Complex Methods in the Asymptotics of Möbius energy integrals of helix curves

Max Lipton · 2026

Read Complex Methods in the Asymptotics of Möbius energy integrals of helix curves by Max Lipton (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-12815.txt.

Introduction

Lipton studies the Möbius energy of helix curves, an energy that penalises self-closeness and interests knot theorists. Fixing the helix radius, he tracks a rescaled energy density as helices unwind to a straight line or coil ever tighter. The unwinding case falls to a short chain of estimates. The tight-coiling case, where energy blows up, needs a far more involved argument built on extending the integrand into the complex plane.

Catalog record

CREATORMax Lipton
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE83601
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.12815

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Complex Methods in the Asymptotics of Möbius energy integrals of helix curves Max Lipton Abstract . The Möbius energy of a curve is a topic of interest to physical knot theorists, harmonic analysts, and geometric analysts. In particular, there are many open questions regarding the gradient flow and critical points. The Gateaux derivative indicates the variation is dependent on curvature and torsion, and so to better understand the gradient, we investigate the family of helix curves, where the ratio of torsion to curvature is a constant proportional to the pitch. We fix the radius of the helix, and study the coiling in both directions: as the helix unravels to a straight line, and as it coils infinitely tight. Specifically, we study the arclength-rescaled Möbius energy density, which is a naturally tractable quantity under the Möbius energy’s chord-arc comparison of inverse-square laws. The asymptotics of the uncoiling helix, corresponding to an energy decay, can be proven with a short chain of estimates. However, the asymptotics of the helix as it coils infinitely tight, blowing up the energy, is a much more involved calculation. Our strategy for calculating the asymptotics, initially reminiscent of the work by Kim-Kusner, begins with a meromorphic extension of the integrand. However, proving the asymptotic equivalence requires a fundamentally distinct strategy because our integrand has infinitely many poles. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 53A04, 30E20, 57K10 1. Introduction 1.1. An abbreviated summary of the Möbius energy A fundamental question in knot theory asks “What is the best way to tie a knot?” Its solution would be a corollary to two fundamental questions of geometry, which ask “What is the best shape?” and “How do you construct it?” To resolve these questions, there are quantities known as energy functionals which geometers use to compare shapes. Ideally, these energies act as topological barriers, indicating a qualitative distinction between shapes. A simple example of a topological barrier is the integral of curvature. The Fàry-Milnor theorem states that if \gamma\subseteq\mathbb{R}^{3} is a C^{2} simple closed curve such that \int_{\gamma}\kappa(s)ds<4\pi , then \gamma is unknotted. However, this theorem has limited utility because it does not distinguish curves with nontrivial knot type, nor does it actually provide the algorithm for untangling a knot with low energy. The account of Simon gives a thorough overview of several different knot energies, discussing their various strengths and weaknesses [ 15 ] . An example of a more refined topological barrier is the Möbius energy, first introduced as part of a family of functionals by O’Hara [ 12 ] , and later expounded upon by Freedman-He-Wang in their seminal paper [ 5 ] . Let j,p\geq 1 , I be an interval or a circle and let \gamma:I\to\mathbb{R}^{n} parametrize a C^{2} curve. For s\in I , define the pointwise energy, also referred to as the energy element or energy density, as (1a) \displaystyle E^{j,p}(\gamma,s) \displaystyle\coloneq\int_{I}\left(\frac{1}{|\gamma(t)-\gamma(s)|^{j}}-\frac{1}{D(\gamma(t),\gamma(s))^{j}}\right)^{p}|\dot{\gamma}(t)|dt, where D denotes the intrinsic distance along \gamma . The (j,p) -O’Hara energy of \gamma is given by (1b) \displaystyle E^{j,p}(\gamma)\coloneq\int_{I}E^{j,p}(\gamma,s)|\dot{\gamma}(s)|ds. Since the extrinsic Euclidean distance minimizes the intrinsic distance on \gamma , the integrand in ( 1a ) is nonnegative. The arclength elements ensure the energy is invariant under reparametrizations of \gamma . As the quantity E^{j,p}(\gamma,s)|\dot{\gamma}(s)| which is integrated, we will see that this arclength-rescaled energy density is the more natural quantity to analyze. We will exclusively work with E^{2,1} for curves in \mathbb{R}^{3} , suppressing the superscripts. This configuration of parameters, known as the Möbius energy, is special. First of all, the Möbius energy is now invariant under Euclidean similarities. Perhaps the central property of the Möbius energy is that it is finite for simple closed curves, but blows up for self-intersecting curves. Therefore, the gradient descent precludes changes in knot type via transverse strand crossing. A “pull-tight” singularity in the limit of an energy minimizing sequence, where a nontrivial part of a composite knot ceases to exist, could still occur. Another central result of Freedman-He-Wang is that prime knot types have Möbius-minimizing parametrizations. The Möbius energy has a coherent history, but we do not intend to provide a full account here. Our understanding of the Möbius energy over the past thirty years is characterized by a sequence of increasingly strong regularity theorems. In [ 5 ] , Freedman-He-Wang show that if E(\gamma)<\infty , then \gamma is C^{1,1} . That is, \gamma is C^{1} with Lipschitz derivative. In [ 7 ] , He expands on this result by proving critical points are C^{\infty} . In a subsequent paper, Blatt shows that E(\gamma)<\infty is equivalent to the condition that \gamma is a simple curve in the fractional Sobolev space H^{\frac{3}{2}}(I,\mathbb{R}^{n}) [ 2 ] . Recently in [ 3 ] , Blatt applies the Cauchy method of majorants to yield the very strong result that if \gamma is a critical point of the Möbius energy, then \gamma is real-analytic. This is the only analyticity result of a nonlocal differential operator to the author’s knowledge. Our choice to study helix curves originates from a non-rigorous heuristic observation regarding the first variation. In [ 5 ] , the authors calculate the Gateaux derivative of the Möbius energy at \gamma , which is a vector field along \gamma , as (2) \displaystyle\nabla E(\gamma)(t)=2\int_{\gamma}\left[\frac{2\text{proj}_{\dot{\gamma}(s)^{\perp}}(\gamma(s)-\gamma(t))}{|\gamma(s)-\gamma(t)|^{2}}-\kappa\textbf{N}_{\gamma(t)}\right]\frac{|\dot{\gamma}(s)|}{|\gamma(s)-\gamma(t)|^{2}}ds. Here, \text{proj}_{\dot{\gamma}(s)^{\perp}} denotes projection onto the plane orthogonal to the tangent \dot{\gamma} and \{\textbf{T},\textbf{N},\textbf{B}\} denotes the Frenet frame. At a fixed t , this integral instructs us to take the difference vector \gamma(s)-\gamma(t) , project away T , subtract away the normal curvature vector \kappa\textbf{N} , while rescaling lengths along the way according to an inverse power law. Then we average by integrating over s . Thus, the Möbius gradient is liable to be large when difference vectors are close to the binormal B , particularly when either a few difference vectors near \gamma(t) align with B well, or a lot of far away difference vectors align with B well. Helix curves fall into the latter case, as the difference vector of a long-distance pair points in nearly the same direction as the helical axis. For a general curve with a subset approximated by a helix, uncoiling the curve (which corresponds to simultaneously performing Reidemeister-I moves) will decelerate its Möbius energy. By studying the asymptotics of the helix, we seek insight into how the Möbius energy varies as a general curve with a sub-arc approximated by a helix coils or uncoils. 1.2. Overview of the main result and its proof A helix has infinite Möbius energy, but it turns out that the energy density is finite. By invariance under rigid screw isometries, we have that the density is uniform across the whole helix. The pitch \rho of a helix, which is the constant ratio of torsion to curvature, is its essential geometric parameter. Hence, we are led to study the relationship between pitch and energy density. Specifically, a helix of pitch 2\pi\rho>0 (we will henceforth instead use the word “pitch” to refer to \rho ) is parametrized by H_{\rho}(t)\coloneq(e^{it},\rho t) in \mathbb{R}^{3} . As \rho\to\infty , the helix unravels to a straight line, uniformly on compact subsets. As \rho\to 0 , the helix coils infinitely tight, converging to a pathological limiting object which is not a curve. Notably, the torsion \tau=\frac{\rho}{\rho^{2}+1}\to 0 in

Read the complete text