Comparing Results from Two Uniform Phase Curve Surveys

Emeline Decocq, Mark Swain, Lisa Dang, David R. Ciardi, Geoffrey Bryden · 2026

Read Comparing Results from Two Uniform Phase Curve Surveys by Emeline Decocq, Mark Swain, Lisa Dang, David R. Ciardi, Geoffrey Bryden (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-10427.txt.

Introduction

Emeline Decocq and four colleagues compare the two most recent comprehensive Spitzer phase-curve studies of exoplanets. Both analyze Spitzer 4.5-micron phase curves with uniform methods, but they correct instrument systematics differently and select optimal system parameters differently. Their 2026 paper asks how consistent the two studies are, at the population level and planet by planet.

Comparing constraints on planet-to-star radius ratio, eclipse depth, phase-curve amplitude, and phase-curve offset, the authors find similar population-level results, though individual planets can vary, especially in offset values. They trace whether discrepancies stem from data-reduction methods or parameter choices, and check whether chosen parameters obey Kepler's third law. One case failed that check despite all values coming from one publication. Recalculating orbital periods and comparing with the NASA Exoplanet Archive, they conclude that testing reported parameters against Kepler's law is worthwhile.

Catalog record

CREATOREmeline Decocq, Mark Swain, Lisa Dang, David R. Ciardi, Geoffrey Bryden
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.10427

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comparing Results from Two Uniform Phase Curve Surveys Emeline Decocq, Mark Swain, Lisa Dang, David R. Ciardi, Geoffrey Bryden Abstract We present a comparison of the two most recent and comprehensive Spitzer phase curve studies – 6 and 26 – which report analyses of the Spitzer 4.5 μ ​ m \mu{m} phase curves. The studies employ different approaches for correcting instrument systematics and they also use different approaches for selecting the optimal exoplanet system parameters. To evaluate the level of consistency between the two studies, we compared the constraints on the ratio of planet-to-star radii ( R P R ⋆ \frac{R_{P}}{R_{\star}} ), eclipse depth ( F P F ⋆ \frac{F_{P}}{F_{\star}} ), phase curve amplitude (A), and phase curve offset ( ϕ \phi ). We find that the two studies produce similar results at the population level although results for individual planets can vary, especially for phase curve offset values. We examined the difference of planet system parameters to see if inconsistencies in individual planet results were due to data reduction methods or system parameter choices. We also examined whether the system parameters used by both studies were consistent with Kepler’s third law. During this comparison, we identified one case where stellar mass, planet semi-major axis, and orbital period did not follow Kepler’s law even though the values were all compiled from the same publication. To assess whether this kind of discrepancy was recurrent, we recalculated the orbital periods using Kepler’s third law and compared them with the values listed in the NASA Exoplanet Archive (NEA). Our detailed analysis of archival system parameters strongly suggests that testing reported/selected parameters for consistency with Kepler’s third law is worthwhile. I Introduction During the extended mission phase, the Spitzer Observatory ( 27 ) observed the thermal phase curves of more than 30 exoplanets with the IRAC instrument ( 8 ; 6 ) . These legacy Spitzer observations provide a unique resource for the statistical study of day-to-night heat transport in the atmospheres of gas giant planets undergoing powerful external radiation forcing. Recognizing the wealth of multi-dimensional insights embedded in thermal phase curve, a number of studies have searched for trends in thermal phase curves properties ( 22 ; 23 ; 28 ; 1 ; 14 ; 6 ; 26 ) with the most recent studies ( 1 ; 6 ; 26 ) implementing uniform analysis methods to facilitate comparative planetology studies. Spitzer IRAC observations are well known to suffer from substantial systematic errors, for which a number of methods correction methods have been developed (see discussion in 6 ). The question of how inferred science parameters for individual dataset are impacted by a choice of selection methods has been examined for individual sources, most notable WASP-43b ( 25 ; 17 ; 18 ; 15 ; 1 ; 19 ; 6 ; 26 ) . In this study, we undertake the first catalog level comparison of results from the two most comprehensive phase curve studies ( 6 ; 26 ) hereafter refereed to as D25 and S25. While both the D25 and S25 studies are similar in that they undertake a uniform analysis of a substantial number of 4.5 \mu m phase curves, the studies have three important differences. Firstly, D25 and S25 bring different interpretations to how the uniform analysis is defined. D25 uses a uniform criteria to select the optimal method for correcting instrument systematic (resulting in different targets in the sample being processed with different systematic correction methods) where as S25 uses single method for correcting instrument systematic that is applied uniformly to the sample. Secondly, D25 and S25 use a different approach for selecting the optimal exoplanet system parameters from among numerous measurements. In particular, they focus on constraining the phase curve, which requires a careful analysis of four key parameters; the planet-to-star radius ratio ( \frac{R_{P}}{R_{\star}} ), the secondary eclipse depth ( Depth_{eclipse} ), the phase curve amplitude (A), and the phase curve offset ( \phi ). Together, these parameters provide insights of the redistribution of heat across the planet’s atmosphere as well as the geometry of the system. The modeling of these parameters relies not only on the planetary radius but also on stellar properties. Since a single phase curve cannot constrain the stellar properties and orbital ephemerides; D25 imposes a gaussian prior on these parameters by using an algorithm that selects system parameters from the NASA exoplanet archives (NEA) ( 5 ) with the smallest uncertainty, regardless of whether the parameters are all from the same paper or from different papers which could result in mutually inconsistent system parameters. In contrast, S25 uses an algorithm which prioritizes identifying a set of self-consistent system parameters derived from a single paper. Thirdly, the D25 and S25 studies differ in scope. D25 is focused on trends for 4.5 \mu m phase curves where as S25 is focused on a smaller subset of planets that have both 3.6 \mu m and 4.5 \mu m phase curves. In what follows, we compare the D25 and S25 studies based on the mutual trends for the key astrophysical parameters reported by the studies. We also discern the possible origin for differences in results in the cases where the studies report findings that are in tension. And finally, we compare the orbital periods derived from our calculations with those reported in the Exoplanet Archive. II Method We compare the D25 and S25 results based on the estimates of four key physical exoplanet parameters; R_{p}/R_{\star} , where R_{p} is the planet radius (in R_{J} ) and R_{\star} is the stellar radius (in R_{\sun} ), the eclipse depth ( Depth_{eclipse} ) is the flux of the planet divided by the flux of the star (in ppm), A is the phase curve amplitude (in ppm), and \phi is the phase of the phase curve modulation relative to the midpoint of the exoplanet eclipse event (in degrees east of the substellar point). We will start by examining the radius and the eclipse depth. These two criteria are important to us because, Figure 3 in 26 , in the left-hand column and the third box up from the bottom, shows that the retrieval results are not correlated. Therefore, we can focus on these two parameters. For R_{p}/R_{\star} , the D25 and S25 results can be directly compared. For the eclipse depth ( Depth_{eclipse} ) we transform the S25 representation into the D25 representation, Depth_{eclipse}=\left(\frac{R_{p}}{R_{\star}}\right)^{2}\times\frac{F_{p}}{F_{\star}} (1) Similarly, the D25 phase curve amplitude, A , is calculated as half the distance between F_{max} (the highest point) and F_{min} (the lowest point). So we obtain the amplitude, using the following equation: A=\frac{F_{max}-F_{min}}{2} (2) with F_{\mathrm{max}} and F_{\mathrm{min}} in ppm. The phase curve phase, \phi , sign convention differed between D25 and S25; D25 define the phase curve offset as degrees east of the substellar point, whereas S25 defined it as the shift in orbital phase of the peak flux. We multiply the S25 values by -1 so that the values can be directly compared as degrees east. We also check the system parameter values used in D25 and S25 for self consistency by comparing the measured period P , to the derived period based upon Kepler’s Law and the system parameters from the NEA,

Read the complete text