How Creatives Approach GenAI Image Generation: Tensions Between Structured Guidance, Self-Experimentation, and Creative Autonomy Conference: Creativity and Cognition; July 13–16, 2026; London, United Kingdom Creativity and Cognition (C&C ’26), July 13–16, 2026, London, United Kingdom DOI: 10.1145/3803784.3807570 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2583-8/2026/07 CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI)
Haidan Liu, Isabelle Kwan, Taiga Okuma, Jeffrey Loverock, Nicholas Vincent, Parmit K Chilana · 2026
Read How Creatives Approach GenAI Image Generation: Tensions Between Structured Guidance, Self-Experimentation, and Creative Autonomy Conference: Creativity and Cognition; July 13–16, 2026; London, United Kingdom Creativity and Cognition (C&C ’26), July 13–16, 2026, London, United Kingdom DOI: 10.1145/3803784.3807570 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2583-8/2026/07 CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) by Haidan Liu, Isabelle Kwan, Taiga Okuma, Jeffrey Loverock, Nicholas Vincent, Parmit K Chilana (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-10898.txt.
Introduction
Haidan Liu and five colleagues study how artists and hobbyists learn generative image tools, and why structured guidance often loses to self-experimentation. Interviews with eight creatives and a survey of 159 more show most people explore on their own or follow tutorials, while tripping over confusing AI terminology.
A follow-up probe with 17 creatives found that even those who called structured guidance helpful still preferred experimenting freely, fearing guidance would fence in their creativity. The central tension is clear: support must teach the tools without curbing artistic autonomy. Tool designers get evidence that guidance should stay optional, skippable, and tuned to creative freedom.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Haidan Liu, Isabelle Kwan, Taiga Okuma, Jeffrey Loverock, Nicholas Vincent, Parmit K Chilana |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 64803 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.10898
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
How Creatives Approach GenAI Image Generation: Tensions Between Structured Guidance, Self-Experimentation, and Creative Autonomy Conference: Creativity and Cognition; July 13–16, 2026; London, United Kingdom Creativity and Cognition (C&C ’26), July 13–16, 2026, London, United Kingdom DOI: 10.1145/3803784.3807570 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2583-8/2026/07 CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) Haidan Liu, Isabelle Kwan, Taiga Okuma, Jeffrey Loverock, Nicholas Vincent, Parmit K Chilana Abstract . As generative AI tools increasingly influence creative practice, they raise longstanding HCI questions about how creatives learn complex software and how they can be better supported. We conducted an interview study with artists and hobbyists (n=8) and a follow-up survey (n=159) to understand how this population approaches and seeks guidance for GenAI image tools. We found that creatives commonly use either self-experimentation or tutorials to explore GenAI tools, yet many struggle with confusing AI terminology. To gain further insight into creatives’ learning experiences, we developed a research probe to elicit creatives’ perceptions of structured guidance. Our user study with 17 creatives revealed that, even when creatives described the guidance as helpful for understanding AI, many still preferred self-experimentation, feeling that guidance could limit their creativity. Our findings highlight a central tension in supporting AI literacy for creatives: balancing guidance and promoting literacy while preserving creative freedom. † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) image tools (e.g., DALL·E ( 20 ) ) and mobile applications (e.g., WhatsApp ( 102 ) , Instagram ( 37 ) ) have lowered barriers to AI-assisted creativity by enabling image generation from natural language prompts ( 21 ) . However, their “black box” nature leaves users with limited understanding of how prompts are interpreted, making it difficult to refine outputs, build reliable workflows, or form useful mental models ( 89 ; 21 ; 90 ) . This opacity also creates challenges for organizations trying to improve AI literacy, or makes it harder for users to become AI literate by limiting users’ ability to evaluate outputs and engage critically with AI ( 80 ; 15 ; 32 ; 21 ) . Recent GenAI tools increasingly support output steering through interface-level controls, such as localized editing, richer prompting workflows, and production-oriented features ( 69 ; 2 ) . While these features improve usability and reduce friction, they primarily support outcome control rather than conceptual understanding. Users may gain more ways to manipulate results, but still lack transferable intuitions about how systems interpret inputs, why outputs vary, or when failures occur. As models change over time, users must also continually adapt strategies that may not transfer across versions or tools ( 8 ; 27 ; 72 ) . Figure 1 . Overview of our staged inquiry across three studies. The formative interviews and survey studies (left) identified creatives’ common learning strategies and challenges in making sense of GenAI image tools. We then developed and refined a research probe that provided easy-to-understand guidance on how GenAI works. The comparative structured user study (right) using the research probe to elicit participants’ perceptions on structured guidance and self-experimentation and surfaced the tension between structured support and creative autonomy. The overall research process spanned summer 2024 to summer 2025. We adopt a mental models lens ( 67 ) to examine how creatives understand and reason about GenAI image tools. Throughout this paper, we use the term “creatives” to refer to visual artists and hobbyists who engage with GenAI image tools in creative contexts. We first conducted interviews with 8 visual artists and hobbyists to understand how they approach GenAI image tools and the challenges they face when trying to make sense of how AI interprets their inputs and generates outputs. While most preferred self-experimentation, some turned to tutorials and expressed a desire for simpler, visual explanations. To assess how prevalent these patterns are beyond our interview sample, we followed up with an online survey with 159 visual artists and hobbyists to assess their views on existing tutorials and support resources for popular GenAI image tools. Our survey findings revealed that third-party online tutorials (e.g., from YouTubers and other content creatives or online courses rather than those from tool platforms) are the most popular strategies among creatives when approaching GenAI image tools. Respondents showed greater interest in tutorials that help them understand AI concepts and parameter settings though complex terminology emerged as a key barrier in the process (Figure 3 b). Building on these formative findings, we next sought to understand how creatives respond to simplified structured guidance when technical barriers such as jargon and overly complex guidance are minimized. We use “structured guidance” to refer to learning support, such as tutorials, videos, walkthroughs, examples, or in-tool explanations, that organizes information to help users understand and use GenAI tools. Existing guidance formats were not well-suited for this purpose as many are highly technical and rely on specialized terminology that can be difficult for non-expert users to follow (e.g., ( 68 ; 4 ) ), while others are tailored to specific applications (e.g., ( 66 ) ). To address this gap, we created our own research probe ( 99 ) to elicit participants’ responses on structured guidance of how AI works without the confounds introduced by these existing guidance formats (e.g., technical jargon). We then conducted a comparative structured observation study and follow-up interviews with 17 visual artists and hobbyists to elicit reflections on their experience with the probe during image-generation tasks and how they balanced structured guidance with self-experimentation. Our findings show that structured guidance can help users by clarifying how the AI interprets prompts and decides what to try next for better results. We also observed an intriguing paradox: while structured guidance supported understanding, some creatives still preferred self-experimentation, describing it as a better match for preserving creative autonomy during exploration. These dynamics suggest that supporting creative work with GenAI tools requires a closer understanding of how creatives build mental models through interaction, while also respecting their desire to maintain creative autonomy as they navigate both AI behavior and external guidance. Our study offers insights into these processes and highlights the need for learning resource designs that foster conceptual understanding of AI systems without diminishing creative freedom. Across our studies, we contribute a staged account of how creatives learn GenAI tools. Our formative interviews identified two dominant learning approaches of self-experimentation and tutorials and a key barrier: difficulty with technical terminology, alongside a demand for simpler, conceptual explanations. The survey showed that these patterns persist at scale, confirming both the prevalence of these strategies and dissatisfaction with existing tutorials. Building on this, the probe study isolates simplified structured visual guidance and examines how creatives engage with it in practice relative to self-experimentation, showing that while guidance can improve understanding of how the system interprets inputs, many creatives still prefer self-experimentation to maintain creative autonomy, that is choosing one’s creative path and expressing unique ideas ( 46 ; 81 ) . We argue that “more tutorials” is not the solution. Learning support should be situated, optional, and adaptable, offering in-context explanations that respect creative agency, the creator’s ability to shape the creative process and outcomes ( 9 ; 81 ) , and reflect that creators’ literacy needs are uneven, personal, and goal-driven. 2. Related Work We draw on four strands