What Makes a Word Hard to Learn? Modeling L1 Influence on English Vocabulary Difficulty

Jonas Mayer Martins Zhuojing Huang Aaricia Herygers Lisa Beinborn · 2026

Read What Makes a Word Hard to Learn? Modeling L1 Influence on English Vocabulary Difficulty by Jonas Mayer Martins Zhuojing Huang Aaricia Herygers Lisa Beinborn (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-12281.txt.

Introduction

Jonas Mayer Martins and three colleagues model what makes English words hard to learn for speakers of Spanish, German, or Chinese. Using gradient-boosted models on cues for known-ness, meaning, surface form, and cross-language transfer, they rank cue groups with Shapley values. Familiarity leads for all three groups. Spanish- and German-speaking learners rely on spelling transfer, missing for Chinese learners, whose difficulty follows familiarity plus surface cues alone. The models give clear, first-language-fitted hardness scores for making word lessons.

Catalog record

CREATORJonas Mayer Martins Zhuojing Huang Aaricia Herygers Lisa Beinborn
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58750
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.12281

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

What Makes a Word Hard to Learn? Modeling L1 Influence on English Vocabulary Difficulty Jonas Mayer Martins Zhuojing Huang Aaricia Herygers Lisa Beinborn Abstract What makes a word difficult to learn, and how does the difficulty depend on the learner’s native language? We computationally model vocabulary difficulty for English learners whose first language is Spanish, German, or Chinese with gradient-boosted models trained on features related to a word’s familiarity (e.g., frequency), meaning, surface form, and cross-linguistic transfer. Using Shapley values, we determine the importance of each feature group. Word familiarity is the dominant feature group shared by all three languages. However, predictions for Spanish- and German-speaking learners rely additionally on orthographic transfer. This transfer mechanism is unavailable to Chinese learners, whose difficulty is shaped by a combination of familiarity and surface features alone. Our models provide interpretable, L1-tailored difficulty estimates that can be used to design vocabulary curricula. Code repository and interactive demo 1 Introduction Learning a second language begins with words. Developing an extensive vocabulary is essential for mastering grammar and achieving fluency ( Schmitt and Schmitt 2020 ; Nation 2000 ) . Yet not all words are equally hard to learn, and researchers of second-language (L2) acquisition, classroom practitioners, and creators of educational materials seek to better understand this phenomenon. The difficulty of a word is partially due to factors common to all learners, that is, lexical properties that depend only on the target language itself ( Peters 2019 ) . For example, common and concrete words are easier to acquire than rare and abstract ones ( Ellis 2002 ; Ellis and Beaton 1993 ) . However, a learner’s individual background—their first language (L1), in particular—plays a key role in word difficulty ( Ringbom and Jarvis 2009 ) . For instance, a German speaker readily infers that the English word “sheep” is related to the cognate Schaf , whereas the Spanish oveja is not a cognate. 1 1 1 Instead, oveja is distantly related to “ewe” , meaning female sheep, in English. This orthographic bridge supports active as well as passive vocabulary competence. Conversely, false friends may lead to interfering transfer ( Bensoussan and Laufer 1984 ) . For example, bravo in Spanish is close to its English cognate “brave” , yet brav in German means “well-behaved” . The same English word can thus be easy for one learner while difficult for another, depending on the relationship between the L1 and L2. However, computational models of lexical difficulty often fail to take a learner’s background into account. The SemEval2021 shared task on lexical-complexity prediction, for example, considers difficulty for unspecified annotators ( Shardlow et al. 2021 ) . Meanwhile, predictions of lexical difficulty tailored to individual learners are receiving increasing attention ( Palmero Aprosio et al. 2020 ; North et al. 2023 ; Schmitt et al. 2021 ; Skidmore et al. 2025 ) , yet studies that do include L1 effects often remain limited to a single language pair. Approach and contributions. Figure 1: Illustration of the task and modeling setup. For each L1, learners translate a word (e.g., Kabel ) from their L1 into English given the first letter ( c ) and a graphical hint indicating the number of characters. Item difficulty is estimated from aggregated responses (gold label). We train L1-specific models on feature groups (familiarity, meaning, and form = surface \cup transfer). By evaluating the feature importance, we assign a relative importance in the prediction of a word to each feature group. We address this gap by modeling English vocabulary difficulty separately for Spanish, German, and Chinese 2 2 2 In this article, we refer to Mandarin Chinese as Chinese. L1 speakers, using the Knowledge-based Vocabulary Lists (KVL), a recent crowd-sourced corpus of lexical-difficulty tests ( Schmitt et al. 2021 ; Skidmore et al. 2025 ) , in the context of the closed track of the Building Educational Applications (BEA) 2026 shared task ( Felice and Skidmore 2026 ) . We create four feature groups: the familiarity of a word based on exposure effects, its meaning based on semantic complexity and concreteness, its surface form based on orthographic complexity, and its transferability from a specific L1 based on string similarity. We train interpretable, gradient-boosted models on these features to predict L1-dependent lexical difficulty and trace their predictive power via Shapley values. Figure 1 illustrates the task format and our approach. To showcase our results and support further research and practical use, we have created an interactive demo that extends our predictions to more than 4,000 to 7,000 additional English words per language, see Appendix A and Appendix B . This demo highlights the advantage of our computational modeling approach, which allows us to make predictions beyond the limited KVL data for a larger range of vocabulary and potentially more L1 backgrounds, providing tailored difficulty estimates applicable to curriculum design. 2 Related work In this section, we discuss factors of word difficulty in a foreign language based on second-language-learning studies and computational models. 2.1 Lexical difficulty Vocabulary knowledge poses a fundamental challenge to all second-language (L2) learners ( Schmitt and Schmitt 2020 ; Nation 2000 ) . However, the difficulty associated with a particular word varies by learner. Some words, for instance, represent intrinsically difficult concepts in the target language, while others are challenging or easy specifically due to a learner’s L1 background. L2-intrinsic difficulty. The more frequent a stimulus occurs, the more readily it tends to be recalled, and as such, frequent words are learned more easily because learners encounter them more often ( Ellis 2002 ; Peters 2019 ) . Educational curricula typically introduce frequent words first to enable learners to speak and understand the target language earlier by efficiently building vocabulary coverage ( Nation 2000 ) . Beyond frequency, other lexical properties are also important. For instance, orthographic complexity has been shown to predict exercise difficulty ( Beinborn et al. 2016 ) . Additionally, homonymous or polysemous words are typically harder to process and acquire than words with just one meaning ( Bensoussan and Laufer 1984 ) . Psycholinguistic features, such as the age of acquisition ( Kuperman et al. 2012 ; Dascalu et al. 2016 ) and concreteness of the word ( Ellis and Beaton 1993 ; Van Hell and Mahn 1997 ; De Groot and Keijzer 2000 ) , are important factors for word difficulty prediction, too. The initial letter plays a disproportionate role in word recognition and production: speakers in tip-of-the-tongue states often remember the first letter and phonological primes aid retrieval ( Brown and McNeill 1966 ; James and Burke 2000 ) . L1-specific difficulty. Beyond L2-intrinsic word properties, difficulty is shaped by the learner’s first language. Learners draw on L1 knowledge when acquiring an L2 vocabulary, with positive transfer where the languages are similar and interference where surface similarity is misleading ( Odlin 1989 ) . At the lexical level, cognateness is a well-studied transfer mechanism. Cognates reduce learning effort because learners can map the L2 target onto the well-known L1 form: De Groot and Keijzer 2000 show that cognateness predicts L2-vocabulary retention, and Beinborn et al. 2014 find that learners infer the meaning of unfamiliar words more readily when there is a cognate in their L1.

Read the complete text