Non-LTE atmosphere models of very luminous sources and their applicability to Little Red Dots, quasi-stars, and similar objects Preprint: Fabrice Martins

Fabrice Martins, Daniel Schaerer, Rui Marques-Chaves · 2026

Read Non-LTE atmosphere models of very luminous sources and their applicability to Little Red Dots, quasi-stars, and similar objects Preprint: Fabrice Martins by Fabrice Martins, Daniel Schaerer, Rui Marques-Chaves (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-12141.txt.

Introduction

Fabrice Martins, Daniel Schaerer, and Rui Marques-Chaves test whether star-atmosphere models can mimic Little Red Dot spectra. Using the CMFGEN code, they compute spherical, expanding, non-LTE models for bright sources, with temperatures from 5000 to 12000 kelvin and luminosity near ten billion suns. The models give blue spectra, hydrogen lines shaped by electron scattering, and a smooth spectrum near the Balmer and Paschen limits. Little Red Dot spectra match when dust dims them by 1.9 to 2.7 magnitudes, though the models struggle to pair a Balmer break with strong lines.

Catalog record

CREATORFabrice Martins, Daniel Schaerer, Rui Marques-Chaves
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68800
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.12141

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Non-LTE atmosphere models of very luminous sources and their applicability to Little Red Dots, quasi-stars, and similar objects Preprint: Fabrice Martins Fabrice Martins, Daniel Schaerer, Rui Marques-Chaves Abstract Context. The spectral properties of Little Red Dots (LRDs) differ from those of active galactic nuclei. LRDs may be the first stage of supermassive black holes formation, where the central engine is hidden in a dense gas reservoir, being de-facto quasi-stars. Aims. We investigate whether atmosphere models traditionally used for massive stars with strong winds can produce synthetic spectra morphologically similar to those of LRDs. Methods. We compute atmosphere models and synthetic spectra with the code CMFGEN. The models assume a thermalized radiation field at the inner boundary, parameterized by a temperature varying between 5000 and 12000 K. We adopt a typical luminosity of 10 10 L ☉ . The models are spherical, assume an expanding atmosphere, and are computed under non-LTE conditions and for several metallicities. Results. The spectral energy distribution (SED) is different from a blackbody, with a blue optical spectrum. Broad hydrogen emission lines are produced, their wings being formed by electron scattering. The SED near the Balmer and Paschen limit is rather continuous. A Balmer break is predicted for the coolest temperature models provided the wind density is reduced. The SED and Balmer decrement of most LRDs is reproduced by the models, provided they are dust-attenuated with Av ∼ \sim 1.9-2.7. Assuming the absorbed luminosity is re-radiated in the infrared, the energy output at these wavelengths is consistent with observational constraints. The models predict Fe ii , oxygen and calcium lines. O i lines at 8446 Å and 1.129 μ \mu m are produced mostly by Ly β \beta fluorescence. The strength of emission lines from metals depends on input temperature, metallicity, and details of the radiative transfer models. Conclusions. CMFGEN atmosphere models predict a large number of spectral properties observed in many LRDs. They struggle to simultaneously produce a genuine Balmer break and strong emission lines. Whether they are more relevant or not to explain LRDs’ spectra compared to alternative models is unclear, leaving open the question of the physical conditions in LRDs. 1 Introduction The physical nature of Little Red Dots (LRD) discovered by JWST ( 77 ) remains elusive. They are characterized by a point source morphology, a red optical spectrum associated with a blue ultraviolet (UV) component, producing a typical V-shape spectral morphology ( 99 ; 30 ; 27 ) , and very often broad emission lines ( 1 ; 44 ; 27 ) among which H \alpha is particularly remarkable. Mostly found at redshifts beyond 3 ( 1 ; 44 ) , a few examples have nevertheless been detected locally ( 63 ; 48 ) . For these latter cases, as well as a couple of bright LRDs ( 56 ; 59 ) , high resolution spectroscopy reveals a rich spectrum of emission and absorption metallic lines including O i , Fe ii , Ca ii , Na i , N ii . Within this global picture, LRDs tend to show spectral diversity ( 6 ; 92 ; 10 ) with important variations in the morphology of the V-shape, the strength of broad lines and the presence or not of specific metallic lines. LRDs were initially interpreted as dust-obscured AGNs or old stellar populations, but these scenarios quickly faced major limitations. The absence of X-ray detection, weak or even no spectral variability, and upper limits on the mid infrared emission are not consistent with the presence of type I AGNs ( 115 ; 57 ; 17 ; 68 ; 117 ; 100 ; 112 ; 65 ) . In addition the black hole (BH) masses inferred from the H \alpha width are orders of magnitudes larger than expected from classical relations between stellar and BH masses in galaxies ( 69 ; 53 ) . And the stellar masses required to explain the observed optical and infrared fluxes exceed what is conceivable for mass assembly in the early Universe ( 58 ; 1 ) . An alternative explanation for these newly discovered, intriguing astrophysical objects is that they may be supermassive black-holes enshrouded in a dense gas envelope ( 55 ; 85 ; 46 ; 26 ) . As such they are also referred to as BH stars and are described by the quasi-stars model presented by 8 . In the quasi-star model a BH inside a dense envelope grows by accretion at a high rate and radiates energy at a luminosity corresponding to that of the BH plus envelope mass ( 94 , see also) . Refinements of this model by 7 predict that several of the observational properties of LRDs are qualitatively reproduced. In particular the spectral energy distribution (SED) shape would be due to the low temperature of the ionized envelope. A high density of free electrons would cause scattering that could account for the broad Balmer lines ( 95 ; 22 ) . The high gas density would absorb all X-ray photons. To describe the shape of LRD spectra at \lambda\ga 4000 Å several studies relied on blackbodies with a temperature of \sim 4000-7000 K, and modifications of the blackbody ( 26 ) . To first order, this reproduces the general shape of the SED, with a peak in the optical and a drop at shorter wavelength, mimicking the red part of the V-shape SED of LRDs. The rest-UV emission is attributed to an independent stellar population from the host galaxy, as also suggested my numerous other studies ( 46 ; 55 ; 104 , e.g.) . Alternatively, 96 used stellar models for evolved stars. They show that the continuum can be broadly recovered by models with low gravity and effective temperatures typical of F- and G-type stars, as also suggested by 48 . 64 reach similar conclusions with a similar type of stellar models. In addition they produce absorption lines from calcium that are qualitatively consistent with those observed in some LRDs. The stellar models of 96 and 64 adopt a plane-parallel geometry and LTE conditions. 103 dropped these assumptions in their ”cocoon” models which are based on a dynamical and extended envelope, illuminated by a blackbody with T\sim 10^{5} K to describe emission from accretion onto a central object. They show that under certain conditions on the neutral hydrogen density and column density a Balmer break is observed together with broad hydrogen emission lines. Other models investigated the reprocessing of an incident SED characteristic of active galactic nuclei (AGN) through a slab of dense gas ( 45 ; 85 ; 107 ; 49 ; 90 ) . The photoionization code CLOUDY ( 37 ) is used and provides the transmitted spectrum. The input AGN spectrum is either an analytical model or an empirical spectrum. These models are able to explain the optical spectrum of LRDs, especially the Balmer break-like feature, by hydrogen atom collisionally excited in their n=2 level, providing a large opacity in the Balmer continuum. No or little dust absorption is required, and emission lines are predicted. Scattering is generally invoked to explain the width of H \alpha ( 49 ) . Fe ii lines are formed in the outer layers of the covering slab (

Read the complete text