Power, Prescription, and Postpositivism: Considerations for collecting and representing neurodiversity demographic information in physics education research
Mason D. Moenter, George R. Keefe, Liam G. McDermott, Erin M. Scanlon · 2026
Read Power, Prescription, and Postpositivism: Considerations for collecting and representing neurodiversity demographic information in physics education research by Mason D. Moenter, George R. Keefe, Liam G. McDermott, Erin M. Scanlon (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-12609.txt.
Introduction
Moenter and three colleagues examine how physics education research gathers and reports neurodiversity data. Current practice often demands official labels rather than letting people name themselves. That blocks true voice for crossing selves and hurts trust in data and reading. Mixed reports across studies further hurt use. Through a review of neurodivergent student lives, they document a wide spread in how data are taken and shown. They call for self-naming and clear write-ups.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mason D. Moenter, George R. Keefe, Liam G. McDermott, Erin M. Scanlon |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22898 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.12609
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Power, Prescription, and Postpositivism: Considerations for collecting and representing neurodiversity demographic information in physics education research Mason D. Moenter, George R. Keefe, Liam G. McDermott, Erin M. Scanlon Abstract Demographic data collection is essential in education research, as demographic data allows researchers to better describe the participant population they study and to contextualize findings. However, current research practices for neurodiversity demographics often rely on prescriptive methods (e.g., requiring participants to report official diagnoses) rather than allowing participants to self-identify. This approach can: a) not allow participants to express their intersecting identities in ways that are authentic; and b) limit trustworthiness and reliability of the data and interpretation. In addition, inconsistent dissemination and representation of demographic data across studies hinder the accessibility and usability of this work. Through a literature review of neurodivergent student experiences with learning and performing STEM, we identified widespread discrepancies in how demographic information is collected and reported. This paper explores how neurodivergent identities can be more accurately and inclusively represented in education research. We present findings of a thematic analysis on the ways neurodivergent demographic data collection is done in the literature using data from a systematic literature review on neurodivergent science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) learning and performance. We call on the PER community to contribute to the development of a framework that centers participant autonomy while supporting clarity, consistency, and future research use. I Introduction "Who do we study when we study Physics Education Research? (PER)" That is the question asked by Kanim and Cid in their paper KanimandCid on the demographic makeup of studies in physics education research (e.g., who do physics education researchers sample from when they study physics learning?). They found that PER overwhelmingly samples from white and wealthy populations, calculus-based courses, and four-year colleges. They also do not mention disability, how ability is represented in PER, or whether or not we even collect data about disabled or neurodivergent students Frazer2017 . Scanlon and Chini ChiniandScanlon conducted a literature review of "the nexus of physics, teaching, and disability" (pp 10) and found 16 sources that did not dis-aggregate impairment types, 8 that focused on multiple impairment categories, and 48 sources focused on specific impairment types. To date, there is no published work which examines the ways neurodivergent people are represented in PER. In an attempt to partially remedy this dearth of research, the authors conducted a literature review of neurodivergent STEM learning and performance with the research question of how are neurodivergent students represented in STEM learning/performance literature? In doing so, the authors found inconsistencies with how we collect and represent demographic data in education research, especially demographic data specific to neurodivergent populations PCAST . Taking both accurate and usable (able to be used by researchers/practitioners to analyze statistics without loss of or gaps in information Collins2016 ; Museus2014 ) demographic data is an ethical obligation Call2022 and a methodological necessity Brookings2020 . In our literature review, we found that often, researchers took a prescriptive rather than a descriptive method of collecting and representing disability demographic data. In the following sections, we make the case for why prescriptive demographics are inappropriate for research involving neurodivergent participants, and why descriptive demographics are ethically and methodologically superior. We present findings of our thematic analysis on the demographic data collection of the data corpus of a systematic literature review on neurodivergent STEM learning and performance. Furthermore, we propose a set of guidelines to make demographic data collection/representation more accessible for researchers, inclusive for research participants, and usable for practitioners. In the following sections we use the words "prescriptivism" and "descriptivism" to describe how neurodivergent demographics are collected and represented in the literature. We specifically borrow these words from linguistics Pinker2003 , as we found them particularly apt for describing what we found in the literature. We define these terms below: • Prescriptivism - applying preconceived normative categories to data with the implication that the applied categories are the "correct" ones. • Descriptivism - using participants’ own words to describe their lived reality. I.1 Neurodiversity, and Identity At the core of any discussion on neurodivergent demographic data is the following question: "what do we mean when we ask ’do you identify as neurodivergent’?" To answer that question, we must also ask: "what does it mean to identify as neurodivergent?" To answer these questions, we turn to the diversity model of disability and post-positivism . The diversity model of disability McDermott2024a ; Dwyer2022 describes disability as an interaction (often a fundamental disconnect) between a person’s innate ways of thinking, doing, and being and their environment. When we say someone identifies as neurodivergent, we mean living and experiencing these fundamental disconnects between the environment and oneself. When we ask "do you identify as neurodivergent?", we unintentionally ask a loaded question. Asking questions in such a manner asserts a categorization (e.g., learning disabled, neurodivergent) and a binary (i.e., someone is either neurodivergent or not) about people’s lives. When we collect data in this way, we prescribe strict bounds on participant identity, which may not be reflective of reality. We make assumptions about participant identity which lead to interpretations based on assumptions which are not necessarily reflective of reality, tainting the impacts the findings and dissemination may have. By taking a postpositivist Fox2008 ; Panhwar2017 approach to analyzing the question "do you identify as neurodivergent?", we must take two key assumptions: 1) participants are actively experiencing a constant re-evaluation and construction of their identity/self based on new ideas, experiences, and situations; and 2) we, as researchers, exist as secondary interpreters of participants’ experiences. It is therefore, perhaps, more reflective of reality to ask " how do you identify as neurodivergent, if at all?" and build pragmatic categories descriptively, from participants’ own words, rather than making assumptions. II Methods II.1 Postionality This project, as a part of Author McDermott’s postdoctoral fellowship project, is led and conceptualized by Author Moenter. Author Moenter is a neurodivergent, white physics graduate student. Author Keefe is a neurotypical, white physics undergraduate, Author McDermott is a neurodivergent, white and queer physics post-doctoral fellow, and Author Scanlon is a white woman with migraines, depression, and anxiety, who is a physics professor and physics education researcher. They are currently conducting a literature review investigating what extant literature says regarding neurodivergent STEM learning and performance. II.2 Data Collection and Analysis This literature review involved Moenter, Keefe, Scanlon, and McDermott sifting through 2,469 sources (peer-reviewed journal articles, conference proceedings, Master’s theses, and Doctoral Dissertations) to arrive at a corpus of 47 sources on neurodivergent undergraduate STEM learning and performance. As a part of data collection, Moenter, Keefe, Scanlon, and McDermott compiled an annotated bibliography which collected, among other things, data on studies’ sample sizes, non-neurodivergent demographic data included in an article, and the neurodivergent demographic data included in an article. We conducted a thematic analysis of the literature to categorize demographic data collection and representation methods. To do this, Moenter and McDermott met to comb through the corpus for demographic data collection discussions. They collaboratively inductively coded the data. While there are other facets of identity that are important to attend to, the findings present in this paper are representative of trends in neurodivergent undergraduate STEM learning and performance