Groups with classifiable actions on the line

Joaquín Brum, Martín Gilabert Vio, Nicolás Matte Bon · 2026

Read Groups with classifiable actions on the line by Joaquín Brum, Martín Gilabert Vio, Nicolás Matte Bon (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-13406.txt.

Introduction

Joaquin Brum, Martin Gilabert Vio and Nicolas Matte Bon study the class C of groups whose line actions are classifiable. Classifiable means conjugacy between minimal actions is smooth, with a Borel transversal. No amenable group outside C is known. The authors prove that C is stable under group operations and show C holds all finitely generated piecewise affine interval homeomorphism groups. They exhibit a finitely generated group outside C, amenable exactly when Thompson's group F is amenable. They also prove semiconjugacy among cocompact actions is smooth exactly in C.

Catalog record

CREATORJoaquín Brum, Martín Gilabert Vio, Nicolás Matte Bon
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE148389
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.13406

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Groups with classifiable actions on the line Joaquín Brum, Martín Gilabert Vio, Nicolás Matte Bon Abstract . We motivate and study the class 𝒞 {\mathcal{C}} of countable groups G G such that the conjugacy relation between minimal actions of G G on ℝ {\mathbb{R}} by orientation-preserving homeomorphisms is smooth — that is, admits a Borel transversal. No example of amenable group outside of 𝒞 {\mathcal{C}} is known. We show a number of stability properties of 𝒞 {\mathcal{C}} under group-theoretic operations and that 𝒞 {\mathcal{C}} contains all finitely generated groups of piecewise affine homeomorphisms of the interval. We exhibit a finitely generated group G G that is not in 𝒞 {\mathcal{C}} , such that G G is amenable if and only if Thompson’s group F F is amenable. We also prove that the semiconjugacy relation among cocompact actions of a countable group G G is smooth if and only if G ∈ 𝒞 G\in{\mathcal{C}} , and that it is essentially countable even when G G is not finitely generated. In the Appendix, we show that there is no good analogue of the space of harmonic actions for a countable non-finitely generated group. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 20F60; Secondary 37C15, 03E15 1. Introduction 1.1. Context One of the central goals in dynamical systems is to identify explicit invariants that classify systems in a given class up to conjugacy. The dynamical systems we consider here are group actions by orientation-preserving homeomorphisms on connected one-manifolds, i.e. the interval and the circle. The situation on the circle is somewhat better-behaved, at least modulo actions that have a finite orbit (whose study essentually reduces to study actions on the line). First, an action \varphi\colon G\to\mathrm{Homeo}_{0}(S^{1}) always admits a unique minimal set \Lambda , that is, a non-empty closed \varphi -invariant subset \Lambda of S^{1} such that action of \varphi(G) on \Lambda has only dense orbits, and after applying a semiconjugacy one can reduce to the case where \Lambda=S^{1} , i.e. when \varphi is minimal. Second, a theorem of É. Ghys [ Ghy87 ] shows that two minimal actions on the circle are conjugate if and only if they have the same bounded Euler class. S. Matsumoto [ Mat86 ] gives a more elementary interpretation of this result. The existence of an explicit invariant that classifies a class of actions up to conjugacy — regardless of the invariant — is a result in its own right that can be formalized in the framework of Borel equivalence relations. Here we are thus led to consider the Polish space \mathrm{Rep}_{\mathrm{min}}(G,S^{1}) of minimal actions of G on S^{1} and the action of the group \mathrm{Homeo}_{0}(S^{1}) of orientation-preserving homeomorphisms of S^{1} on \mathrm{Rep}_{\mathrm{min}}(G,S^{1}) by conjugation. It is then apparent from [ Mat86 ] that there is a Borel map from \mathrm{Rep}_{\mathrm{min}}(G,S^{1}) to a standard Borel space such that its fibers are exactly the conjugacy classes. The conjugacy relation on \mathrm{Rep}_{\mathrm{min}}(G,S^{1}) is thus said to be smooth . The case of the real line is more complicated and is the subject of this article. Firstly, even when an action by orientation-preserving homeomorphisms of {\mathbb{R}} has no global fixed points it may fail to admit a minimal set. This phenomenon cannot happen when G is finitely generated, for which we can still reduce to minimal actions (up to a semi-conjugacy). But, secondly, even in this case there may be no Borel map from the space \mathrm{Rep}_{\mathrm{min}}(G,{\mathbb{R}}) of minimal actions \varphi\colon G\to\mathrm{Homeo}_{0}({\mathbb{R}}) to a standard Borel space whose fibers are the conjugacy classes. For instance, the free group on two generators admits no such map (see Subsection 2.2 below), and this rules out an analogue of the Ghys–Matsumoto result. On the other hand, there are several classes of groups whose minimal actions can be explicitly classified. A foundational result of O. Hölder [ Höl01 ] implies that all minimal actions of countable abelian groups on the real line are conjugate to actions by a dense group of translations. This remains true for all groups containing no non-abelian free semigroups, due to work of J. Plante [ Pla75 ] . For another example see [ Riv10 ] , where C. Rivas proves that every solvable Baumslag-Solitar group \mathrm{BS}(1,n),n\in{\mathbb{N}}_{+} admits only two minimal actions on {\mathbb{R}} up to conjugacy. Motivated by this discussion, in this paper we study the following class of groups. As mentioned above, we denote by \mathrm{Rep}_{\mathrm{min}}(G,{\mathbb{R}}) the space of all minimal actions \varphi\colon G\to\mathrm{Homeo}_{0}({\mathbb{R}}) . It is a Polish space with respect to pointwise convergence in the compact-open topology of \mathrm{Homeo}_{0}({\mathbb{R}}) (see Subsection 3.1 ), and hence a standard Borel space. Definition 1.1 . Define {\mathcal{C}} as the class of countable groups G such that the conjugacy relation on \mathrm{Rep}_{\mathrm{min}}(G,{\mathbb{R}}) is smooth. Hence a group G is in {\mathcal{C}} if and only if there exists a Borel function \mathrm{e}(\cdot) on \mathrm{Rep}_{\mathrm{min}}(G,{\mathbb{R}}) , with values in a standard Borel space, such that two minimal actions \varphi_{1},\varphi_{2} are topologically conjugate if and only if \mathrm{e}(\varphi_{1})=\mathrm{e}(\varphi_{2}) . A more concrete (and checkable) characterisation is provided in Theorem 3.4 below. It follows from the preceding examples that all groups G not containing a free semigroup on two generators (in particular, all abelian groups) belong to {\mathcal{C}} . The class {\mathcal{C}} is also known to contain various examples of groups of exponential growth such as \mathrm{BS}(1,n),n\in{\mathbb{N}}_{+} . The following questions arise naturally. Question 1 . i. Is every finitely generated amenable group in {\mathcal{C}} ? ii. Is every finitely generated elementary amenable group in {\mathcal{C}} ? We do not know the answer to either question. A positive answer to Question 1 ( i ) would give a strengthening of Witte-Morris’ theorem that a finitely generated amenable group acting non-trivially on the line has a non-trivial homomorphism to ({\mathbb{R}},+) [ Mor06 ] . This connection becomes transparent using the space of harmonic actions of Deroin, Kleptsyn, Navas and Parwani [ DKNP13 ] : we explain it in Subsection 2.4 . 1.2. Main results Our first main result is a stability property of the class {\mathcal{C}} , that implies that many groups are in {\mathcal{C}} . Recall that a subgroup H\leq G is commensurated if gHg^{-1}\cap H has finite index in H for every g\in G . We denote by \langle\langle H\rangle\rangle its normal closure. Theorem A . Let G be a finitely generated group. If there is a commensurated subgroup H\leq G such that H and G/\langle\langle H\rangle\rangle belong to {\mathcal{C}} , then G\in{\mathcal{C}} . Corollary 1.2 . i. If G is a finitely generated group having a normal subgroup N\unlhd G such that N and G/N belong to {\mathcal{C}} , then G\in{\mathcal{C}} . ii. If H,K\in{\mathcal{C}} are finitely generated, then the wreath product H\wr K is in {\mathcal{C}} . iii. If \Phi\colon H\to K is an isomorphism between finite-index subgroups H,K of a finitely generated group G\in{\mathcal{C}} , then the HNN-extension G^{\Phi} is in {\mathcal{C}} . iv. If H,G\in{\mathcal{C}} are finitely generated groups containing K as a finite-index subgroup, then the amalgamated product G\ast_{K}H is in {\mathcal{C}} . Example 1.3 . From item ( i ) it follows by induction that if G is a finitely generated group having a series of normal subgroups \{e\}=G_{0}\unlhd\cdots\unlhd G_{m}=G such that G_{i}/G_{i-1}\in{\mathcal{C}} for i=1,\ldots,m (e.g. if G_{i}/G_{i-1} does not

Read the complete text