Much of Geospatial Web Search Is Beyond Traditional GIS
Ilya Ilyankou, Stefano Cavazzi, James Haworth · 2026
Read Much of Geospatial Web Search Is Beyond Traditional GIS by Ilya Ilyankou, Stefano Cavazzi, James Haworth (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-11336.txt.
Introduction
Ilya Ilyankou, Stefano Cavazzi and James Haworth map geospatial web search at scale. They use embeddings, a small classifier and clustering on the full MS MARCO set of 1 point 01 million Bing queries. They find 181,827 geospatial queries, or 18 percent, nearly three times the share labelled Location in the original annotations. Costs and prices alone make up 15 point 3 percent of geospatial queries, and much of this practical lookup lies outside what traditional GIS was built to serve.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ilya Ilyankou, Stefano Cavazzi, James Haworth |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56611 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.11336
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Much of Geospatial Web Search Is Beyond Traditional GIS Ilya Ilyankou, Stefano Cavazzi, James Haworth Abstract Web search queries concern place far more often than existing labelling schemes suggest, yet the landscape of geospatial web search queries – what people ask of place, and how often – remains poorly characterised at scale. We apply dense sentence embeddings, a lightweight SetFit classifier, and density-based clustering to the full MS MARCO corpus of 1.01 million real Bing queries without prior filtering for toponyms or spatial keywords, identifying 181,827 geospatial queries (18.0%), nearly threefold the 6.17% labelled as Location in the original annotations. The resulting taxonomy of 88 query categories reveals that geospatial web search is dominated by transactional and practical lookups: costs and prices alone account for 15.3% of geospatial queries, nearly twice the size of the entire physical geography theme. Much of this activity – costs, opening hours, contact details, weather, travel recommendations – falls outside the scope of what traditional GIS and knowledge graphs are built to serve. The categories vary substantially in the kind of answer they admit, from deterministic lookups answerable from spatial databases or knowledge graphs to evaluative or temporally volatile queries that require generative or real-time systems. We discuss implications for hybrid retrieval architectures and for benchmarks of geographic reasoning in large language models. We openly release the labelled dataset, classifier, and taxonomy. SpaceTimeLab, Department of Civil, Environmental, and Geomatic Engineering, UCL, London, UK and https://ilyankou.com [email protected]://orcid.org/0009-0008-7082-7122This work was supported by Ordnance Survey & UKRI Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council [grant no. EP/Y528651/1]. Ordnance Survey, Southampton, [email protected]://orcid.org/0000-0003-3575-0365 SpaceTimeLab, Department of Civil, Environmental, and Geomatic Engineering, UCL, London, [email protected]://orcid.org/0000-0001-9506-4266 ccs Information systems Web searching and information discovery ccs Information systems Geographic information systems ccs Information systems Web log analysis ccs Computing methodologies Natural language processing ccs Computing methodologies Cluster analysis ccs Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) keywords Web search queries, geographic information retrieval, query classification, geospatial query taxonomy, MS MARCO, sentence embeddings, density-based clustering, GeoAI, large language models, place theory † † runningauthor: I. Ilyankou, S. Cavazzi, and J. Haworth † † copyright: Ilya Ilyankou, Stefano Cavazzi, and James Haworth † † related-version: Full Version : https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.11336 † † supplement: Software: https://github.com/ilyankou/ms-marco-geospatial † † supplement: Model: https://huggingface.co/ilyankou/is-geospatial-query † † editors: Sabine Timpf, Gabriele Filomena, Armand Kapaj, Rui Zhu, Nicholas Giudice, and Ed Manley † † event-title: 17th International Conference on Spatial Information Theory (COSIT 2026) † † event-shorttitle: COSIT 2026 † † event-acronym: COSIT † † year: 2026 † † event-date: September 22–25, 2026 † † event-location: York, UK † † series-volume: 393 † † articleno: 4 1 Introduction Place is central to how people make sense of the world, yet existing information systems represent it in an impoverished way, often reducing it to named points or coordinate-bound objects rather than the vague, relational, and socially constructed phenomenon it actually is [ 34 , 10 , 18 ] . Large-scale web search query logs offer an empirical window into what people want from place: whether a town falls in a particular county, what the weather or cost of living is somewhere, where the nearest airport is, or what language is spoken in a country. The MS MARCO corpus of 1.01 million real Bing queries [ 5 ] remains the largest publicly available record of such behaviour, despite being collected prior to 2018 and skewed toward Anglophone North American users. It captures web search rather than conversational, voice, or professional GIS use, but it is the most suitable corpus currently available for characterising geospatial web search at scale. Prior work has identified geospatial queries primarily by syntactic form or the presence of toponyms [ 17 , 18 , 25 ] , producing prevalence estimates that are typically too low and taxonomies too narrow to capture the full range of what people want from place. We argue that the right starting point is the query corpus itself, without prior filtering. By applying Transformer sentence embeddings [ 36 ] and density-based clustering to the full MS MARCO dataset, we build a data-driven taxonomy of geospatial web search queries that quantifies not just how many queries are geospatial, but what categories they fall into and how those categories are distributed. Much of this activity, such as costs, opening hours, travel recommendations, or weather, falls outside the scope of what traditional GIS is built to serve, with direct implications for hybrid retrieval and generative system design. We address three research questions: 1. What proportion of web search queries are geospatial, under a definition broader than ‘contains toponyms’? 2. What are the dominant themes of geospatial web search, and how are they distributed? 3. How do the resulting categories vary in the kind of answer they admit, and what does this imply for the design of systems that serve such queries? Our work makes three practical contributions. First, we release a gold human-annotated dataset of 1,200 web search queries, labelled as geospatial or non-geospatial, constructed to cover the full embedding space of MS MARCO rather than its high-density regions. Second, we train and release a lightweight binary classifier that identifies geospatial queries with F_{1}=0.930 (95% bootstrap CI 0.909-0.947 ) and can be applied to web search query corpora beyond MS MARCO. Third, we derive and release a taxonomy of 88 geospatial query categories, illustrated in Figure 3 , that quantifies the relative prevalence of distinct query types and provides a concrete empirical characterisation of geospatial web search at scale. We make the code available on GitHub 1 1 1 https://github.com/ilyankou/ms-marco-geospatial under the MIT license for reproducibility. 2 Related work 2.1 Taxonomies of geographic questions Hamzei et al. mined MS MARCO [ 5 ] to characterise place questions by place type and scale [ 17 ] , and later by a broader semantic schema covering place names, types, activities, spatial relationships, and qualities [ 16 ] . Xu et al. showed that professional geographic questions drawn from GIScience literature are syntactically richer and semantically distinct from web queries, centring on analytical entities such as distribution, pattern, and density [ 42 ] . Another top-down approach by Kuhn et al. derived question templates from a spatial ontology and a taxonomy of place facets, arguing that corpus-driven methods inevitably under-represent emotive and physical facets due to collection bias [ 25 ] . On the system side, Punjani et al. addressed answering geographic natural language questions over structured linked data, translating questions into GeoSPARQL queries via handcrafted templates. Their GeoQuestions201 benchmark defines seven question categories of increasing structural complexity, covering topological, cardinal direction, and distance relations [ 33 ] . Kefalidis et al. extended this line of work with GeoQuestions1089 , a larger benchmark, and showed that even improved template-based systems leave substantial headroom on geographic question answering [ 24 ] . 2.2 Geospatial content in search queries and on the web Several studies have attempted to quantify how much of online information and search activity is geographic in nature, using methods that range from keyword matching to network analysis to LLM-based classification. Sanderson and Kohler found that roughly 18.6% of 1 million Excite 2 2 2 Major web portal and search engine of the late 1990s search queries studied contained a geographic term, with