Simulating the jittering-jets explosion mechanism: Supernova remnant G11.2-0.3

Muhammad Akashi, Noam Soker · 2026

Read Simulating the jittering-jets explosion mechanism: Supernova remnant G11.2-0.3 by Muhammad Akashi, Noam Soker (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-12356.txt.

Introduction

Akashi and Soker simulate a collapsing star exploding through three pairs of jittering jets, then compare the wreckage with remnant G11.2-0.3. The first wide jets trigger the blast and squeeze gas into a shell and a flat plane. The second pair clears that plane except for a dense bar, while narrow third jets punch through to form two opposite rings. The match supports the jittering-jets picture, since rival models struggle to explain such point-symmetric remnants.

Catalog record

CREATORMuhammad Akashi, Noam Soker
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26042
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.12356

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Simulating the jittering-jets explosion mechanism: Supernova remnant G11.2-0.3 Muhammad Akashi, Noam Soker Abstract We hydrodynamically simulate a core-collapse supernova (CCSN) explosion by launching three pairs of jets in the framework of the jittering-jets explosion mechanism (JJEM), and reproduce a morphology of two opposite circum-jet rings and a bar of dense gas perpendicular to the rings’ axis, resembling these morphological features in the CCSN remnant SNR G11.2-0.3. The first pair of wide jets is very energetic; it triggers the explosion and inflates two bubbles that compress the material in an expanding shell. The bubbles also compress material in a plane perpendicular to the jet axis. The second pair of wide jets removes material from this plane, beside along a bar that is on an axis perpendicular to the two pairs’ axes. The jets of the third pair, now of narrow jets, penetrate the expanding shell and compress material to their sides to form two opposite rings. These morphological features are qualitatively similar to those observed in the point-symmetric CCSNN remnant G11.2-0.3. As competing theoretical CCSN explosion mechanisms cannot explain point-symmetric CCSN remnants, our study provides support for the claim that the JJEM is the primary explosion mechanism of CCSNe. I Introduction There are two intensively studied theoretical explosion mechanisms aiming to explain the majority of core-collapse supernova (CCSN) explosions: The neutrino-driven (delayed-neutrino; neutrino heating) explosion mechanism (e.g., 8 ; 19 ; 24 ; 32 ; 43 ; 45 ; 50 ; 55 ; 57 ; 62 ; 90 ; 93 for some papers from 2026), and the jittering-jets explosion mechanism (JJEM; e.g., 85 ; 87 ; 86 , for papers from 2026); for earlier reviews, see, e.g., 82 for the JJEM, and 37 for the delayed-neutrino mechanism, and 83 for the relation between them, and to other rare explosion mechanisms and other energy sources in CCSNe. In the JJEM, several to about twenty pairs of jets with fully or partially stochastic variations in their axes explode the star. Intermittent accretion disks around the newly born neutron star (NS) launch the jittering jets. The pre-collapse core rotation introduces a fixed angular momentum component to the accreted gas, while the pre-collapse core convection introduces the stochastic component (e.g., 78 ). According to the assumption of the JJEM, vortices in the convection zones of the collapsing core seed instabilities above the NS (for some studies of these types of instabilities see, e.g., 2 ; 39 ; 18 ) that amplify the stochastic angular momentum fluctuations (e.g., 70 ; 91 ; 92 ). The jets that explode the star in the framework of the JJEM might leave imprints on CCSN remnants (CCSNRs) in the form of jet-shaped morphological features, particularly point-symmetric morphologies. Point-symmetrical morphologies are misaligned pairs of opposite structural features (e.g., 69 ). The structural features might include rings, lobes, bubbles, clumps, filaments, nozzles, and ears, as three-dimensional (3D) hydrodynamic simulations of the JJEM have recently shown ( 16 ; 72 ; 7 ; 73 ) . In general, the jittering jets are not relativistic ( 35 argued that most CCSNe have no relativistic jets, unlike those of gamma ray bursts, e.g., 36 ; 1 ). The morphologies of some CCSNRs exhibit one, two, or three very powerful pairs of jets, where in some cases the two jets in a pair differ substantially in their energy and momentum (e.g., 11 ; 68 ). Each energetic pair of jets can excite a strong shock in the exploding star, leading to a photospheric shell in the early stages of the explosion. Two or more energetic pairs can, therefore, form two or more photospheric shells that observations might reveal in the first days to weeks of the explosion. 74 identified two (or possibly three) photospheric shells in SN 2023ixf (based on observation by 95 ), and 67 identified two photospheric shells in SN 2024ggi (based on observations by 20 ). At present, CCSNRs’ morphologies are the only observable that can robustly distinguish between the two theoretical explosion mechanisms (e.g., 81 ; 82 ), and they clearly support the JJEM (e.g., 13 ; 75 ; 71 ; 84 ; 83 ), and severely challenge the neutrino-driven mechanism, which cannot explain these morphologies. Hydrodynamical simulations of CCSNRs in the framework of the neutrino-driven mechanism do not address point-symmetric morphologies (e.g., 52 ; 51 ; 53 ; 54 ). Therefore, it is utmost important to study the morphologies of CCSNRs and compare them with the predictions of the two theoretical explosion mechanisms. In this study, we conduct JJEM simulations with three pairs of jets to explain the rings and the bar of SNR 11.2-0.3. In 7 , we reproduced the pair of rings of SNR 11.2-0.3. Here we add one pair of jets to explain the bar of this SNR, i.e., a bright X-ray bar extending across the SNR through its center. We do not aim to explain all features of this CCSNR. In particular, we do not add a pair of jets to explain the second jet axis observed in this CCSNR. The approach we take is the one that has been successfully used in the study of planetary nebulae and which has lead to a deep understanding of the shaping of a rich variety of jet-shaped planetary nebula morphologies (e.g., 49 ; 76 ; 66 ; 6 ; 25 ; 89 ; 9 ; 28 ; 29 ; 21 ; 59 ; 22 ; 48 ; 3 ; 23 ; 47 ; 64 ; 44 ), including precessing jets (e.g., 34 ; 46 ; 63 ; 14 ; 88 ; 60 ; 33 ; 21 ); for a recent review on PNe see 40 . The first step is an eye inspection and a qualitative classification of planetary nebulae and their morphological features (e.g., 10 ; 58 ; 65 ; 41 ). This qualitative approach yields a robust identification of jet-shaped morphological features (e.g., 66 ), which motivate and guide jet-shaped hydrodynamical numerical simulations. The qualitative and partially quantitative comparisons of simulations with observations over the years (e.g., 4 ; 29 ; 30 ; 27 ; 5 ; 38 and references to earlier studies therein) have established jets as a major player in powering and shaping planetary nebula outflows. Considering the many morphological similarities between CCSNRs and planetary nebulae (e.g., 12 ; 80 ), the systematic study of morphological features that 3D hydrodynamical simulations of jets give against those observed in CCSNRs became a major task in studying the JJEM (e.g., 16 ; 72 ; 7 ; 73 ). We summarize the main ingredients of our numerical setting in Section II ; more details are in 7 . In Section III we describe the bar and rings we obtain, and in Section IV we compare our results to the bar and rings of SNR G11.2-0.3. We summarize this study in Section V . II The numerical settings II.1 Initial model Our numerical setting is very similar to that in 7 , where more details can be found; here we describe the basic properties of the numerical setting. The main difference is that we add another pair of wide jets here. In 7 , we launched two consecutive pairs of conical jets into the core and obtained two opposite

Read the complete text