Towards a Holistic Understanding of Selection Bias for Causal Effect Identification
Yiwen Qiu, Filip Kovačević, Shimeng Huang, Peter Spirtes, Francesco Locatello · 2026
Read Towards a Holistic Understanding of Selection Bias for Causal Effect Identification by Yiwen Qiu, Filip Kovačević, Shimeng Huang, Peter Spirtes, Francesco Locatello (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-13430.txt.
Introduction
Yiwen Qiu and four colleagues study whether average treatment effects can be found from selected populations, where selection warps the sample. Biobank data can show healthy volunteer bias when people are healthier and wealthier than the wider population. Estimating effects from such a sub-population can badly bias the estimate for the whole population. The authors give necessary and sufficient rules for finding the average treatment effect under selection bias, using weak assumptions to describe propensity scores and selection chances. Their results stretch existing graphical criteria with weaker conditions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yiwen Qiu, Filip Kovačević, Shimeng Huang, Peter Spirtes, Francesco Locatello |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 99583 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.13430
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Towards a Holistic Understanding of Selection Bias for Causal Effect Identification Yiwen Qiu, Filip Kovačević, Shimeng Huang, Peter Spirtes, Francesco Locatello Abstract Selection bias is pervasive in observational studies. For example, large scale biobanks data can exhibit “healthy volunteer bias” when respondents are healthier and of higher socio-economic status than the population they are meant to represent ( 48 ; 50 ) . Recovering causal effects from such sub-population is an important problem in causal inference, as estimating average treatment effects (ATE) from selected populations can result in a severely biased estimate of the ATE from the whole population. In this paper, we investigate the identifiability of the ATE under selection bias. We provide necessary and sufficient conditions for ATE identifiability, leveraging assumptions on probability classes to characterize propensity score and selection probability, which are weaker assumptions than those required by existing general identification frameworks . Compared to previous works, our results extend existing graphical identifiability criteria and offer a more comprehensive understanding of causal effect identification with strictly weaker conditions in the presence of selection bias. 1 Introduction In many real-world scenarios, the data we collect is often subject to selection bias, which arises from the preferential inclusion of certain data points that are dependent on some of the observed variables ( 22 ) . This bias poses a significant challenge in statistical inference. For instance, in medical studies, patients who volunteer for clinical trials may differ systematically from those who do not, leading to biased estimates of treatment effects ( 23 ) . In social sciences, survey respondents may not represent the broader population due to non-random participation, affecting the validity of conclusions drawn from such data ( 47 ) . More concretely, we can consider the following Example 1.1 (illustrated in Figure 1 ). Example 1.1 (Biased ATE estimation) . The government wants to estimate the ATE of a physical activity subsidy T (e.g. opening a free community fitness center) on overall cardiovascular health ( Y ) for the entire country. Data is collected via a voluntary digital health survey. Because the survey is intensive and digital-only, the respondents (the subpopulation S=1 ) are primarily individuals with higher socio-economic status (SES) and higher education levels. We use Y(1) to denote the potential outcome of Y if one receives the subsidy ( T=1 ), and Y(0) otherwise. In this case, there is a discrepancy between the ATE in the selected subpopulation ( \mathrm{ATE}^{\mathrm{obs}} ) and that in the whole population ( \mathrm{ATE}^{\mathrm{all}} ). For high-SES individuals, the subsidy might have a smaller marginal effect. They likely already exercise or have the means to stay healthy. Adding a free fitness center might only result in a small improvement in cardiovascular health. In contrast, for low-SES individuals, the subsidy could have a more substantial impact, as they might have fewer opportunities for physical activity due to cost or neighborhood safety. Figure 1 : Illustration of selection bias in estimating the ATE of a physical activity subsidy ( T ) on cardiovascular health ( Y ). The participation into the survey is influenced by SES, which creates a selection bias that can lead to incorrect estimates of the ATE ( \mathrm{ATE}^{\mathrm{obs}}\ll\mathrm{ATE}^{\mathrm{all}} ) if not properly accounted for. This work aims to address the challenges posed by selection bias in causal inference. We propose a novel framework that is general enough to encompass various existing models while being specific enough to provide clear identifiability results. We make the following contributions: DAG Framework SEM Framework Ours X T Y S ∗ X T Y S X T Y S ∗∗ X T Y S X T Y S X T Y S ∗∗ Table 1 : A comparison of different frameworks. The DAG Framework refers to the result in ( 12 ) , which gives identifiability results assuming common DAG assumptions (Definition 3.7 , Definition 3.8 ) hold. The SEM Framework refers to the result in ( 56 ) , which assumes an additive noise model (ANM) and non-Gaussian noise. With these additional parametric assumptions, they are able to identify causal effect when the selection is only outcome-dependent ( 56 ) . In the chart, indicates that the causal effect in the whole population ( 2.2 ) is identifiable under the framework, provided with the assumptions in * (ANM model and non-Gaussian noise) and ** (access to external unbiased distribution on the covariate), while indicates that it is not identifiable or not considered. Our identifiability results cover all the scenarios which are identifiable through other frameworks, and extend the results to scenarios which are not considered identifiable before. For a comparison of causal effect identifiability results in sub-populations, please refer to Appendix C . General definition of selection bias. We provide a general definition of selection bias, not only in terms of M-bias or collider stratification bias ( 19 ; 16 ) . Selection bias is most widely understood in epidemiological studies as collider stratification bias ( 19 ; 24 ; 16 ) , where conditioning on a collider variable (or its descendants) can induce spurious associations between its causes. However, selection bias can manifest in other forms, not necessarily due to the collider effect, e.g., manifest itself in various graphical forms ( 45 ; 34 ) . We gave the general definition of selection bias in Definition 2.1 . General solution. We do not need to detect the location where selection occurs, in contrast to the various works based on graphical models ( 36 ; 28 ; 57 ; 37 ; 40 ; 4 ; 5 ; 7 ; 6 ) . Table. 3 compares our framework with existing works. Previous works often rely on identifying the exact location of selection bias in the causal directed acyclic graph (DAG), which can be challenging in practice. Our approach circumvents this requirement by providing a general solution that does not depend on pinpointing the selection mechanism. For a complete literature review, please refer to Appendix A . Identifiability under weaker assumptions. Apart from restrictive assumptions on where the selection happens, it is also common for existing works to have strong distributional assumptions or specific functional forms, such as non-Gaussian noise and additive noise models (ANM) for causal effect identifiability under selection bias 1 1 1 Note that, these works provide the sufficient condition, i.e. the causal effect is not identifiable by the provided method (backdoor adjustment etc.) but might still be identifiable with other methods. . Our framework imposes mild assumptions firstly by allowing selection to depend on arbitrary observed variables, and secondly by requiring weaker distributional assumptions. We achieve this through leveraging recent advances in the truncated statistics ( 9 ; 15 ; 31 ; 32 ) , which allow us to perform extrapolation from given samples from their truncations to their whole distribution. 2 Notations and Definitions We consider a general potential outcomes model. An observational study involves units ( e.g. , patients) with covariates X\in\mathbb{R}^{d} ( e.g. , medical history). Each unit receives a binary treatment T\in\{0,1\} ( e.g. , medication) with a fixed but unknown probability, independent across units, and we observe a treatment-dependent outcome Y(T)\in\mathbb{R} ( e.g. , symptom severity). The tuple (X,Y(0),Y(1),T) follows an unknown joint distribution \mathcal{D}