Assessing the imprint of eccentricity in GW signatures using two independent waveform models
Natalie Malagon, Richard O’Shaughnessy · 2026
Read Assessing the imprint of eccentricity in GW signatures using two independent waveform models by Natalie Malagon, Richard O’Shaughnessy (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-12818.txt.
Introduction
Malagon and O'Shaughnessy test whether gravitational waves from merging compact objects carry traces of stretched, non-circular orbits. They analyse 162 confident detections from the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA network's third and fourth observing runs with two independently built waveform models that allow for orbital eccentricity and aligned spins. Both models mostly argue against eccentricity, but three black-hole mergers show possible signs, two of them ambiguously.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Natalie Malagon, Richard O’Shaughnessy |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 89917 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.12818
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Assessing the imprint of eccentricity in GW signatures using two independent waveform models Natalie Malagon, Richard O’Shaughnessy Abstract The gravitational wave signal from merging compact binaries encodes information about their orbital and intrinsic properties. Over the last few years, state-of-the-art waveform models have begun to incorporate the effects of orbital eccentricity into their estimated signal. Over a similar period, many groups have applied these waveforms to characterize whether the imprint of eccentricity is present and, if so, measure this time-evolving property (at a suitably-defined reference point). In this work, we present a comprehensive analysis of 162 confident sources identified in the O3 and O4a observing runs of the International Gravitational Wave Network (LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA). Using the RIFT parameter inference engine, we employ two independently implemented waveform models (SEOBNRv5EHM and TEOBResumS-Dali) which account for orbital eccentricity and the effects of aligned compact object spins. Using these two waveforms, we find consistent conclusions that disfavor the eccentric hypothesis. Unlike previous work, among binary black hole candidates, we find potential evidence for eccentricity in three events: GW200129, GW231001, and GW231123. For the latter two events, the evidence for eccentricity is ambiguous, with different degrees of support from different waveforms. Consistent with previous work, we find conclusions obtained about GW200129 can be sensitive to analysis settings, as expected, given the nonstationary noise present. I Introduction Since the discovery of GW150914_095045 by the Advanced LIGO 57 and Virgo 6 detectors, now joined by KAGRA 7 , the first four observing runs (referred to as O1, O2, O3, and O4) of the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA (LVK) network by the LVK Collaboration have identified the characteristic gravitational-wave signature of more than O(\simeq 200) coalescing compact binaries 60 ; 5 ; 3 ; 61 . Independent analyses of the public data have also contributed to the candidate event census; see, e.g., 37 ; 63 ; 64 and references therein. For each candidate event, the gravitational wave (GW) strain data can be compared to approximate models for the emitted gravitational radiation from a coalescing compact binary, to deduce the distribution of plausible source binary parameters consistent with the data; see, eg., 62 ; 68 for details. While until recently these inferences were restricted to quasi-circular binaries, because few models allowed for non-quasi-circular binaries with any spin, now multiple waveform modeling implementations account for orbital eccentricity, particularly in the case where both compact object spins are aligned with the orbital angular momentum, including SEOBNRE 29 , SEOBNRv5EHM 18 , TEOBResumS-Dali 11 ; 36 ; 35 , IMRPhenomTEHM 16 , and the inspiral-only pyEFPE model 33 . Using these and earlier models, several groups have investigated large subsets of the total GW catalog, identifying several candidate events with possible indications of orbital eccentricity (e.g., GW190521, GW190701, GW190929, GW191109, GW200105, GW200129, and GW200208_22) 49 ; 54 ; 19 ; 45 ; 47 ; 22 ; 21 ; 42 ; 24 ; 25 ; 34 ; 50 ; 32 . Unambiguous signatures of eccentricity could provide complementary insight to better differentiate between different formation channels 31 ; 72 ; 46 ; 55 . There are two formation channels for stellar-mass binary black holes: isolated binary evolution and dynamic assembly 30 . The isolated binary evolution scenario entails the binary to undergo binary stellar evolution with no external interactions until the stellar binary collapses into black holes 8 . Another possible mechanism is dynamic assembly which involves independently evolved black holes which become gravitationally bound in dense stellar environments, such as globular clusters and galactic centers, and dynamically interact with other black holes 9 ; 73 . Isolated compact binaries are expected to have quasi-circular orbits when they merge due to the damping of orbital eccentricity, while dynamically assembled systems may retain measurable eccentricities at the merger 30 . The distinctions in eccentric gravitational-wave signals serve as a potential probe for better understanding compact binary formation and evolution. However, previous experience with novel physics and parameter extremes in gravitational-wave models suggests that substantial differences may remain, complicating our ability to reliably discern source parameters with eccentricity included; see, e.g., the first analyses of GW190521 59 and GW231123 1 . In addition, incorporating both eccentric waveform models and precessing waveform models, without neglecting the relativistic anomaly parameter, can help mitigate potential systematic biases in parameter estimation studies 43 ; 44 . In this work, we perform parameter inference on 162 sources in the O3 and O4a observing runs of the LVK network, including all previously identified as confident candidates with a false alarm rates (FAR) of less than one per year as well as most other detection candidates highlighted in these two runs. Unlike previous investigations, our sample is comprehensive: we analyze additional sources above this threshold. To assess the impact of eccentricity, we perform inferences using two state-of-the-art waveform models incorporating eccentricity (SEOBNRv5EHM and TEOBResumS-Dali). We compare these inferences to each other and to previously reported results. To mitigate the high computational cost associated with evaluating these waveforms 48 , we employ the RIFT parameter inference pipeline, whose architecture provides generic methods to mitigate this cost 26 ; 69 ; 68 ; 65 . The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we describe the parameter estimation method, asimov infrastructure, and analysis settings for events that are re-analyzed in this work. In Section III we survey our parameter inferences, illustrating both qualitatively and quantitatively that these two waveform models largely draw similar conclusions and briefly comment on the extent to which our eccentric inferences resemble previously-reported quasi-circular posteriors. We also identify and discuss events with at least modest indications of eccentricity or otherwise noteworthy features in Section III.3 , as well as events with large waveform systematics in Section III.4 . In addition, in Section III.5 , we examine the impact of different analysis settings on GW200129_065458. In Section IV we discuss how our results compare with previously published work that attempt to characterize eccentricity for these same events with other analysis frameworks, sometimes using one of the waveform models adopted here. We conclude with a summary of our findings in Section V . In Appendix A , we supply additional plots of events with eccentric features and two events for which we find no evidence of eccentricity including a previously identified eccentric candidate, GW190701_203306. II Methods II.1 Parameter inference with RIFT and asimov Coalescing compact binaries, such as binary black holes, with quasi-circular orbits can be characterized by 15 parameters with an additional parameter used to describe tidal deformability for binary neutron stars (BNSs) or neutron star-black holes (NSBHs). The eight intrinsic parameters ( \lambda ) refer to the physical properties of the individual components within each binary including the component masses, spin magnitudes, spin tilts, and azimuthal angles. The seven extrinsic parameters ( \theta ) refer to the spacetime location and orientation of the binary system: right ascension, declination, luminosity distance, inclination, polarization, orbital phase, and coalescence time. Two additional intrinsic parameters, eccentricity and mean anomaly, are inferred to describe an eccentric aligned-spin binary system. RIFT comprises a two-step iterative process that compares gravitational-wave observations d to predicted gravitational-wave signals h(\bm{\lambda},\bm{\theta}) . In the first step, for a large number of \bm{\lambda} values, RIFT computes a marginal likelihood {\cal L}{({\bm{\lambda}})}\equiv\int{\cal