AI-Generated Slides: Are They Good? Can Students Tell? DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: Western Canada Conference on Computing Education 2026; April 30–May 1, 2026; Vancouver, Canada ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2026/06 CCS: Computing methodologies Artificial intelligence CCS: Social and professional topics Computing education
Juho Leinonen, Lisa Zhang, Arto Hellas · 2026
Read AI-Generated Slides: Are They Good? Can Students Tell? DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: Western Canada Conference on Computing Education 2026; April 30–May 1, 2026; Vancouver, Canada ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2026/06 CCS: Computing methodologies Artificial intelligence CCS: Social and professional topics Computing education by Juho Leinonen, Lisa Zhang, Arto Hellas (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-13532.txt.
Introduction
Juho Leinonen, Lisa Zhang and Arto Hellas examine generative AI slide generation from course notes. They test NotebookLM, two general models and two coding assistants. Educators judge whether generated slides are good, and the best slides are used in a real course. Coding assistants produce the most accurate, complete and pedagogically sound slides. Students rate AI slides as similar in quality to instructor slides and cannot reliably tell which are AI-generated. High quality ratings correlate negatively with AI ratings, suggesting students link poor quality with AI origin.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Juho Leinonen, Lisa Zhang, Arto Hellas |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37452 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.13532
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
AI-Generated Slides: Are They Good? Can Students Tell? DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: Western Canada Conference on Computing Education 2026; April 30–May 1, 2026; Vancouver, Canada ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2026/06 CCS: Computing methodologies Artificial intelligence CCS: Social and professional topics Computing education Juho Leinonen, Lisa Zhang, Arto Hellas Abstract . As generative AI (GenAI) tools become easily accessible, there is promise in using such tools to support instructors. To that end, this paper examines using GenAI to help generate slides from instructor authored course notes, emphasizing instructor and student perceptions. We examine an end-to-end education tool (NotebookLM), two general-purpose LLMs (Claude, M365 Copilot), and two coding assistants (Cursor, Claude Code). We first analyze whether GenAI generated slides are “good” via narrative assessment by educators. We choose the best slides to use (with some modification) in a real course setting, and compare the student perception of human vs. AI generated slides. We find that coding assistant tools produce slides that were most accurate, complete, and pedagogically sound. Additionally, students rate GenAI slides to be of similar quality as instructor-created slides, and cannot reliably identify which slides are AI-generated. Additionally, we find a negative correlation between a high quality rating and a high “AI-generated” rating, suggesting students associate poor quality with the source of the slides being AI. These findings highlight promising opportunities for integrating GenAI into instructional design workflows and call for further research on how educators can best harness such tools responsibly and effectively. † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction As large language models (LLMs) and AI-powered educational tools rapidly advance, LLM and Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) tools have been shown to create educational content ( 31 ) . They are perceived to increase productivity on both programming tasks ( 20 ) and writing tasks ( 17 ) . However, even within software engineering, there is variation in users’ perception ( 3 ) , with GenAI tools sometimes generating incorrect or hallucinated outputs. Computing instructors thus face both opportunities and uncertainties in integrating GenAI into their pedagogical practice. Student perceptions of AI-generated materials introduce further complications ( 13 ) . This paper presents a case study using GenAI tools in assisting instructors in generating slides from instructor-authored online textbook chapters, in the context of an upper-year undergraduate web programming course. We are interested in two questions: (1) Are they good? Here, “they” refers holistically to the GenAI tools themselves, the process of using them, and the generated slide outputs. We explore and compare various types of GenAI tools: end-to-end education tools that students may already use (e.g., NotebookLM), general purpose LLMs that are accessible (e.g., Claude, M365 Copilot), and coding assistants that have been shown to be helpful for programming tasks (e.g., Cursor, Claude Code). We report on the instructor experience and their narrative assessment of factual accuracy, completeness, and pedagogical soundness. These factors are similar to work conducted at a similar time frame ( 33 ) . (2) Can students tell? We select the best slides generated across tools and, with some modifications, evaluate their quality in a real-world classroom; we then report student perception of quality and their ability to identify AI-generated content. Specifically, after matching the visual styling of GenAI-generated slides to the instructor’s preferred format and selectively deleting content, we use these slides in actual course lectures alongside instructor-created slides. Students are informed that lectures may contain GenAI-generated content but are not told which segments or how many. After each lecture segment, students rate the slide quality and guess whether the slides were AI or human generated. We choose tools that are accessible (free, <USD$30 per month, or available via institutional licenses). We prioritize tools that have not been widely discussed in the computing education literature ( 22 ; 21 ) , to introduce new tools to the community. Additionally, slides are a common form of content used to support lectures that is time-consuming to create. Slides are also challenging for GenAI tools as its creation involves coordination across text, code, and diagrams. As the authors are computing educators and researchers with minimal (<2 months) prior experience using these specific GenAI tools to build educational resources, we offer an authentic perspective on the instructor on-boarding experience. Additionally, one researcher serves as the instructor for the course examined, providing domain expertise for evaluating content quality and pedagogical appropriateness. The student evaluation is conducted with upper-year undergraduate students enrolled in the actual course, providing authentic feedback from learners. 2. Related Work Recent surveys have shown that LLMs are used to assist students, teachers, and for adaptive learning ( 31 ) . The potentials of multimodal models—models that combine text, image, and audio—are also being explored for STEM domains (e.g., in 34 ). In computing education, early work showed that code-aware models like Codex could solve most introductory programming problems ( 5 ) , prompting questions about assessment validity and curricular goals. More recently, 4 explored using natural language prompts to generate CS1 solutions, while 25 documented GPT-4’s improved performance on higher education programming assessments, underscoring rapid capability growth. Recent work found that instructors are adapting their teaching based on the widespread availability of generative AI tools, such as changing assessment practices and learning objectives ( 22 ) . Beyond student-facing applications, emerging work explores instructor support for content creation. 24 demonstrated that LLMs could generate programming exercises and explanations, though with limitations in diversity and pedagogical appropriateness. More recently, 14 found that newer LLMs perform better at generating thematically contextualized exercises, even though the contextualization was often shallow. 10 found that LLMs can create suitable exercises in multiple languages, although exercises generated in low-resource languages such as Tamil had lower quality. 29 found that LLMs can be used to create culturally relevant textbooks for CS1. Taken together, these works show the potential and interest in leveraging LLMs in computing education. Slide generation, in particular, is under-explored. Early work on automatic slide generation focused on extracting content from scientific papers ( 26 ) , while more recent approaches leveraged LLMs. 33 present SlideBot, a multi-agent framework that generates educational slides using specialized agents for retrieval, summarization, figure generation, and LaTeX formatting. Other recent systems include PASS ( 1 ) for automated slide and speech generation, AutoPresent ( 6 ) for designing structured visuals from scratch, and SlideCraft ( 23 ) as a context-aware slide generation agent. These works primarily focused on system development and technical evaluation, rather than instructor and student experience. Research on student perceptions of LLM-generated educational resources is limited. Prior work suggests that disclosure of AI assistance affects perception, e.g. in writing ( 13 ) . However, 12 found LLM-generated code explanations rated comparably to student-written ones. Similarly, 9 compared student perceptions of generative AI versus teacher feedback, finding differences in perceived usefulness and trustworthiness. For slides specifically, 7 examined student perceptions of instructor-created AI-assisted PowerPoint slides, finding that while students had favorable opinions of instructor AI usage, they expressed substantial concerns about slide design including structure, consistency between text and images, and typography. 3. Textbook to Slides in a Web Software Course: Are They (GenAI Tools) Good? This section explores whether and how GenAI tools could help transform chapters from an online web programming textbook into lecture slides. This