The Solar System as a lab for the Law of Universal Gravitation

Mauricio Mendivelso-Villaquirán · 2026

Read The Solar System as a lab for the Law of Universal Gravitation by Mauricio Mendivelso-Villaquirán (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-10868.txt.

Introduction

Mauricio Mendivelso-Villaquirán turns the Solar System into a classroom laboratory for Newton's law of universal gravitation. Textbooks usually hand students the finished formula as a fact from three centuries ago, with no path showing how it was earned.

A deduction built from public data from trusted sources uses planetary observations of the kind Kepler analyzed before Newton unified them. Students see how scattered measurements harden into a single law, and teachers get a worked route for teaching deduction rather than memorization. Middle- and high-school physics classes are the intended audience.

Catalog record

CREATORMauricio Mendivelso-Villaquirán
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE21682
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.10868

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Solar System as a lab for the Law of Universal Gravitation Mauricio Mendivelso-Villaquirán Abstract The Law of Universal Gravitation is part of middle and high school’s general physics and astronomy curricula. This topic is included in the most popular physics textbooks available as a fact whose origin remains in the detailed work of Sir Isaac Newton 300 years ago. Consequently, its mathematical form is presented as an equation without any deductive process. Nevertheless, deduction of the mathematical form of this law is an opportunity to discuss how a deductive process can be performed using the data available on the Internet from reliable sources. I Introduction The Law of Universal Gravitation (LUG) offers Newton’s elegant solution to the longstanding challenge of describing planetary motion around the Sun. By the 16 th century, European observatories had amassed extensive numerical data from celestial observations. Scholars like Johannes Kepler analyzed this data and formulated empirical laws governing planetary motion. While Kepler’s laws hinted at a deeper underlying principle, earlier attempts by Galileo and others to generalize them often led to models that were either overly complex or redundant. It was Isaac Newton who succeeded in synthesizing these insights into a unified, coherent theory. His model, in contrast to those built on convoluted trajectories, provided a clear explanation, quickly gaining widespread acceptance. At its foundation, LUG describes planetary motion as the result of a gravitational attraction between two masses, with a force proportional to the product of the masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them F=G\frac{m_{1}m_{2}}{r^{2}} (1) where G is the gravitational constant, m_{1} and m_{2} are the masses involved, and r is the distance separating them. This inverse-square relationship has been extensively tested and confirmed. Although widely featured in general physics textbooks across high school and university levels, the derivation of this law is often absent. As with many physics topics, instructional focus tends to emphasize the final formula and its consequences rather than the path leading to its discovery. Consequently, LUG is frequently presented as an isolated result, historically rooted in Galileo’s time but rarely contextualized in terms of how it was initially deduced. Many educational efforts have attempted to make the implications of LUG more approachable. While some of these are reproducible in the classroom, they often leave students wondering how the law was originally derived. When learners ask, “How can I, as a student, arrive at this result?” they are commonly referred to post-Galilean or Newtonian interpretations—often found in dated, complex texts—or are simply encouraged to focus on the law’s implications, with little attention to its derivation. Surprisingly, there exists a more accessible way to address this question—through the use of a 20 th -century tool that transformed our understanding of galactic dynamics: the rotation curve. This straightforward method can be applied to systems governed by gravity—such as the Solar System, satellites in orbit, and even exoplanet systems—to empirically derive LUG. Using rotation curves in tandem with software tools, students can approximate LUG and the Cavendish constant G with remarkable precision. This approach not only simplifies the derivation process but also reflects the analytical practices of modern science, making the result more tangible and engaging. From a pedagogical perspective, this methodology illuminates the origins of LUG and demystifies its development. It also promotes collaborative inquiry and mutual learning as students work together toward a shared scientific goal. Furthermore, the integration of computational tools embodies the principles of STEM education, allowing learners to connect historical breakthroughs with contemporary technology in a meaningful way. In doing so, this activity reinforces gravitational principles while showcasing the relevance and power of STEM-based learning in reconstructing foundational scientific achievements. II LUG in Textbooks and Other Sources Physics textbooks serve as the primary resource for investigating on the presentation of the Law of Universal Gravitation (LUG). Historically and presently, they remain key channels for the dissemination of scientific knowledge. To begin this investigation, a curated list of textbooks was assembled. The motivation behind this compilation stems from the wide variety of available physics textbooks and their differing levels of accessibility. Although using an existing list such as the one by Leite [ 1 ] was considered advantageous, the age and limited distribution of those titles required an alternative approach. In physics education, curricular frameworks frequently rely on textbooks as foundational resources. For example, the Advanced Placement (AP) program, developed by the College Board in the United States, heavily integrates textbooks into its curriculum. Due to the structure of the U.S. educational system, access to textbooks is often driven by demand and market availability, with widely adopted titles enjoying broader circulation. Platforms like Reddit, eBay, and Amazon proved useful for identifying the most accessible and commonly used books. Using this strategy, the textbooks shown in Table I emerged as central to this review. Authors Title Edition E. Etkina, M. Gentile, and A. Van Heuvelen College Physics 3rd R. Freedman, T. Ruskell, P. Kesten, and G. Stewart College Physics for the AP® Physics 1 & 2 Courses 2nd D. Giancoli Physics 7th D. Halliday, R. Resnick, and J. Walker Fundamentals of Physics 10th C. Hamper Pearson Baccalaureate: Higher Level Physics 3rd K. Johnson Physics for You 3rd T. Kirk IB Physics Study Guide: Oxford IB Diploma Programme 3rd R. Knight, B. Jones, and S. Field College Physics: A Strategic Approach 3rd R. A. Serway & J. W. Jewett Physics for Scientists and Engineers with Modern Physics 10th K. A. Tsokos Physics for the IB Diploma 2nd P. P. Urone, R. Hinrichs OpenStax College Physics 2e (online textbook) Jul 13, 2022 H. C. Verma Concepts of Physics (Part 1) 1st H. D. Young & R. A. Freedman University Physics with Modern Physics 15th TABLE I: University, college, and AP/IB/GCSE general physics textbooks under review Additional frameworks such as the International Baccalaureate Organization’s (IBO) International Baccalaureate program and the British General Certificate of Secondary Education (GCSE) have also been included. These resources offer complementary perspectives on how LUG is presented across educational systems. Although not exhaustive, this selection reflects textbooks commonly used in physics instruction in recent years. After reviewing these textbooks, a consistent pattern emerges: LUG is typically introduced in its mathematical form, accompanied by explanations of the equation’s components and its implications. Most authors highlight the law’s universality and general applicability without addressing its origin or derivation. At the university level, some texts introduce LUG by invoking Kepler’s Third Law and the nearly circular nature of planetary orbits. This leads to a derivation of the proportionality between the square of the orbital period and the cube of the mean orbital radius, with G introduced as a proportionality constant. While valid, this method often feels artificial or disconnected, leaving the core question posed in the introduction—how students can deduce LUG—unanswered. Turning to other resources, some articles [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] examine the implications of LUG’s derivation, often citing the measurement of the Cavendish Constant G , or detailing methods used to validate its value. From a historical standpoint, various research groups have studied how the deduction of G is represented in educational literature [ 6 ] . Videos are also useful learning tools, though their content is often influenced

Read the complete text