Compact space catalysis of false vacuum decay and Schwinger effect
Saquib Hassan, and John March-Russell · 2026
Read Compact space catalysis of false vacuum decay and Schwinger effect by Saquib Hassan, and John March-Russell (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-11081.txt.
Introduction
Saquib Hassan and John March-Russell study false vacuum decay in compact space, showing that small volumes open a new decay channel. Below a critical volume, a new bounce solution, distinct from Coleman's celebrated symmetric bubble, mediates decay and typically boosts the rate exponentially.
Continued to Lorentzian signature, the bounce nucleates a homogeneous field configuration below the critical volume and quasi-homogeneous configurations just above, never forming a thin- or thick-walled bubble in a false-vacuum background. Its fluctuation spectrum carries the features decay requires, and the homogeneous-to-quasi-homogeneous crossover is mapped with a real-time interpretation. The bounce also applies to a scalar-field model and to a close cousin of the Schwinger effect in one-plus-one-dimensional axion electrodynamics. Field theorists get finite-volume decay physics that infinite-volume intuition misses.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Saquib Hassan, and John March-Russell |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61655 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.11081
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Compact space catalysis of false vacuum decay and Schwinger effect Saquib Hassan, and John March-Russell Abstract We study zero-temperature false vacuum decay in D D compact spatial dimensions and show that for volumes below a critical value a new bounce solution, different from Coleman’s celebrated O ( D ) O(D) bubble, mediates the decay process, and typically leads to an exponentially enhanced decay rate. The bounce, when analytically continued to Lorentzian signature, nucleates a homogeneous field configuration for spatial volumes below a critical value, and quasi-homogeneous configurations for slightly larger volumes, and is not of the form of a thin or thick-walled bubble embedded in a false vacuum background. We explicitly show that the new bounce has the necessary features associated with false vacuum decay, following from its eigenvalue spectrum of fluctuations. The cross-over from homogeneous to quasi-homogeneous solutions as the spatial volume is increased is discussed, as is a real-time interpretation of the bounce. We apply this bounce to the study of a scalar field model, as well as a close cousin of the Schwinger effect that applies to ( 1 + 1 ) d (1+1)d axion electrodynamics in compact space. 1 Introduction Decays of metastable “vacuum” states in finite space tend to have peculiar properties which are unexpected from usual calculations in infinite space. Whilst many decay processes and rates in quantum field theory tend to be altered by finite size, background geometry, or temperature effects brown2018schwinger ; Hawking:1981fz ; Mogliacci:2018oea ; Coleman:1980aw ; Linde:1981zj ; Garriga:1994ut ; PhysRevD.46.5321 , in this paper we are particularly interested in how zero-temperature false vacuum decay rates are modified by the effects of finite spatial volume. The Schwinger effect Heisenberg:1936nmg ; Schwinger:1951nm in finite space brown2018schwinger is of special interest. Indeed, when the spatial volume becomes smaller than a certain critical scale, decay rates often tend to be exponentially enhanced. This point is especially intriguing, since one may view the Schwinger effect as a type of false vacuum decay process. While in infinite space, the decay rate per volume of an electric field of magnitude E through particle-antiparticle pairs, each of mass m and charge \pm q , is given by \Gamma/V\sim\exp{\Bigg(-\frac{\pi m^{2}}{qE}\Bigg)}, (1) the recent work of brown2018schwinger shows instead that when space is compact (in this case in (1+1)d with space compactified on a circle of perimeter L ), the decay rate becomes \Gamma\sim\exp{\Bigg(-2mL\Big(1-\frac{L^{2}}{6x_{\star}^{2}}+\cdots\Big)\Bigg)}, (2) where x_{\star}=m/qE , is the radius of the critical bubble in infinite space; in this case, half the separation between the charged pair at nucleation. One assumes throughout that L\lesssim x_{\star} . We review these results in appendix A . It follows that when space is compactified on extremely small scales, the rate becomes approximately 1 1 1 Semiclassical validity still requires L\gtrsim m^{-1} . : \Gamma\sim\exp{\Big(-2mL\Big)}. (3) This result is notably different from the naive expectation that as the physical space becomes smaller, the vacuum becomes stable because a bubble mediating the decay no longer fits. Instead, we find that the decay rate grows 2 2 2 See also Qiu:2020gbl . , and is independent of x_{\star} . Importantly, the action now has an explicit linear scaling in volume (length in this case). There is an important qualitative lesson here. Whereas on the infinite line, a larger electric field decays via a charged pair with the electric field in the interior region enclosed by the pair weaker than the field in the exterior, for a small circle instead, brown2018schwinger argues that a stronger electric field decays into a weaker one across the entire space directly, producing only a pair of photons via virtual charged pair annihilation, since no real charged pair is formed. Intuitively, the larger electric field decays homogeneously into a weaker one, which also justifies the volume scaling of the action in eq. ( 3 ). This observation will be important when we generalize false vacuum decay in compact space to quantum field theory. This consideration leads us to explore how the false vacuum decay in finite spatial volumes could be different from Coleman’s bubble nucleation story Coleman:1977py ; Callan:1977pt , and in doing so we attempt to place results such as eq. ( 3 ) on a more unified footing. We find that even when the linear size of all spatial directions is smaller than the size of Coleman’s critical bubble, and naively the energetics of true-vacuum bubble solutions appears to forbid bubble nucleation, the false vacuum is nonetheless able to decay. This process occurs through a different homogeneous or quasi-homogeneous bounce solution with no region of the compact space left in the false vacuum basin. This new homogeneous bounce leads to a qualitatively different and exponentially enhanced decay rate. The structure of the paper is as follows. In section 2 we will introduce the homogeneous bounce solution that mediates false vacuum decay in small compact spaces (we also explore how compact size and spatial curvature effects modify the usual decay rate when space is larger than the critical Coleman bubble diameter, at least in one particular example, in appendix B ). We find a bounce configuration, extended in space, satisfying key requirements to mediate vacuum decay, such as time reversal symmetry at the bounce center, a single negative eigenvalue for fluctuations, etc. In section 3 we solve an explicit example and compute the eigenvalue spectrum of quadratic fluctuations about the homogeneous bounce, and discuss how as the spatial size increases above a critical value new collective coordinate zero modes arise, as well as a mode indicating a bifurcation to a preferred quasi-homogeneous bounce solution. We also discuss a real time interpretation of our homogeneous bounce. In section 4 we apply our new bounce to a study a theory with charged domain walls - akin to charged particle pairs in QED - in the context of axion electrodynamics in (1+1)d , obtaining a Schwinger rate for the theory in compact space, demonstrating striking similarities with brown2018schwinger . 2 Vacuum decay in compact space through the homogeneous bounce First, let us quickly outline some of the key features of false vacuum decay (in infinite space and time) that are necessary for the remainder of this paper 3 3 3 Our presentation here is terse. The reader may consult Coleman:1985rnk ; Coleman:1977py ; Callan:1977pt for details. . We start in the distant past with the expectation value of a field \Phi(t,\mathbf{x}) in the metastable minimum of a potential U(\Phi) , corresponding to a constant false vacuum value \Phi_{\mathrm{FV}} . It is convenient to set U(\Phi_{\mathrm{FV}})=0 . There is also a true vacuum field value, \Phi_{\mathrm{TV}} , corresponding to a lower minimum with U(\Phi_{\mathrm{TV}})<0 . For instance, take the action in D dimensional spacetime: I=\int d^{D}x\ \Big(-\frac{1}{2}\partial_{\mu}\Phi\partial^{\mu}\Phi-U(\Phi)\Big), (4) with U(\Phi)=U_{+}(\Phi)+\frac{\epsilon}{2a}(\Phi-a),\quad U_{+}(\Phi)=\frac{\lambda}{8}\Big(\Phi^{2}-\frac{\mu^{2}}{\lambda}\Big)^{2}, (5) and \mu^{2}/\lambda=a^{2} . The precise values of the parameters are not particularly important for the present discussion, but note that \Phi_{\mathrm{FV}}=a here. See figure 1 . Figure 1: The potential U(\Phi) for a scalar field \Phi showing a false vacuum field value \Phi_{\mathrm{FV}} for which the potential vanishes and is a local minimum, and a true vacuum corresponding to a global minimum at \Phi_{\mathrm{TV}} . In Euclidean signature, we sum over all paths, taking the initial false vacuum field