Deep Arguing
Adam Gould, Francesca Toni · 2026
Read Deep Arguing by Adam Gould, Francesca Toni (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-10569.txt.
Introduction
Adam Gould and Francesca Toni make deep learning clear through argument. Deep learning dominates high-power modeling across diverse data types. But models tightly link feature mining with task goals and often lack clear reasoning steps, making it hard for humans to understand how predictions arise. Their 2026 paper introduces Deep Arguing.
Deep Arguing is an approach pairing deep learning with symbols, argument building, and reasoning for clear sorting across data types. Deep neural networks build an argument structure where data points back their assigned label and attack different ones. With smooth argument rules for reasoning, the model trains end-to-end to jointly learn feature patterns and argument links. The resulting structures give faithful case-based reasons for predictions. Structure constraints over the argument graph guide learning, improving both clarity and results. Tests on tabular and imaging datasets show performance matching standard baselines while offering clear argument reasoning.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Adam Gould, Francesca Toni |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY SA |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.10569
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Deep Arguing Adam Gould, Francesca Toni Abstract Deep learning has become the dominant approach for creating high capacity, scalable models across diverse data modalities. However, because these models rely on a large number of learned parameters, tightly couple feature extraction with task objectives, and often lack explicit reasoning mechanisms, it is difficult for humans to understand how they arrive at their predictions. Understanding what representations emerge and why they arise from the training data remains an open challenge. We introduce Deep Arguing , a novel neurosymbolic approach that integrates deep learning with argumentation construction and reasoning for interpretable classification with different data modalities. In our approach deep neural networks construct an argumentation structure wherein data points support their assigned label and attack different ones. Using differentiable argumentation semantics for reasoning, the model is trained end-to-end to jointly learn feature representation and argumentative interactions. This results in argumentation structures providing faithful case-based explanations for predictions. Structure constraints over the argumentation graph guide learning, improving both interpretability and predictive performance. Experiments with tabular and imaging datasets show that Deep Arguing achieves performance competitive with standard baselines whilst offering interpretable argumentative reasoning. 1 Introduction As deep learning becomes the dominant AI approach for high capacity, scaleable models across diverse data modalities, questions arise as to how deep learning models arrive at their predictions [ 20 , 58 ] . This becomes exceedingly difficult as deep neural networks (DNNs) scale, because the sheer volume of parameters and varying input-output behaviours render DNNs intractable to fully interpret [ 58 ] . Additionally, the reasoning mechanism used by DNNs is not explicit. Often DNNs are trained with a task-specific objective end-to-end, meaning that their reasoning mechanism is tightly coupled with the latent features extracted. Therefore, one cannot easily explain how the training data give rise to a classification beyond the features extracted. Given the complexity of deep learning, even these feature-based explanations may not be faithful [ 31 , 55 ] . But faithfully understanding the reasoning behind predictions is important for preventing model failures. Additionally, users may have an expectation and right to an explanation for decisions made by autonomous systems [ 23 ] . Neurosymbolic AI integrates symbol manipulation with DNNs to gain the benefits of explicit reasoning and constraint enforcement that symbolic AI excels at [ 22 , 50 ] . We introduce Deep Arguing , a neurosymbolic model that classifies data points using formal argumentative semantics as studied in computational argumentation, in the spirit of [ 6 , 44 ] . Computational argumentation is highly effective for modelling defeasibility in data, handling conflicting information, representing uncertainty, and explaination [ 12 ] , all properties leveraged by Deep Arguing. Like some existing computational argumentation approaches [ 44 ] , Deep Arguing relies upon specific argumentative structures whereby arguments are equipped with an intrinsic strength, interact by dialectical relationships of attack or support, and these relationships are weighted according to their magnitude. In the case of Deep Arguing these argumentative structures are learnt, wherein data points are individual arguments. DNNs parametrise the intrinsic strength of arguments and the magnitude of the attack and support interactions. While learnable parameters reside within the DNNs, as their outputs induce the strength of arguments and the weights of their relationships, varying these parameters gives rise to different argumentative structures. Using differentiable argumentation semantics and careful consideration of soft constraints, the DNNs can be trained end-to-end through the argumentative structure. As Deep Arguing does not directly modify the structure of the DNNs, one can select any architecture that best suits their use case, for example Multi-Layer Perceptrons (MLPs) for tabular data and convolutional neural networks (CNNs) [ 29 ] or ResNets [ 26 ] (as in Figure 1 ) for images. No matter which DNN architecture is used to underpin Deep Arguing, it results in an interpretable graph (see Figure 2 for an illustration) from which we can draw faithful case-based explanations that justify how the training data gives rise to a prediction. In summary, our contributions are as follows. (1) We introduce Deep Arguing as a novel neurosymbolic method for interpretable classification, integrating formal argumentative reasoning in conjunction with deep learning to enable structured and interpretable predictions. (2) We show that the framework is constrainable through fuzzy logic and optimisation objectives, enabling desirable properties (e.g. minimality, acyclicity, sparsity) that support both interpretability and scalable learning. (3) We conduct an empirical evaluation across tabular and imaging datasets, demonstrating that Deep Arguing achieves performance competitive with DNN baselines, while simultaneously providing interpretable argumentative reasoning. (4) We carry out a case study on the CIFAR-10 dataset [ 28 ] providing insight into Deep Arguing’s reasoning process, illustrating how argumentation supports class discrimination and justifies predictions between competing classes. Figure 1 : Left: Illustrated architecture of parametrised base score and edge weight functions using a shared ResNet [ 26 ] feature extractor for two example cases of CIFAR-10 [ 28 ] . Right: An example subset of a generated argumentation graph. Arguments are images from CIFAR-10, each coloured by its label, with the new case in grey. Arguments attack (or support) those with opposing (or equal) outcomes. For the example pair, we see the base scores (represented by border thickness) as well as the weight and direction of the attack relation as computed by the parametrised functions. 2 Related work Neurosymbolic AI Neurosymbolic AI [ 22 , 50 ] integrates deep learning with symbolic reasoning to achieve the flexibility and scalability of DNNs with interpretability. Often DNNs are used as perception modules (e.g. classifying MNIST digits) whilst the symbolic layer handles downstream reasoning (e.g. adding two digits) [ 35 ] . Many approaches encode reasoning using hand-crafted rules as part of the loss function [ 57 , 5 , 35 ] . In these lines of work, although the reasoning layer may be interpretable, the underlying neural predictions remain opaque and weak supervision can lead to reasoning shortcuts [ 36 ] , where incorrect class assignments still lead to correct downstream outputs. Deep Arguing is closer to methods that jointly learn perception and reasoning [ 14 , 11 ] , but these approaches may inherit the aforementioned issues. Instead Deep Arguing is fully supervised and addresses interpretable classification. Existing approaches often encode logic into model weights [ 52 , 51 , 41 ] , which can be difficult to scale to complex problems given the rigidity of logical rules, restrictions to monotonic logics and applications to only MLP layers and not other architectures like CNNs. In contrast, Deep Arguing uses DNN to learn the dialectical relationships between data points as arguments, creating a graphical structure that provides a flexible inductive bias that supports non-monotonicity and defeasible reasoning [ 12 , 16 ] . Neuro-Argumentative Learning Previous attempts to combine DNNs with argumentation [ 45 ] often operate in a pipeline fashion in which the DNN is first trained for feature extraction and then the argumentation layer is used for the final classification [ 9 , 10 , 21 , 15 ] . Multi-layer perceptrons (MLPs) can also be interpreted as argumentation frameworks [ 44 , 4 , 17 , 18 ] , and have been used for interpretable prototypical learning [ 3