimation with statistical power and enables uncertainty quantification. Considering the foundational setting of bivariate observational data, we show how quantities analogous to statistical power and effect size can be used in causal discovery to determine when data contain sufficient information to favor one direction over the other. We introduce the effect-size asymmetry assumption that characterizes when the probability of correctly detecting the causal direction (i.e., the power of causal discovery) exceeds that of incorrectly favoring the reverse direction. We show that the effect-size asymmetry assumption can be used for causal direction estimation with uncertainty quantification. Simulations show that CDSP direction estimation is robust to mild and moderate model misspecifications. Real data analyses on 100 cause–effect benchmark pairs further demonstrate that CDSP reduces false discovery rates by approximately 18% relative to a commonly used existing method. † † footnotetext: Preprint. 1 Introduction Inferring causal relationships from observational data is a central problem across many scientific disciplines ( 10 ; 44 ; 31 ; 21 ; 30 ; 15 ; 17 ; 9 ) . While causal effects can be established through randomized or interventional studies, such experiments are often expensive, time-consuming, or infeasible. As a result, there is substantial interest in methods that infer causal structure directly from observational data. Functional causal discovery uses structural assumptions on the functional form to identify the causal direction. Functional causal discovery methods have been extensively studied in both bivariate and multivariate settings ( 35 ; 14 ; 28 ; 43 ) and widely applied in practice ( 30 ; 26 ; 18 ; 15 ; 36 ) . In this paper, we focus on bivariate functional causal discovery that reduces to determining the causal direction between two variables by fitting regressions in both directions. The bivariate setting is important because it is the simplest setting in which causal discovery identifiability mechanisms can be studied. It can also be considered a building block for more complex multivariate settings. Bivariate causal discovery methods are often evaluated on benchmark datasets consisting of cause–effect pairs ( 25 ) . In a bivariate setting, functional causal models posit that the data-generating process for two random variables X and Y and the true causal direction X\rightarrow Y can be written as Y=f(X,\eta), (1) where \eta is a noise term that is independent of X and f\in\mathcal{F} is a function belonging to a specified model class. Functional causal discovery methods rely on strong identifiability assumptions to identify the causal direction from observational data ( 34 ; 14 ) . Assumptions A1–A5 (Assumptions for Identifiability) . In the bivariate setting, the identifiability assumptions are as follows: (A1) The data-generating mechanism is correctly specified within the assumed functional model class. (A2) X and Y have an acyclic relationship. (A3) X and Y are unconfounded, i.e., they share no common causes. (A4) The data are independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.). (A5) The data-generating process does not fall into the few unidentifiable cases characterized by 43 ; for example, when the relationship between X and Y is linear and all variables are Gaussian. Under Assumptions A1–A5 , the independence between cause variable X and noise variable \eta holds only in the true direction and fails in the reverse direction. This asymmetry enables identification of a unique causal direction from observational data. When Assumptions A1–A5 hold, the causal direction can be identified; however, impacts of assumption violations on traditional causal discovery approaches are unclear. In addition, most existing causal discovery methods do not provide statistical guarantees—that is, statistical inference for the estimated direction. In practice, assumption violations such as model misspecification due to deviations from the assumed functional form are often unavoidable. This has been widely recognized; for example, in linear regression, the consequences of assumption violations have been extensively studied, motivating the use of diagnostic tools and uncertainty quantification to assess model fit and guide interpretation ( 40 ; 22 ) . In contrast, current work on uncertainty quantification in functional causal discovery has been limited. It can be broadly divided into two categories: resampling-based procedures that assess stability of estimated causal structures and inferential approaches based on statistical tests. Bootstrap-based methods extend causal discovery algorithms by repeatedly refitting models on resampled datasets to assess stability of inferred causal orderings ( 20 ; 37 ) ; however, as we will see in this paper, resulting reliability measures can be misleading when the underlying modeling assumptions are violated. 39 develop statistical inference via confidence sets for causal orderings by inverting goodness-of-fit tests in identifiable structural equation models with additive errors. The confidence sets offer insights into model-class misspecification: an empty confidence set indicates that the “model class does not capture the data-generating process” ( 39 , p. 2) . While this approach provides a formal method for uncertainty quantification for both bivariate and multivariate functional causal discovery, it does not extend to more general functional causal models such as the post-nonlinear model. Additionally, both resampling-based and inferential methods are developed under the assumption that the working models are correctly specified and may fail to provide reliable directional evidence under mild violations, as robustness to such assumption violations is not explicitly examined. More broadly, much of the existing causal discovery literature emphasizes identifiability under idealized modeling assumptions, with comparatively limited attention paid to uncertainty quantification and robustness under assumption violations. A central challenge in applying causal discovery in practice is that identifiability assumptions—such as those related to model specification (Assumption A1)—are rarely satisfied exactly, making it essential to develop methods that remain informative under such violations. To address this challenge, we develop Causal Discovery via Statistical Power (CDSP) , a framework that connects causal direction estimation with statistical power concepts. CDSP provides a statistical perspective on causal discovery by introducing notions of statistical power and effect size tailored to this setting. Within this framework, we introduce the effect-size asymmetry assumption , which posits that the incorrect direction deviates more strongly from its null and is therefore easier to reject than the correct direction. We show that this asymmetry implies that the probability of detecting the correct causal direction exceeds that of detecting the incorrect direction, yielding a statistical characterization of directional evidence. We further leverage the effect-size asymmetry assumption to formulate causal direction estimation as a problem of assessing directional detectability. We develop the CDSP procedure to estimate the causal direction via effect-size asymmetry and to provide statistical inference for this estimate. Through simulation studies, we demonstrate that CDSP is robust to model misspecification. Analyzing 100 cause–effect benchmark pairs ( 25 ) , we find that CDSP yields materially improved performance, reducing the false discovery rate by approximately 18% relative to LiNGAM, both across all pairs and when restricted to pairs with approximately linear relationships—a setting in which methods based on the linear model class are expected to perform well. Next, we