A philosophical history of infinitesimals

Vladimir Kanovei, Mikhail G. Katz, Taras Kudryk, Karl Kuhlemann · 2026

Read A philosophical history of infinitesimals by Vladimir Kanovei, Mikhail G. Katz, Taras Kudryk, Karl Kuhlemann (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-13102.txt.

Introduction

Kanovei, Katz, Kudryk and Kuhlemann explore a framework for Leibnizian infinitesimals, tiny numbers in the spirit of Leibniz, through modern standard and nonstandard lenses. They sort infinite numbers into three kinds: ordinals, cardinals and ringinals, where a ringinal is a number of a third kind, unlike Cantor's ordinals and cardinals. Work with endless numbers fits inside Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory, making it safe in a knowledge sense. Their sketch spells out Leibnizian definitions while shunning the axiom of choice and ultrafilters, challenging received views on infinitesimals.

Catalog record

CREATORVladimir Kanovei, Mikhail G. Katz, Taras Kudryk, Karl Kuhlemann
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53676
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.13102

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A philosophical history of infinitesimals Vladimir Kanovei, Mikhail G. Katz, Taras Kudryk, Karl Kuhlemann Abstract . We explore the issue of providing a foundational framework for Leibnizian infinitesimals in the light of modern standard and nonstandard approaches . We outline a trichotomy of ordinals, cardinals and ringinals as a historiographic tool. A ringinal is a concept of infinite number, arithmetic in nature, different from Cantor’s transfinite ordinals and cardinals. The continuum is not necessarily identifiable with ℝ {\mathbb{R}} ; even if one seeks such an identification, infinitesimals are not ruled out. Analysis with unlimited numbers (via the predicate standard ) is possible in a conservative extension of Zermelo–Fraenkel set theory and in this sense is epistemologically ‘safe’. We sketch a recent theory of infinitesimal analysis that formalizes Leibnizian definitions and heuristic principles while eschewing both the axiom of choice and ultrafilters, thus challenging received philosophical views on the nature of infinitesimals. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 01A45, 01A61 Secondary 01A85, 01A90, 26E35 If in the following someone will complain about the use of these quantities, he will show himself to be either an ignorant or an ungrateful person. As an ignorant one, if he does not understand what a great light is lit here in the whole method of indivisibles and in the field of quadratures; as an ungrateful one, if he hides the benefit he gets. –Leibniz, De Quadratura Arithmetica , Scholium to Propositio XXIII 1. Intermediate state between Leibniz and d’Alembert Abraham Robinson included a sketch of the history of infinitesimal analysis in Chapter 10 of his 1966 book [ 125 ] . Over half a century later, significant advances have taken place both in understanding this history and in axiomatic nonstandard analysis. Indivisibles were controversial in the 17th century, not least in the eyes of the jesuits who issued numerous bans against them. 1 1 1 McCue [ 116 , p. 419] ; Festa [ 50 , p. 101] and [ 51 ] . Perhaps sensing the doctrinal burden of the (overly) evocative term indivisible (see Section 1.2 ), Leibniz coined the term infinitesimal in 1673 taking up a suggestion of Nicolaus Mercator. 2 2 2 See Probst [ 123 , p. 200] , who also notes that Wallis used the term pars infinitesima already in 1670. Ever since the inception of infinitesimal calculus in the work of Leibniz and Newton, there have been attempts to delegitimize infinitesimals. Abraham Robinson claimed to have developed a formalisation of Leibnizian infinitesimals. Robinson’s claim has been challenged by some historians and supported by others. 1.1. Law of Continuity and status transitus Leibniz formulated a number of heuristic principles that governed his infinitesimal calculus, such as the Law of Continuity . 3 3 3 See e.g., Bos [ 26 ] , Katz and Sherry [ 85 ] . One of the formulations of the Law of Continuity involves the postulation of a status transitus , an intermediate stage before reaching the end of the process of vanishing. 4 4 4 See Bair et al. [ 10 , Section 6.1] . Such an intermediate stage witnesses the appearance of inassignable quantities such as infinitesimals. The Leibnizian distinction between assignable and inassignable quantity goes back to Nicholas of Cusa (Cusanus) (1401--1464). 5 5 5 See Knobloch [ 93 , p. 5] . A (positive) infinitesimal is smaller than every assignable number (see further in Section 4.3 ). Concerning such quantities, Leibniz wrote: Although they are not assignable, they turn out to be something existing and not an absolute nothing. 6 6 6 “Bien qu’elles ne soient pas assignables, elles se trouvent être quelque chose d’existant et non pas un rien absolu.” (Leibniz as quoted in Bella [ 20 , p. 195] ). It is ‘‘a question of fundamental methodology’’ 7 7 7 Cf. Archibald et al. [ 2 ] . in the Leibnizian calculus that such infinitesimal quantities are fictional; see [ 80 ] . Another formulation of the Law of Continuity posits that The rules of the finite are found to succeed in the infinite and vice versa. 8 8 8 “il se trouve que les regles du fini reussissent dans l’infini, … et que vice versa les regles de l’infini reussissent dans le fini” Leibniz [ 103 , pp. 93–94] (original spelling preserved). Cf. Robinson [ 125 , p. 266] . See further in Section 3.3 . Leibniz’s dealing in such notions was not uniformly accepted by his contemporaries. 9 9 9 Today, we possess a better appreciation of Leibniz’s work, and few scholars would accept Whiteside’s claim that “very few proofs of any kind in classical mathematics will be allowable, and certainly none were given in the 17th century on any but the most elementary numerical level” [ 139 , p. 184] . One of the opponents was Michel Rolle, who initiated a lively debate at the French Academy. 10 10 10 Mancosu [ 114 ] ; Bair et al. [ 6 , Section 2.9] . The 17th century acrimonious debates over indivisibles set the tone for centuries to come. In 18th century France, Jean D’Alembert reasoned as follows: A quantity is either something or nothing: if it is something, it has not yet vanished; if it is nothing, it has literally vanished. The supposition that there is an intermediate state between these two is a chimera . 11 11 11 D’Alembert as translated by Boyer [ 27 , p. 248] ; emphasis added. See Lamandé [ 96 , p. 52] for the original. D’Alembert’s attitude toward the intermediate state appears to be less positive than Leibniz’s. Some historians today adopt the attitude of the former rather than the latter; see e.g., Section 1.4 . 1.2. Theological context Indivisibles and atomism were thought contrary to catholic doctrine as established by the Council of Trent in the 16th century, and specifically Session 13, canon 2. The said canon concludes that whoever denies the transubstantiation interpretation of the eucharist, ‘let him be anathema’. Opposition to atomism within catholicism goes back at least to Duns Scotus in the 13th century . 12 12 12 Cross [ 39 , p. 118] . and Katz et al. [ 87 ] . Theological concerns may have been behind Fermat’s caution in presenting his method of adequality and the variable E . 13 13 13 See [ 84 ] , [ 16 ] . Leibniz was keenly aware of such doctrinal tensions over indivisibles. Already in 1668, he published a work on substance aimed to effect a reconciliation between Roman Catholics and Protestants. … These works are especially valuable for what they reveal about the motivations behind Leibniz’s first account of substance. 14 14 14 Mercer and Sleigh [ 117 , p. 68] . Decades later, in a letter to des Bosses dated 8 september 1709, Leibniz explicitly distanced himself from both transubstantiation and consubstantiation, and sketched a monad-based approach. 15 15 15 See Look and Rutherford (transl.) [ 106 , p. 153] . On the theological background, see further in Katz et al. [ 80 ] . 1.3. Ordinals, Cardinals, Ringinals Some historians today tend to interpret the thrust of their training in naive set theory as entailing that there could exist only two types of

Read the complete text