Hybrid Analytical–EMT Method for HVDC Protection System Component-Level Design

Abolfazl Mohammadi, Merijn Van Deyck, Geraint Chaffey, Dirk Van Hertem · 2026

Read Hybrid Analytical–EMT Method for HVDC Protection System Component-Level Design by Abolfazl Mohammadi, Merijn Van Deyck, Geraint Chaffey, Dirk Van Hertem (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-11174.txt.

Introduction

Abolfazl Mohammadi and three co-authors present a design method for HVDC grid protection parts in multi-terminal grids. Setting DC breakers and series DC inductors matters, but math routes miss real system behavior while simulation routes take heavy compute and time.

Their hybrid analytical-EMT route first derives a basic analytic answer covering protection needs, then speeds convergence toward required design values, after which detailed models ensure accuracy in design and validation. It applies to component-level design for both fully and partially selective schemes in HVDC grids. Power engineers get a design route that balances speed and fidelity.

Catalog record

CREATORAbolfazl Mohammadi, Merijn Van Deyck, Geraint Chaffey, Dirk Van Hertem
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45826
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.11174

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hybrid Analytical–EMT Method for HVDC Protection System Component-Level Design Abolfazl Mohammadi, Merijn Van Deyck, Geraint Chaffey, Dirk Van Hertem Abstract Protection system design for multi-terminal HVDC grids is challenging due to the complexity of the system and the often conflicting design requirements. Effective specification of protection component parameters (e.g., DC circuit breakers and series DC inductors) during component-level design is crucial due to interdependencies among components, the need for detailed modeling, and the complex interactions between the protection system and converter control systems. Both analytical and simulation-based approaches have been proposed as solutions for component-level design. However, analytical methods may not accurately represent system behavior given that approximation is necessary, and simulation-based approaches often require extensive computational effort and time. Therefore, this paper presents an efficient systematic design method, combining both approaches. First, a fundamental analytical solution is derived to consider the protection system requirements. Then, a hybrid analytical–EMT methodology is proposed to accelerate convergence toward the required design parameters, after which detailed models are applied to ensure accuracy in design and validation. The approach is applicable to component-level design for both fully and partially selective protection strategies in HVDC grids. Keywords HVDC protection, DC circuit breaker , DC inductor sizing, EMT modeling. 1 Introduction Multi–terminal HVDC systems provide a promising solution for future transmission networks, enabling bulk power transfer over long distances, interconnection of asynchronous AC systems, and integration of offshore wind farms [ 1 ] . Therefore, the industry is increasingly looking toward large-scale HVDC grids to transmit energy across Europe and to achieve the required expansion in electricity transmission capacity [ 2 ] . However, one of the main technical challenges in HVDC grids is protection against DC faults. Due to the characteristics of DC fault currents, such as the absence of natural current zero crossing and a rapid rise rate, dedicated protection devices such as a DC circuit breaker (DCCB) for interrupting fault currents, and a DC inductor for limiting the fault current may be be needed for multi-terminal HVDC systems [ 1 , 3 ] . Protection systems that allow DC-side fault isolation help avoiding prolonged interruptions of power transfer, ensuring continuity of supply, and maintaining the operation of the healthy parts of the grid [ 4 ] . System-level protection design, which includes the specification of the system topology, protection strategy and converter DC fault ride-through (DC-FRT) capabilities [ 5 , 6 ] , provides inputs for the component-level design. In this component-level design stage, key protection system parameters, such as DCCB characteristics and fault current limiting inductance, are specified to meet the system-level and component-level requirements [ 5 , 7 , 3 ] . Component-level design for multi-terminal grids is not straightforward, as components, such as DCCBs, DC inductors, and converter control systems, are interdependent [ 8 ] . Therefore, detailed electromagnetic transient (EMT) modeling is typically required for these studies. In industrial applications such as the Zhangbei project [ 9 ] , DC inductors installed in series with DCCBs are reported in the range of 150–200 mH to limit the DC fault current. Other studies propose inductances exceeding 500 mH for this purpose [ 10 , 8 ] . Large inductance values increase installation costs [ 11 ] and may lead to stability issues [ 12 , 13 ] . Therefore, DC protection systems should be properly designed to account for these effects by sizing DC inductors as small as possible while still satisfying protection requirements. Existing design methods take different approaches, which can be categorized into three main groups. The first group is based on analytical solutions, such as fault-current estimation [ 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] . Such methods have been used for DC inductor sizing [ 7 ] and DCCB parameter specification [ 3 ] . However, analytical methods cannot suitably represent the complex behavior of the HVDC system [ 18 ] . In practice, representing components such as HVDC cables or converters fully analytically is impractical and overly complex [ 18 ] , as details are often unavailable due to IP concerns and black-box representations [ 19 ] . The second type of design method, such as [ 20 , 21 ] , is based on exhaustive EMT simulations. Although these methods can be more representative of system and component behavior, in practice, relying solely on EMT simulations to design components often requires extensive, repetitive simulations, with hundreds to thousands of iterations, depending on the system size. The third category uses hybrid methods, a combination of methods and tools, to tackle the problem. For instance, in [ 22 ] , optimization-based methods are used to size the DC inductor optimally. These methods embed an EMT model into an optimization problem to optimally size components and represent system behavior more accurately. However, these optimization problems require expensive EMT simulations, particularly as the system size increases towards future large-scale multi-terminal HVDC systems. In this paper, an efficient hybrid method for designing protection components is proposed. An overview of the proposed method is illustrated in Fig. 1 . The method first identifies critical design scenarios to reduce the number of simulation cases. Then, a hybrid methodology is applied, where combination of analytical approximations and EMT model allowing accurate specification of the component parameters. The main contributions of this paper are as follows: • Development of a computationally efficient, systematic method for sizing protection components for both fully and partially selective DC protection systems. • Identification of critical cases to reduce the number of simulations for the design, increasing the efficiency of the design process. • Achieving high-accuracy component parameter specification using the proposed hybrid analytical–EMT method, with the possibility of incorporating vendor models. The rest of the paper is structured as follows. Section II outlines the protection systems requirements, followed by the component-level design method in Section III. Section IV describes two case studies, and Section V discusses the results. Figure 1: Overview of the protection component sizing method 2 Protection System Functional Requirements 2.1 System-level requirements System-level functional requirements of HVDC protection systems have recently been developed [ 4 , 23 , 5 , 3 ] . Key system-level design aspects include the loss-of-infeed limits of the surrounding AC grids [ 4 ] , the selection of protection strategies and zone configurations (i.e., fully selective, partially selective, or non-selective) [ 23 , 5 ] , and the converter DC-FRT requirements [ 4 , 3 ] . These requirements should be specified during the system-level protection design stage to ensure that high-level objectives, such as the stability of the surrounding AC and DC grids, are maintained [ 5 ] . Therefore, in this paper as shown in Fig. 1 , the fundamental inputs requirements form system-level design for component-level design are as follows: • System topology and configuration • Protection strategy and protection zones boundaries • Converter DC-FRT requirements 2.2 Component-level requirements The design of the selected components must ensure that the protection system can effectively isolate faults while satisfying the individual component constraints, such as DCCB and converter maximum current capacity [ 23 ] . While the system-level design provides the system-level constraints, there is flexibility in the sizing of the individual components that make up the

Read the complete text