Unique Gravitational-Wave Signals from Negative-Mass Binaries Preprint: APS/123-QED
Oem Trivedi 1 , Abraham Loeb 2 · 2026
Read Unique Gravitational-Wave Signals from Negative-Mass Binaries Preprint: APS/123-QED by Oem Trivedi 1 , Abraham Loeb 2 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-10976.txt.
Introduction
Oem Trivedi and Abraham Loeb build a sky test for negative mass, the exotic idea that some matter could pull with a negative charge. Bondi's classic work showed positive-negative pairs would run away together, yet the idea keeps resurfacing in dark-energy and rival-cosmology proposals.
Their joint framework pairs charge-level bounds with motion probes: radiation limits demand one universal charge, while negative-mass pairs would generically give anti-chirps, dispersal, and runaway motion. None of those signs appear in current gravitational-wave sightings, giving a robust exclusion path that does not lean on rival-gravity assumptions. Gravity physicists get a clean way to rule negative mass in or out.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Oem Trivedi 1 , Abraham Loeb 2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23208 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.10976
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Unique Gravitational-Wave Signals from Negative-Mass Binaries Preprint: APS/123-QED Oem Trivedi 1 , Abraham Loeb 2 Abstract Negative masses have long been explored, but their observational viability remains unclear. In this work, we develop a unified, observationally testable framework to constrain negative masses using both coupling level and dynamical probes. We establish that while dipole radiation bounds require universality of gravitational charge, the intrinsic dynamics of negative mass binaries generically lead to anomalous behaviors such as anti-chirps, dispersal and runaway motion. These signatures are absent in current gravitational wave observations, providing a robust exclusion channel independent of modified gravity assumptions. Negative masses have been a topic of interest in gravitational physics for quite some time. Starting with the foundational work of Bondi in 1957 Bondi 1957 , it was realized that systems involving positive and negative masses lead to highly non-trivial dynamics, including runaway motion and unconventional gravitational interactions. Since then, negative masses have been explored across a wide range of contexts, including their role in general relativity, exotic compact objects and black hole physics, as well as in cosmological settings where they have been invoked in attempts to explain dark energy like behavior or to construct alternative cosmological models such as the Bondi universe Manfredi et al. 2026 ; Nojiri and Odintsov 2026 ; Farnes 2018 ; Belletête and Paranjape 2013 ; Bonnor 1989 ; Cebeci et al. 2006 ; Mann 1997 ; Forward 1990 . More broadly, they have appeared in modified gravity frameworks and discussions of exotic matter, where they challenge conventional assumptions about energy conditions and gravitational coupling Møller et al. 2017 ; Khamehchi et al. 2017 ; Socas-Navarro 2019 ; Petit and d’Agostini 2014 ; Nájera et al. 2021 ; Manfredi et al. 2018 . The peculiar dynamical behavior that negative masses exhibit such as runaway acceleration and apparent violations of intuitive energy considerations, raise serious concerns about their physical viability. Moreover, despite decades of theoretical exploration, there has been no direct observational evidence supporting their existence and this motivates the need for a systematic framework that goes beyond purely theoretical arguments. Instead one requires robust, observationally testable constraints to really probe negative masses properly. The aim of this Letter is to put viable, observationally testable constraints on negative masses and provide a strong criterion which can either rule out this paradigm completely or guide us better under which regimes one could observe such negative mass objects. Dipole radiation provides some of the cleanest constraints on deviations from universal gravitational coupling Wang et al. 2022 ; Lazaridis et al. 2009 ; Will 1977 ; Krisher 1985 ; Barausse et al. 2016 ; Vasúth et al. 2003 ; Weisberg and Taylor 1981 ; Arun 2012 . It is so because in a general framework one may define a channel-dependent gravitational charge q^{X} and corresponding charge to mass ratio is given by \alpha^{X}=\frac{q^{X}}{m}. (1) Before proceeding, it is useful to clarify the mass conventions used in this work. In general, one may distinguish inertial mass, which controls the response of an object to an applied force, active gravitational mass, which sources the gravitational field and passive gravitational mass, which controls the response to an external gravitational field. The equality of active and passive gravitational mass is required for momentum conservation. Since momentum conservation is associated with spatial translation symmetry, it is not optional for a consistent physical theory. We therefore identify active and passive gravitational mass in what follows and refer to this common quantity as the gravitational mass or, more generally the gravitational charge. By contrast, the equality between inertial mass and gravitational mass is the content of the equivalence principle, which has been experimentally verified for ordinary positive mass matter but not for any hypothetical negative mass sector. We hence use q^{X} as a generalized, channel dependent gravitational charge in an observational channel X , while m denotes the inertial mass entering the charge-to-mass ratio \alpha^{X}=q^{X}/m . The dipole-radiation analysis later constrains possible deviations in this ratio, whereas the later quadrupole waveform analysis assumes the stronger signed mass realization in which inertial and gravitational masses remain equal even for negative masses. For two bodies in a binary system labeled 1 and 2 , the difference in their effective couplings in a given channel X is \Delta\alpha^{X}=\alpha_{1}^{X}-\alpha_{2}^{X}. (2) In theories that admit additional radiative degrees of freedom beyond the tensor modes of general relativity such as scalar tensor theories, the leading correction to gravitational radiation appears as a dipole contribution. We can then write the energy loss due to gravitational radiation as \dot{E}=\dot{E}_{\rm GR}\left[1+B\left(\frac{M}{r}\right)^{-1}\right], (3) where \dot{E}_{\rm GR} is the standard quadrupole formula contribution, M is the total mass of the system, and B parametrizes the strength of dipole radiation. B is directly related to the difference in gravitational charge to mass ratios of the two bodies in such frameworks, with this given as B=\frac{5}{96}(\Delta\alpha^{\rm dip})^{2}. (4) Observational constraints from binary pulsars and gravitational wave inspirals require B to be extremely small, typically B\lesssim 10^{-7} Wang et al. 2022 and this would mean that |\Delta\alpha^{\rm dip}|\lesssim\sqrt{\frac{96B}{5}}, (5) this means that the effective gravitational coupling in the dipole channel must be nearly identical for all objects in a binary system. It is important to emphasize that this constraint does not exclude the existence of negative mass objects per se, but does something deeper. It constrains the difference in gravitational charge to mass ratios. in particular, a scenario in which positive and negative masses carry opposite gravitational charges such that \left(\frac{q}{m}\right)_{+}=+1,\quad\left(\frac{q}{m}\right)_{-}=-1, (6) would give \Delta\alpha^{\rm dip}=2, (7) and therefore B=\frac{5}{96}(2)^{2}\sim 0.21, (8) which is many orders of magnitude larger than observational bounds. Such a configuration is therefore ruled out but if negative mass objects satisfy \left(\frac{q}{m}\right)_{-}\simeq\left(\frac{q}{m}\right)_{+}, (9) then \Delta\alpha^{\rm dip}\simeq 0 and dipole radiation constraints are satisfied. Thus, dipole radiation excludes negative masses with non-universal gravitational charge, but does not exclude negative masses with universal coupling. Note that we get dipole gravitational radiation after introducing negative masses for the same reason we get dipole electromagnetic radiation, as we now have both positive and negative gravitational “charges”. The dipole channel, however, represents only one aspect of gravitational interaction and one can think of more general scenarios as well. In a more general setting, different physical probes are sensitive to different effective couplings and we may therefore introduce a set of channel dependent charge to mass ratios which are \alpha^{X}=\frac{q^{X}}{m}, (10) where X labels different physical processes such as conservative orbital dynamics, radiative energy loss, gravitational lensing, propagation of gravitational waves and cosmological growth Yagi et al. 2016 ; Barausse and Yagi 2015 ; Barausse 2017 ; Das et al. 2025 ; Lambiase et al. 2021 . For each such channel, one can define \Delta\alpha^{X}=\left(\frac{q^{X}}{m}\right)_{+}-\left(\frac{q^{X}}{m}\right)_{-}. (11) Each observational probe then constrains the corresponding \Delta\alpha^{X} to lie within some small tolerance \epsilon_{X} |\Delta\alpha^{X}|\leq\epsilon_{X}. (12) For example, in the conservative sector we see that the force law between two bodies can be written as F=-\frac{Gm_{1}m_{2}}{r^{2}}\alpha_{1}^{\rm cons}\alpha_{2}^{\rm cons}, (13) so that any difference in \alpha^{\rm cons} between objects would lead to violations of the equivalence principle and anomalous orbital dynamics. Also in gravitational lensing the deflection angle can be expressed as \hat{\alpha}_{\rm lens}=\alpha^{\rm lens}\frac{4GM}{c^{2}b}, (14) and deviations in \alpha^{\rm lens} would alter observed lensing