Necessary conditions for causality from linearized stability at ultra-high boosts

Shuvayu Roy, Sukanya Mitra, Rajeev Singh · 2026

Read Necessary conditions for causality from linearized stability at ultra-high boosts by Shuvayu Roy, Sukanya Mitra, Rajeev Singh (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-12291.txt.

Introduction

Roy, Mitra and Singh look for a shortcut to test whether a relativistic fluid theory respects causality. They exploit a quirk of boosted frames, where higher-order wave terms fade at near-light speeds. Stability at zero wave number can then reveal the causal region, even for waves of nonzero momentum. They test the idea on conformal Müller-Israel-Stewart theory and recover the required causality conditions while staying inside the theory's low-energy range.

Catalog record

CREATORShuvayu Roy, Sukanya Mitra, Rajeev Singh
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66166
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.12291

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Necessary conditions for causality from linearized stability at ultra-high boosts Shuvayu Roy, Sukanya Mitra, Rajeev Singh Abstract In this work, we provide a novel method to constrain the causal parameter space of a relativistic hydrodynamic system exclusively from its linear stability analysis at non-zero momenta. Our approach exploits the Lorentz-invariant stability property of causal theories. In boosted frames, the dispersion relation exhibits a feature that we call “ γ \gamma -suppression,” whereby the higher-order terms in the wavenumber expansion are increasingly suppressed beyond leading order at large boosts. As a consequence, at near-luminal values of Lorentz boost, stability criteria at the spatially homogeneous limit are sufficient to identify the region of the parameter space that satisfies the necessary conditions of causality, even at non-zero momenta. After presenting the general hydrodynamic framework, we test the method in conformal Müller-Israel-Stewart theory and show that it provides an efficient way of deriving the necessary conditions of causality while remaining within the low-energy regime of hydrodynamic validity. I Introduction To describe collective systems that can be coarse-grained from an underlying microscopic formulation, effective field theories have proven useful across a range of physical systems. Relativistic hydrodynamics 42 is one such effective theory that finds applications ranging from high-energy physics (facilitated by heavy-ion experiments) 3 ; 36 ; 26 ; 20 ; 13 to astrophysical problems involving neutron stars 2 and cosmological dark matter 15 . It is a low-energy, long-wavelength limit of its microscopic origin, i.e., an “infrared approximation” considering that the high-energy parts of the original solutions are small and do not include fast-growing modes. The physical acceptance of such a theory relies on several benchmark criteria. Some of the major ones state that the governing equations must obey (i) sub-luminal signal propagation, i.e., causality conditions, and (ii) perturbations around equilibrium being bounded over time (not growing indefinitely), i.e., stability criteria 50 ; 30 ; 31 ; 44 . Relativistic hydrodynamic theory is generally formulated via systematic derivative corrections to include dissipative phenomena over the ideal fluid theory (leading term) 47 ; 39 . Due to the introduction of dissipation, gradient-corrected theories of relativistic fluids encounter pathologies 32 ; 6 . The two conditions mentioned above can be used to impose the required constraints of physical applicability over a possibly large number of candidate theories. This is the reason that the analysis of causality and stability constraints for a given theory in terms of its parameter space (set by the transport coefficients of the underlying theory) is crucial and has become a growing field of current studies 18 ; 45 ; 14 ; 5 ; 7 ; 40 ; 33 ; 11 ; 12 . Furthermore, the interconnectedness between these two apparently distinct features has led to fascinating recent studies in the context of the frame-invariant properties of a relativistic dissipative hydrodynamic theory 28 ; 24 ; 21 ; 23 ; 22 ; 51 ; 34 ; 35 . Traditionally, the analysis of causality within the scope of a linearized theory (in the sense of its perturbations) belongs to the physics of its large momenta (large wavenumber) 34 . In this context, the asymptotic causality condition is widely used to check the causal validity of a hydrodynamic theory, which states that the group velocity of a propagating mode at the infinite wavenumber limit must not exceed the speed of light. Several studies 19 ; 41 ; 45 argue that the asymptotic group velocity being sub-luminal preserves the causality of a theory as a whole, even if it diverges for some intermediate values of momenta (as long as it is restricted to a finite range), since the Fourier transform of a linear signal has significant contributions from large wavenumbers ( k ). The issue with this analysis is that this large-momentum treatment is well outside the domain of validity for hydrodynamics as a low-energy effective theory. Hydrodynamic gradient expansion, being a divergent series with a zero radius of convergence 46 ; 27 ; 29 has little ability to reproduce the large-momentum behavior of the underlying UV (ultra-violet) complete theory. Our current work attempts to derive the causal parameter space of a given theory without leaving the low-momentum regime of relativistic hydrodynamics. To explore the causal parameter space of a relativistic hydrodynamic theory in the low wavenumber limit, we use the property of frame-invariant stability of a theory. The linearized hydrodynamic theory is known to face the paradox that small perturbations around equilibrium could lead to stable solutions in one reference frame but become unstable in another. Recently, it has been shown that this stability-invariance issue has profound consequences for causality, which is rigorously studied in Refs. 24 ; 21 ; 34 ; 9 . The agreement on stability between Lorentz-boosted observers depends on how the non-hydrodynamic modes are introduced to restore causality 4 ; 8 ; 25 . In a nutshell, causality is a necessary condition for covariant stability to hold and violating causality results in disagreement between different observers on whether a dissipative system is stable or not. Following this line of argument, in this work, we utilize the covariantly stable parameter space to identify the causal domain of the theory without leaving the small k -limit. In Ref. 48 , we have already introduced this alternate way of deriving the causal parameter space at the spatially homogeneous limit ( k\rightarrow 0 ) of the theory. There, we analyzed the stability-invariance of the dispersion modes (frequencies) at the leading order in k . This means that, in any arbitrary boosted frame, if a dispersion mode \omega is expressed by the following expansion in terms of momenta k , \omega=\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}a_{n}k^{n}~,\quad a_{n}={\text{constant coefficients}}, (1) only the leading term a_{0} has been analyzed there to derive the causal parameter space at k\rightarrow 0 limit. The inclusion of the non-vanishing wavenumber in the stability analysis of Fourier modes is known to be quite non-trivial (especially in boosted frames), even if we restrict ourselves to small values of k and truncate the dispersion series ( 1 ) to a certain low order in k . In continuation with our recent work 10 , we show here that in an arbitrary moving frame with boost velocity v , the k expanded dispersion series exhibits a behavior termed “ \gamma -suppression”, which significantly improves the situation. This can be expressed as the following, \omega=\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}a_{n}\left\{\frac{k}{\gamma}\right\}^{n},\quad\gamma=\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-v^{2}}}~. (2) In a reference frame moving with near-luminal boost velocity ( v\rightarrow 1 ), this suppression becomes sufficiently strong to make the next-to-leading order terms in ( 2 ) practically insignificant. So, in near-luminal Lorentz frames, the mode analysis and, consequently, the stability constraints reduce to that of the spatially homogeneous limit ( k\rightarrow 0 ), where the treatment of only the leading term suffices for the analysis. We show for the causal Müller-Israel-Stewart (MIS) theory 38 ; 37 ; 43 that at the v\rightarrow 1 limit, the stable parameter space remains the same as for k\rightarrow 0 , irrespective of the non-zero values of k or the order of k considered in the dispersion series ( 2 ). Now, since for any causal theory, for every k , there must be a common region of parameter space that is stable at all v (including v\rightarrow

Read the complete text