The fine structure of electricity price volatility

Thomas K. Kloster, Fred Espen Benth · 2026

Read The fine structure of electricity price volatility by Thomas K. Kloster, Fred Espen Benth (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-13320.txt.

Introduction

Thomas Kloster and Fred Espen Benth carry out the first strict study of electricity price volatility across day-ahead prices in Germany, Norway and Spain. Treating observed prices as local averages of a hidden price process, they build estimators of weekly integrated variance. Their method copes with mean reversion in prices and with smoothing effects in the estimated variance. Their decomposition shows each zone has quite different drivers of volatility. Apparent leverage effects, where falls move volatility more than rises, vanish once suitable state variables are taken into account.

Catalog record

CREATORThomas K. Kloster, Fred Espen Benth
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE98418
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.13320

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The fine structure of electricity price volatility Thomas K. Kloster, Fred Espen Benth Abstract We conduct the first rigorous study of electricity price volatility for the full panel of electricity prices across three European generation zones. By interpreting the observed day-ahead prices as local averages of a latent price process governed by a stochastic partial differential equation, we develop estimators of the weekly integrated variance. The inherently infinite dimensional setting introduce several complications that are not relevant in the conventional finite dimensional semimartingale setting, and we spend considerable effort in dealing with these. In particular, we must account for both mean-reversion in prices and semigroup-smoothing in the estimated variance. We provide a detailed decomposition and interpretation of the empirical estimates across three vastly different European generation zones, namely Germany, Norway, and Spain. Our findings indicate that each zone has very different drivers of volatility, and that the impact of generation variables differs considerably. We document that leverage effects appear to be present at first sight, but disappear once we condition on suitable state variables, thereby showing that electricity price volatility does not generally exhibit asymmetric responses to price shocks. Keywords: Electricity markets, realized volatility, functional data analysis, quadratic variation, mean-reversion, leverage effect 1 Introduction Volatility is a ubiquitous term in finance and typically refers to the second order structure of the conditional return distribution. It is generally regarded as being the most dominant time-varying feature of the distribution and plays a critical role in, e.g., portfolio management, derivatives pricing, and trading impact ( 3 ; 1 ; 2 ; 6 ; 15 ; 16 ; 17 ; 18 ; 24 ; 5 ) . Depending on the horizon and data availability, different proxies for the second order structure can be considered, but most modern measures rely on quadratic variation theory. In this work, the goal is to investigate the conditional second order structure in European day-ahead (spot) electricity markets in a systematic and rigorous way, down to the individual delivery period. While there is a large literature on stylized facts and forecasting of spot price levels , there seems to be less focus on the volatility of the panel of prices. The market for electricity is very different from classical equity markets and it therefore requires different interpretations and modeling tools (see 10 ; 34 , for comprehensive introductions) . The most notable feature of electricity spot prices is that they evolve as a high-dimensional multivariate time series P_{t}\in\mathbb{R}^{d} , where each component P_{t}^{(i)} represents the price of consuming 1MWh of electricity during the i ’th delivery period . Typically, it is the case that d=24 or d=96 , which, respectively, corresponds to hourly and quarter-hourly delivery periods throughout the day. Unlike stock prices, electricity spot prices can also be negative, which means that log-transformations are not generally feasible, as is otherwise common in the literature on volatility. Other unique features of electricity spot prices that distinguish them from traditional asset prices are the presence of mean-reversion, short-lived spikes, and seasonality effects. Furthermore, the cross-sectional dependence structure of electricity prices exhibits a very particular diurnal pattern as shown in 29 ; in particular, electricity spot prices exhibit “cyclicality” in the sense that the earliest and the latest delivery period of the day are more highly correlated than, e.g., the earliest and the mid-day delivery periods. This is generally ascribed to the strong correlation of the underlying supply and demand at these periods, which is largely agnostic to when the price is determined. These characteristics can be modeled by imposing suitable assumptions within a multivariate model, but it is illustrated in 29 that one obtains a flexible and parsimonious framework by letting P_{t} evolve as a function-valued process, such that the daily cross section of prices corresponds to observations along a latent price curve. More precisely, it is shown that when P_{t} takes values in the separable Hilbert space of square-integrable functions on the unit circle, denoted by L^{2}(\mathbb{S}^{1}) where \mathbb{S}^{1} is the unit circle, then cyclicality of prices is essentially a model-free implication. The functional time series perspective is not new in the context of electricity spot markets (see, e.g., 31 ; 14 ; 13 ) , but the choice of \mathbb{S}^{1} as an index for the cross sectional dimension introduced in 29 yields a particularly tractable framework in which we shall operate. The infinite dimensional perspective have several convenient implications that cannot be modelled by conventional methods, in addition to the diurnal periodic structure induced in the prices from the embedding into L^{2}(\mathbb{S}^{1}) . It allows for modeling arbitrary and changing partitions of the day into delivery periods, which is relevant as these are not fixed throughout time or generation zone in practice. It also allows for the interpretation of spot prices as functionals of the latent daily price curve, which is a perspective we adopt throughout. Furthermore, the interpretation of both time and cross section as a continuum is very tractable for the purpose of derivatives pricing, which is an area where infinite dimensional models have generally been used to great effect ( 9 ; 4 ; 19 ) , and an area where volatility modeling is particularly important. To illustrate our framework, suppose that \{[h_{i-1},h_{i})\}_{i=1}^{d} is the partition of delivery periods where h_{0}=0<h_{1}<\cdots<h_{d}=2\pi . Each h_{i} represents a unique time of the day via the canonical mapping onto the circle h_{i}\mapsto(\cos(h_{i}),\sin(h_{i}))=(\cos(i/(2\pi d)),\sin(i/(2\pi d))) . Let X_{t}(h) be the instantaneous latent price of electricity on time h of day t and suppose that the function-valued process X_{t}(\cdot) takes values in L^{2}(\mathbb{S}^{1}) . Since electricity can be consumed at any point during the delivery period, it is economically reasonable that the observed price, P_{t}^{(i)} , corresponds to the average of the true, but unobserved, price over that period. More precisely, we find it natural to impose that P_{t}^{(i)}=\frac{1}{(h_{i}-h_{i-1})}\int_{h_{i-1}}^{h_{i}}X_{t}(h)dh. (1) In this view, each observed price P_{t}^{(i)} is a bounded linear functional of X_{t} , which has several convenient statistical implications. In particular, we do not a priori require the latent process X_{t} to take values in a “nice” subspace of L^{2}(\mathbb{S}^{1}) , which is often required to make the evaluation functional \delta_{x}f=f(x) continuous. By formulating the evolution of X_{t}(\cdot) as a stochastic partial differential equation (SPDE) in L^{2}(\mathbb{S}^{1}) , we may construct an estimate of the integrated variance – which is an operator on L^{2}(\mathbb{S}^{1}) – via methods related to quadratic variation theory. Our methods and results are similar to those of 12 ; 11 , who study realized covariation for a class of semilinear SPDE’s in a high frequency setting. They introduce the so-called semigroup-adjusted realized covariation, which generalizes the multivariate realized covariation of 7 . Their semigroup adjustment is a natural consequence of the functional setting, and must be accounted for to ensure that certain propagation effects disappear in the infill limit. A similar adjustment turns out to play a role in our long-span setting, and we discuss the relation to the high frequency case as well as classical realized covariation in detail. To the best of our knowledge, the literature on volatility estimation in electricity markets is rather sparse, likely due to the complexity of the task. An approach for volatility estimation at the level of

Read the complete text