Forbidden Formation Histories: The Binary Black Hole Merger Rate Disfavours Long Delay Times NumPy ( 39 ) , SciPy ( 78 ) , Matplotlib ( 40 ) , pandas ( 51 ) , Seaborn ( 80 ) , JAX ( 19 ) , NumPyro ( 56 ) , Astropy ( 12 ; 11 ; 10 ) , and corner.py ( 35 ) .

Aryanna Schiebelbein-Zwack, Maya Fishbach · 2026

Read Forbidden Formation Histories: The Binary Black Hole Merger Rate Disfavours Long Delay Times NumPy ( 39 ) , SciPy ( 78 ) , Matplotlib ( 40 ) , pandas ( 51 ) , Seaborn ( 80 ) , JAX ( 19 ) , NumPyro ( 56 ) , Astropy ( 12 ; 11 ; 10 ) , and corner.py ( 35 ) . by Aryanna Schiebelbein-Zwack, Maya Fishbach (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-12858.txt.

Introduction

Schiebelbein-Zwack and Fishbach test which histories of black-hole formation fit the observed merger rate across cosmic time. The merger rate combines the birth rate of progenitor binaries with the delay before they merge. They show some delay distributions are forbidden outright, since their long-delay tails predict too many nearby mergers. Using population models and gravitational-wave data, they find the data disfavour long delays and channels like stable mass transfer.

Catalog record

CREATORAryanna Schiebelbein-Zwack, Maya Fishbach
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47716
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.12858

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Forbidden Formation Histories: The Binary Black Hole Merger Rate Disfavours Long Delay Times NumPy ( 39 ) , SciPy ( 78 ) , Matplotlib ( 40 ) , pandas ( 51 ) , Seaborn ( 80 ) , JAX ( 19 ) , NumPyro ( 56 ) , Astropy ( 12 ; 11 ; 10 ) , and corner.py ( 35 ) . Aryanna Schiebelbein-Zwack, Maya Fishbach Abstract The redshift evolution of the binary black hole (BBH) merger rate can be expressed as the convolution of the progenitor formation rate with the distribution of time delays between formation and merger. We show that starting with data-driven fits to the BBH merger rate as a function of redshift, deconvolving the inferred BBH merger rate into a delay time distribution and progenitor formation rate exposes physically incompatible delay time distributions. For a given evolution of the merger rate, certain delay time distributions are forbidden because their long-delay tails overpredict low redshift mergers independently of any assumption about the progenitor formation rate. Using delay-time distributions derived from the COMPAS population synthesis code in combination with the BBH merger rate inferred from GWTC-4.0, we reconstruct the physically permitted progenitor formation histories and find a steeper decline toward low redshift than the global star formation rate. We also find that the GWTC-4.0 data are in tension with formation channels that predict shallow power-law delay-time distributions ( α ≳ − 0.7 \alpha\gtrsim-0.7 ), such as stable mass transfer. Conversely, imposing the COMPAS predictions for the delay time distribution as a prior reduces the median merger rate inferred in GWTC-4.0 by 10% at z = 1.5 z=1.5 , favoring a shallower merger rate evolution than the standard GWTC-4.0 inference. Additionally, we demonstrate that our method can constrain binary evolution physics by directly evaluating the compatibility of population synthesis parameters with gravitational wave observations. Our framework provides a model-independent avenue for ruling out regions of binary evolution and merger rate parameter space. I Introduction The binary black hole (BBH) merger rate is inherently informative of the progenitor stellar populations that produce merging BBHs, as it is the culmination of the birth of massive stars, the conditions of the Universe at their formation, and their subsequent evolution ( 16 ; 48 ; 23 ; 77 ; 34 , e.g.) . The merger rate, R_{\text{merge}} , depends on both the rate by which progenitor stars form, R_{\text{form}} , and the delay in time until eventual merger, \tau ( 52 ; 54 ; 79 ; 49 ; 31 ; 33 ; 73 ; 65 ; 3 , e.g.) . Mathematically, this is described by the linear convolution of the progenitor formation rate and the distribution of all possible delay times: R_{\text{merge}}(t)=\int^{\tau_{\text{max}}}_{\tau_{\text{min}}}R_{\text{form}}(t-\tau)p(\tau)d\tau, (1) where t is the age of the Universe. 1 1 1 Throughout, we use Planck 2018 cosmology to convert between the age of the Universe t and the cosmological redshift z ( 57 ) , and use cosmic time and redshift interchangeably. The hypothetical progenitor formation rate, R_{\text{form}} , is a modified version of the global star formation rate (SFR), assuming the observed BHs are entirely stellar remnants. These modifications account for the efficiency of BBH formation, determined by how many stars become BHs in systems that merge within a Hubble time. It remains unknown exactly which stars map to merging BBHs, and therefore gravitational wave (GW) observations are informative of the underlying physics that R_{\text{form}} depends on. Metallicity is a key driver of BBH formation efficiency, since enriched stars produce more winds which cause radial expansion and mass loss that can prompt premature mergers or prevent BHs from forming at all ( 16 ; 69 ; 23 ; 76 ; 65 ) . The distribution of delay times, p(\tau) , dictates the fraction of mergers that occur on short vs. long timescales post star formation. This time is dominated by the GW inspiral time ( 55 ) , since the massive stars that serve as progenitors to merging systems are massive and live short lives on the order of 10 Myr. The inspiral time is dictated by the initial separations of the BHs, governed by binary evolution physics. In the context of the isolated binary formation channel, common envelope evolution is an efficient mechanism for reducing orbital energy, shrinking orbits, and leading to shorter time delays compared to stable mass transfer ( 36 ; 74 ; 33 ; 43 ) . Alternative formation channels include chemically homogeneous evolution ( 24 ; 47 ; 50 ; 62 ) , triple stellar evolution ( 7 ; 67 ) , dynamical evolution in star clusters ( 63 ; 25 ; 82 ) , or in Galactic centers with or without an active galactic nucleus (AGN) ( 6 ; 68 ; 14 ; 8 ; 37 ) . Altogether, the BBH merger rate as a function of redshift encodes information on star formation, stellar evolution, and environmental conditions. This makes the merger rate evolution a valuable lens through which to view stellar phylogenies and the changing landscape of the Universe. The LIGO-VIRGO-KAGRA (LVK) collaboration ( 1 ; 45 ; 2 ; 4 ) has observed the BBH merger rate evolution out to z=1.5^{+0.2}_{-0.2} (90% credibility) as of GWTC-4.0 ( 71 ; 72 ) . This merger rate is modeled with both strongly-modeled, or parametric, and data-driven, or non-parametric, methods. Parametric methods assume a specific underlying functional form and fit the parameters of the assumed form to the GW event data. The LVK uses a Power-Law Redshift model, which assumes R_{\text{merge}}\propto(1+z)^{\kappa} ( 30 ) . The GWTC-4.0 fit resulted in \kappa=3.2^{+0.94}_{-1.00} at 90% credibility ( 72 ) . Previous studies have compared strongly modelled LVK parametric merger rates to models of the progenitor formation rate and delay time distribution according to Eq. 1 ( 53 ; 27 ; 69 ; 20 ; 74 ; 73 ; 41 ; 65 ; 18 , e.g.) . These methods have provided useful insights, including establishing the metallicity dependence of BBH formation efficiency and suggesting a preference for short delay times ( 77 ; 73 ; 65 ) . However, approaches that utilize strongly-modeled parametric merger rates can miss features in the data not prescribed by the predetermined merger rate model structure ( 26 ; 21 ) . Furthermore, strong models for the progenitor formation rate and delay time distribution, even if physically motivated, may fundamentally mismatch the observed redshift evolution of the BBH merger rate ( 22 ; 18 ; 44 ; 17 ) . These methods therefore always have an inherent degeneracy between the inferred delay time distribution and the progenitor formation rate; do we measure mergers from ancient stars with long time delays or recent formation with short time delays? Alternatively, there are more flexible non-parametric approaches that fit the BBH merger rate without strong assumptions, such as the B-spline model used for GWTC-4.0 ( 26 ; 72 ) , the autoregressive BBH population inference of 21 , or the non-parametric delay time distributions explored in 3 . In GWTC-4.0, the parametric Power-Law Redshift model is generally consistent with the flexible B-spline model, however with the allowance of additional structure there is a steeper decline in the merger rate from z=0.2 to the present

Read the complete text