Comparison of the hadronic vacuum polarization between
hadronic · 2026
Read Comparison of the hadronic vacuum polarization between by hadronic (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-12205.txt.
Introduction
Noah Allen and five colleagues compare hadronic vacuum polarization from lattice QCD and tau-decay data. They use isospin-symmetric lattice results against a dispersive account from inclusive tau decay data corrected for isospin breaking. The comparison spans polarization at squared momenta from 0.5 to 12 GeV squared. It also covers the light-quark share of the muon magnetic moment and its short-, intermediate-, and long-distance window parts. Agreement is good, but tau-based window values for the two four-pion modes differ from Pais-relation expectations for one mode.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | hadronic |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67589 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.12205
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comparison of the hadronic vacuum polarization between hadronic Abstract We compare the isospin-one, vector-current hadronic vacuum polarization (HVP) obtained from isospin-symmetric lattice QCD with that obtained from a dispersive representation employing inclusive hadronic \tau decay data corrected for isospin breaking. We consider the subtracted HVP evaluated at squared Euclidean momenta ranging from 0.5 GeV 2 to 12 GeV 2 , together with the light-quark-connected HVP contribution to the muon anomalous magnetic moment and the short-, intermediate- and long-distance RBC/UKQCD window components thereof. Dispersive contributions from the region of hadronic invariant masses above the \tau mass are evaluated using perturbative QCD. We also consider dispersive determinations using \tau data only for contributions from two-pion, or two-pion and four-pion, modes, and evaluating the remaining contributions using exclusive-mode e^{+}e^{-}\to\mbox{hadrons} cross sections up to about 2 GeV, lessening the dependence on perturbation theory. We find generally good agreement between lattice and \tau -based results. However, a comparison of \tau -based window-quantity contributions for the two four-pion modes to expectations for those contributions based on the Pais relations and e^{+}e^{-} four-pion cross sections, reveals significant differences for the 2\pi^{-}\pi^{+}\pi^{0} mode. I Introduction Because of the recent high-precision measurement of the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon a_{\mu}=(g-2)/2 Muong-2:2006rrc ; Muong-2:2025xyk , there has been much interest in the hadronic vacuum polarization (HVP) contribution a_{\mu}^{\rm HVP} , which plays a crucial role in the determination of the Standard Model (SM) expectation for a_{\mu} . The reason is that, at present, the error on a_{\mu}^{\rm HVP} strongly dominates the total error on the SM expectation WP25 . Moreover, there are large discrepancies between the estimate for a_{\mu}^{\rm HVP} from lattice QCD and dispersive estimates obtained from the R -ratio measured in e^{+}e^{-}\to\mbox{hadrons}(\gamma) WP25 , with the exception of those using CMD-3 results for the two-pion exclusive-mode contribution CMD3 . These discrepancies can be traced to the exclusive electroproduction mode e^{+}e^{-}\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-} , for which there are significant differences in the cross section in the region around the \rho peak. Because this exclusive mode has isospin 1, data for the dispersive analysis can also be obtained from the decay \tau^{-}\to\pi^{-}\pi^{0}\nu_{\tau} , if one can reliably correct for the differences in isospin breaking (IB) between the two processes. Much effort has gone into this approach; for a partial list of references, see Refs. Davier:2023fpl ; Davier:2010fmf ; Masjuan:2023qsp ; Castro:2024prg ; Colangelo:2022prz ; Hoferichter:2023sli ; Davier:2025jiq ; CCHH and other references therein. In this paper, while also considering the question of to what extent information from hadronic \tau decays can help provide additional insight, we take a slightly different approach, focusing on the facts that (i) the I=1 contribution to a_{\mu}^{\rm HVP} can be obtained from the inclusive vector isovector spectral function obtained from non-strange vector hadronic \tau decays, and (ii) in the isospin limit, the I=1 contribution to a_{\mu}^{\rm HVP} is directly related to the light-quark connected (lqc) contribution computed in isospin-symmetric lattice QCD: a_{\mu}^{\rm HVP,lqc}=\frac{10}{9}\,a_{\mu}^{{\rm HVP},I=1}\ . (1) Our primary goal is to use hadronic \tau -decay data in the vector isovector channel, and to compare results based on these data with results obtained from lattice QCD. The quantities we are interested in are a_{\mu}^{\rm HVP,lqc} , the lqc parts of the window quantities defined in Ref. RBC18 , and values for the I=1 component of the subtracted vacuum polarization {\overline{\Pi}}(Q^{2}) as a function of Euclidean momentum Q which contributes to the running of the electromagnetic (EM) coupling \alpha , and for which values were obtained in lattice QCD Mainz25 ; BMW20 . Results for the lqc intermediate window are of particular interest given that the largest of the discrepancies between pre-CMD-3 dispersive and lattice results was observed for this quantity Benton:2023dci . Most lattice computations of a_{\mu}^{\rm HVP,lqc} are carried out in the “time-momentum” representation BM , in which a_{\mu}^{\rm HVP,lqc} is expressed as a weighted integral over the zero-spatial-momentum current-current correlator C^{I=1}(t) , where t is the Euclidean time. This correlator can be obtained from a Laplace transform of the inclusive vector isovector spectral function, \rho_{V}^{I=1}(s) , where s is the hadronic invariant mass-squared. For squared invariant masses s\leq m_{\tau}^{2} , \rho_{V}^{I=1}(s) can be obtained from the differential distributions measured in non-strange hadronic \tau decays. For s>m_{\tau}^{2} , where no such experimental data are available, we determine \rho_{V}^{I=1}(s) using perturbation theory (PT) to fifth order in the strong coupling \alpha_{s}(m_{\tau}^{2}) PT , 1 1 1 Only an estimate of the fifth-order term is known, see Eq. ( 11 ). employing a model to estimate uncertainties due to residual quark-hadron duality violations in that region. For the \tau -based input for \rho_{V}^{I=1}(s) in the region s\leq m_{\tau}^{2} , we use the results of Ref. us25 . These were obtained by combining \tau -decay data from ALEPH ALEPH ; ALEPH2 ; ALEPH13 , OPAL OPAL and Belle Belle for the two-pion and from ALEPH and OPAL for the four-pion contributions, with the small contributions from other (“residual”) modes obtained using exclusive-mode electroproduction data (for a detailed explanation of how this was done, see Ref. alphas20 ), with the exception of the K^{-}K^{0} mode, for which \tau -decay data from Ref. babarkkbartau18 was used. 2 2 2 A complete list of references used in estimating residual-mode contributions, can be found in Ref. alphas20 . The resulting \rho_{V}^{I=1}(s) is the most precise vector isovector inclusive spectral function available at present that does not involve data from e^{+}e^{-} to two or four pions. As we will see in this paper, in addition to the well-known discrepancies between \tau\to\mbox{hadrons} -based and e^{+}e^{-}\to\mbox{hadrons} -based two-pion distributions, there appear to be further discrepancies between \tau and electroproduction results for the four-pion modes. In making comparisons between \tau - and electroproduction-based results, we will use the 2019 (“KNT19”) versions of the exclusive-mode electroproduction R(s) contributions produced and made available to us by the authors of Ref. KNT19 . The lattice results we will compare with have been computed in “isoQCD,” which is QCD without EM corrections, and in the limit m_{u}=m_{d} , defined such that the pion mass is equal to the neutral pion mass. We will use the definition of isoQCD specified in Ref. FLAG , which is sufficiently close to the scheme used in Ref. WP25 ; differences between these two schemes are negligible. The inclusive \tau -decay data we employ have already been corrected by the short-distance electroweak factor S_{\rm EW} erlersew , but this is not the only source of IB in the \tau data, and we will need to correct the \tau -based results for these additional IB contributions before comparing with isoQCD lattice results. 3 3 3 While EM and strong IB corrections have been computed or estimated by various lattice-QCD collaborations, these corrections have only been considered for the EM current correlator, and not for the charged I=1 , vector current case relevant for \tau decays. This paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II we provide definitions and collect the theory results we need for our analysis. In particular, in Sec. II.3 we give a detailed description of our treatment of IB in the \tau data. In Sec. III we describe in more detail all data we employ, with emphasis on the data for \tau\to 2\pi^{-}\pi^{+}\pi^{0}\nu_{\tau} and