Quantitative comparison of heat flow, guarded-heater and AC Harman methods for thermoelectric module efficiency Preprint: APS/123-QED

K. Okawa, Y. Amagai, N. Sakamoto, N.-H. Kaneko · 2026

Read Quantitative comparison of heat flow, guarded-heater and AC Harman methods for thermoelectric module efficiency Preprint: APS/123-QED by K. Okawa, Y. Amagai, N. Sakamoto, N.-H. Kaneko (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-11440.txt.

Introduction

Okawa and three colleagues benchmark three module-level methods for measuring thermoelectric conversion efficiency. The methods are heat flow, guarded heater and AC Harman, tested on commercial bismuth telluride modules. Heat flow and guarded heater agree closely. The AC Harman method reads systematically lower by about sixteen to thirty percent, depending on module architecture. Computer models trace this to open thermal boundaries that skew internal temperatures. Method choice matters, and no single number tells the whole story, so Harman suits rapid screening only with its bias accounted for.

Catalog record

CREATORK. Okawa, Y. Amagai, N. Sakamoto, N.-H. Kaneko
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34692
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.11440

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantitative comparison of heat flow, guarded-heater and AC Harman methods for thermoelectric module efficiency Preprint: APS/123-QED K. Okawa, Y. Amagai, N. Sakamoto, N.-H. Kaneko Abstract The evaluation of thermoelectric conversion efficiency remains challenging owing to the lack of internationally standardized measurement protocols. Commonly used techniques—including the heat flow, guarded heater, and AC Harman methods—differ fundamentally in their operating principles and sensitivity to heat losses. In this study, we benchmark three module-level efficiency measurement techniques—the heat-flow, guarded heater, and AC Harman methods—using commercial Bi 2 ​ Te 3 \rm Bi_{2}Te_{3} -based modules with different substrates materials. The conversion efficiencies obtained using the heat flow and guarded heater methods showed good agreement within experimental uncertainty for temperature differences up to 70 K 70\text{\,}\mathrm{K} . In contrast, the AC Harman method underestimated the conversion efficiency by approximately 30 % 30\text{\,}\% . Through systematic measurements on modules with different substrates and detailed finite element simulations, this underestimation was attributed to boundary-condition effects and radiative heat dissipation, which significantly reduce the effective temperature difference developed across the module in the Harman configuration. These results highlight the limitations of the AC Harman method for quantitative conversion-efficiency evaluation under non-ideal thermal environments and emphasize the necessity of accounting for radiative and substrate-related heat losses. Nevertheless, with appropriate modeling and correction, strategies, the AC Harman method remains a viable tool for rapid performance screening. Our results provide a quantitative benchmark of major measurement techniques and contribute to clarify best practices for module-level thermoelectric metrology and guide method selection, fully supporting future efforts toward methodological standardization. I Introduction Thermoelectric modules play a key role in waste heat recovery by efficiently converting waste heat into electrical energy. Dissemination of thermoelectric power generation using waste heat necessitates the establishment of standardized and accurate measurement techniques to precisely estimate conversion efficiency 19 ; 4 ; 47 ; 9 ; 38 . The uncertainty in measuring thermoelectric properties is approximately 20\text{\,}\% as per the results of a recent international round-robin test 45 ; 44 ; 1 ; the results highlight the lack of a standardized evaluation protocol or sample modules in the field of thermoelectrics 46 ; 54 ; 55 ; 53 . The performance of thermoelectric power generation modules is typically evaluated by assessing their conversion efficiency, \eta , defined as the ratio of the input heat flow to the high-temperature side of the module, Q_{\rm in} , to amount of power generated P_{\rm out} . That is \displaystyle\eta=\frac{P_{\rm out}}{Q_{\rm in}}. (1) Accurate evaluation of Q_{\rm in} is crucial for determining conversion efficiency and is a major challenge 52 . Two typical methods for evaluating the conversion efficiency of thermoelectric modules are the heat flow method (HFM) and guarded heater method (GHM); each differs in their approach to assessing Q_{\rm in} 46 ; 11 ; 52 . The AC Harman method, which can estimate the dimensionless figure of merit, ZT , through DC and AC resistance measurements, provides a quick estimation of module-level performance 15 ; 21 . HFM and GHM are classified as steady-state methods, whereas the AC Harman method is a measurement technique that utilizes transient response of the modules. In AC Harman technique, a small alternating current is applied to the modules, and the resulting in-phase (resistive) and out of- phase (thermoelectric) voltage responses are measured. This method enables for the direct calculation of ZT by measuring AC and DC resistances as follows: \displaystyle ZT=\frac{R_{\rm DC}-R_{\rm AC}}{R_{\rm AC}}, (2) Figure 1: (a) Schematic overview of a typical thermoelectric module, illustrating the temperature gradient applied across the module. (b–d) Schematic illustrations of three representative techniques for evaluating thermoelectric conversion efficiency: (b) the heat flow method, (c) the guarded heater method, and (d) the AC Harman method. where R_{\rm DC} and R_{\rm AC} denote the resistances of the sample measured by applying DC and AC currents, respectively. The AC Harman method leverages the Peltier effect, which occurs at the edges of the sample when current I is applied. This method is widely used in estimating ZT for various samples, including minute crystals, thin films, and composite structures, owing to its simplicity and reliance on a simple two-probe configuration. Based on obtained ZT , The maximum conversion efficiency, \eta_{\rm max} , is estimated as the product of the Carnot efficiency and a term that includes ZT value 38 , \displaystyle\eta_{\rm max}=\frac{\Delta T}{T_{\rm H}}\frac{\sqrt{(1+ZT)}-1}{\sqrt{(1+ZT)}+T_{\rm C}/T_{\rm H}}. (3) The conversion efficiency is limited when the temperature of the high-temperature end is T_{\rm H} and that of the low-temperature end is T_{\rm C} ; it does not exceed the Carnot efficiency (T_{\rm H}-T_{\rm C})/T_{\rm H} . A comparison study with other reliable measurement techniques, such as HFM and GHM, is an important issue to identify the measurement problem and improve the accuracy of the measurement. However, a systematic and quantitative under identical experimental conditions with the HFM, GHM, and AC Haman method have not been fully discussed at the module level 36 ; 43 ; 32 ; 51 , while the recent report discussed the material-level characterization 18 . In particular, the extent to which differences in measurement principles and thermal boundary conditions lead to discrepancies in evaluated conversion efficiency remains unclear. Here, we perform a comparison of the three different measurement techniques for characterizing the conversion efficiency using reliable commercial \rm Bi_{2}Te_{3} -based modules with different types of substrates. To perform the three types of measurements, we have developed an apparatus capable of evaluating these methods. The discrepancies observed in the evaluated conversion efficiencies obtained from the three measurement techniques are attributed to differences in the boundary conditions of the measurement environment and the actual temperature gradients established within the module. To investigate these factors, a combined analysis of experimental results and finite element method (FEM) simulations was performed using COMSOL Multiphysics 12 . II Experimental setup II.1 Sample information The commercial thermoelectric modules exhibit variations in area, heights, shapes of the legs, and numbers of the p-n pairs (the p-n pair comprises two legs, each made of n-type and p-type thermoelectric materials electrically connected in series) as shown in Fig. 1(a). The properties of the modules used in this study are presented in Table 1. This evaluation employed commercially available Bi-Te modules, including a skeleton type with a polyimide substrate measuring $48\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\mathrm{m}$\times$56.6\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\mathrm{m}$\times$1.36\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\mathrm{m}$ , and a rigid type with an alumina substrate measuring $51.2\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\mathrm{m}$\times$55.0\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\mathrm{m}$\times$4.4\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\mathrm{m}$ . The number of p-n pairs in each thermoelectric module is 199 for the skeleton type and 161 for the rigid type. The thickness of the electrodes connecting the n-type and p-type thermoelectric materials is 0.06\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\mathrm{m} and 0.60\text{\,}\mathrm{m}\mathrm{m} , respectively. Modulel type Skelton Rigid Substrate material Polymide Alumina Module size (mm 3 ) 48.0\times 56.6\times 1.36 51.2\times 55.0\times 4.4 Thermoelectric leg number 199 161 Electrode thickness (mm) 0.06 0.60 Table 1: Properties of thermoelectric modules II.2 Heat flow and guarded heater methods In HFM, a calibrated Cu-block heat flow meter was employed to measure heat flow from the cold side of the module Q_{\rm flow} 52 ; 18 . Embedded thermocouples along the Cu block accurately measured the temperature gradient. The heat flow was calculated using the Fourier equation. The input heat flow, Q_{\rm in} , into the module can be determined along with the maximum output power, P_{\rm out}

Read the complete text