The Meissner effect does not require radial charge flow

A.V. Nikulov · 2026

Read The Meissner effect does not require radial charge flow by A.V. Nikulov (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-10945.txt.

Introduction

A.V. Nikulov argues that the Meissner effect, the expulsion of magnetic flux from a bulk superconductor, needs no radial charge flow. An alternative theory claims the persistent surface current arises from the Lorentz force on such a flow, and its author insists the flow is required.

Nikulov counters that the current follows from quantization of Cooper-pair angular momentum, a fact established by experiment, not merely by conventional theory. Since the Lorentz-force story cannot explain that experimental fact, the radial flow is an unnecessary extra. Superconductivity researchers get a pointed defense of the standard account against a long-running alternative.

Catalog record

CREATORA.V. Nikulov
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53414
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.10945

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Meissner effect does not require radial charge flow A.V. Nikulov Abstract The Meissner effect is the expulsion of magnetic flux from the interior of a bulk superconductor in the presence of the constant critical magnetic field by the persistent current circulating near the surface of the superconductor. The conventional theory of superconductivity explains the appearance of the persistent current in the Meissner effect and other macroscopic quantum phenomena observed in superconductors as a consequence of the quantization of angular momentum of Cooper pairs. According to the alternative theory of hole superconductivity the persistent current appears due to the Lorentz force acting on a radial charge flow rather than due to quantization. Therefore, the author of this theory, Jorge Hirsch, argues in his numerous publications that a radial charge flow is required to explain the Meissner effect. This article draws attention to the fact that the appearance of the persistent current because of quantization is not only the statement of the conventional theory of superconductivity, but first of all the experimental fact that cannot be explained using the Lorentz force. Therefore, the explanation of the Meissner effect does not require radial charge flow. I Introduction Jorge Hirsch in his book Hirsch2020book and numerous publications HirschList seeks to convince the superconducting community of the superiority of his alternative theory of hole superconductivity, proposed more than thirty-five years ago Hirsch1989 , over the conventional theory BCS1957 . The main Hirsch argument in favor of his theory is the prediction of a radial charge flow during the transition to the superconducting state. Hirsch writes in a resent article Hirsch2025 ” The alternative theory of hole superconductivity Hirsch2020book ; HirschList predicts that metals expel negative charge from their interior to the surface when they become superconducting Hirsch2001PLA ; Hirsch201PhSc ” . In contrast to the Hirsch theory, ” the conventional theory predicts no radial charge flow” Hirsch2025 . Hirsch explains why he considers the prediction of radial charge flow an advantage of his theory: ” We have discussed in previous work why radial charge flow is required to explain the Meissner effect Hirsch2016PhS ; Hirsch2017PRB ; Hirsch2010PhysC ” . According to the Hirsch theory ” In the presence of a magnetic field the outflowing charge acquires azimuthal velocity through the Lorentz force Hirsch2003 generating a magnetic field in direction opposite to the applied field, thus accounting for the Meissner effect” Hirsch2025 . Contrary to the Hirsch assertion Hirsch2016PhS ; Hirsch2017PRB ; Hirsch2010PhysC , the Meissner effect was explained as early as 1941 Landau41 without radial charge flow, as a consequence of the quantization of the angular momentum of superconducting mobile charge carriers. The wave function deduced in the article Landau41 for the explanation of the Meissner effect is the basis of the Ginzburg-Landau theory published in 1950 GL1950 before the BCS theory BCS1957 . M. Tinkham wrote about this theory: ” As originally proposed, this theory was a triumph of physical intuition, in which a pseudowavefunction \Psi(r) was introduced as a complex order parameter. \cdot\cdot\cdot Although quite successful in explaining intermediate-state phenomena, where the need for a theory capable of dealing with spatially inhomogeneous superconductivity was evident, this theory was initially given limited attention in the western literature because of its phenomenological foundation. This situation changed in 1959 when Gor’kov Gorkov1959 showed that the GL theory was, in fact, derivable as a rigorous limiting case of the microscopic theory ” Tinkham1996 proposed in 1957 by J. Bardeen, L.N. Cooper and J.R. Schrieffer (BCS) BCS1957 . The GL theory GL1950 and the BCS theory BCS1957 may be considered as a unified conventional theory of superconductivity due to the Gor’kov publication Gorkov1959 . W. Meissner and R. Ochsenfeld discovered in 1933 Meissner1933 that at the transition of a solid cylinder, i.e. without a hole, to the superconducting state in the presence of the constant critical magnetic field the persistent current circulating near the surface appears, which expels the magnetic flux from the interior of the cylinder. The paradox of this effect, which Hirsch points out Hirsch10Meis , is the absence of a force that could explain the appearance of the persistent current against the action of the Faraday electromagnetic force. Later, the persistent current was observed also in cylinders with a hole, with thick fluxquan1961a ; fluxquan1961b and thin LP1962 walls, as well as in superconducting rings PCJETP07 . The conventional theory of superconductivity BCS1957 ; GL1950 explains the appearance of the persistent current in all these cases as a consequence of the quantization of the angular momentum of Cooper pairs PhysicaC2021 . This article draws reader’s attention that the appearance of the persistent current because of the quantization of the angular momentum is not only the statement of the conventional theory BCS1957 ; GL1950 , but is, first of all, experimental fact. The next section draws attention that the angular momentum of Cooper pairs in the Meissner state equals zero. While, in cylinders with a hole in which flux quantization fluxquan1961a ; fluxquan1961b and the persistent current LP1962 are observed, this angular momentum equals an integer number n of Planck’s constants \hbar . In the third section, the observation of the quantization of the angular momentum in systems with macroscopic sizes is explained by the violation of the correspondence principle in macroscopic quantum phenomena. The connection between the observation of quantization at the macroscopic level and the long-range phase coherence of the wave function describing the superconducting state is indicated in the fourth section. The fifth section draws attention to the fact that the problem with the law of conservation of angular momentum, which Hirsch drew attention to, is a consequence of the violation of the correspondence principle in macroscopic quantum phenomena. The Conclusion points out the need for a critical attitude not only to conventional but also to alternative theories. II The appearance of the persistent current under the influence of the Faraday electromagnetic force and because of the quantization The superconducting state with zero magnetic flux inside a macroscopic cylinder is called the Meissner state. But this state was observed before the discovery of the Meissner effect Meissner1933 . It was known before 1933 that magnetic flux does not penetrate in the interior of a superconductor due to the persistent current induced in a surface layer by the increase in external magnetic field H . No one doubted and no one doubts that the persistent current with a density j=n_{s}qv appears in this case under the influence of the Faraday electric field E=-dA/dt in accordance with the Newton second law mdv/dt=qE . It is important to note that the Faraday electric field increases the velocity mdv/dt=-qdA/dt of particles with a charge q and a mass m , but does not change the canonical momentum dp/dt=d(mv+qA)/dt=0 . We can conclude that the Meissner state is a state with zero canonical momentum p=mv+qA=0 and the angular momentum rp=rmv+rqA=rmv+q\Phi/2\pi=0 of Cooper pairs since v=0 and A=0 without magnetic field H=0 . Here r is the distance from the center of the superconducting cylinder with the radius R_{b} ; \Phi is the magnetic flux inside a circle with radius r\leq R_{b} . The relation \Phi=\oint_{l}dlA between the magnetic flux inside the circle l=2\pi r and the magnetic

Read the complete text