Travelling waves of invasion in microbial communities with phenotypic switching

Diego Manso Anda, Pierre A. Haas · 2026

Read Travelling waves of invasion in microbial communities with phenotypic switching by Diego Manso Anda, Pierre A. Haas (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-10420.txt.

Introduction

Diego Manso Anda and Pierre A. Haas study invasion waves in microbial communities where bacteria switch phenotypes. Clonal bacterial groups split into types, including a persister type resilient to rivalry. Their 2026 paper models two competing species in space. One switches, both by chance and in response to its rival, to that dormant state. The authors ask how that switching shapes travelling waves of invasion.

Combining analytic and numeric results, the authors find a surprising asymmetry. That switching does not change the speed of the rivals' wave into the switching group. Conversely, switching can quicken the wave by which that group invades its rivals. Bacterial persistence, the results suggest, can be an offensive rather than defensive survival strategy, surprising given persisters' usual reputation as a defensive refuge.

Catalog record

CREATORDiego Manso Anda, Pierre A. Haas
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.10420

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Travelling waves of invasion in microbial communities with phenotypic switching Diego Manso Anda, Pierre A. Haas Abstract Complex microbial habitats see the spatial competition of different clonal bacterial populations that switch between different phenotypes. Here, we determine the effect of this subpopulation structure on the invasion of one species by another in a minimal model of two competing species: one species switches, both stochastically and in response to its competitor, to a persister phenotype resilient to competition. Surprisingly, our combined analytical and numerical results show that this phenotypic switching has no effect on the speed of the travelling wave by which the competitors invade the first population. Conversely, we discover that phenotypic switching can speed up the wave by which this population invades their competitors. Our results thus suggest, counterintuitively, that bacterial persistence can be an offensive, rather than defensive ecological strategy. I INTRODUCTION In microbial communities, clonal bacterial populations divide into different phenotypes [ 29 , 3 , 8 ] . Despite the known ecological importance of this subpopulation structure [ 5 , 12 , 31 ] , physical models of its effect on species coexistence in well-mixed populations have only emerged more recently [ 19 , 24 , 15 , 14 , 18 ] . Abundant phenotypic variation is expected to be destabilising in general [ 15 ] from May’s stability paradigm [ 23 , 2 ] , since it increases the effective number of species in the community. Still, different mechanisms by which phenotypic variation can increase diversity and stability have been identified [ 24 , 15 , 18 ] . For example, phenotypic switching to a rare phenotype, such as the bacterial persister phenotype [ 4 , 22 , 16 , 27 ] , can stabilise coexistence [ 15 , 14 ] . Complex microbial habitats are not however well-mixed. Rather, one expects spatial competition dynamics, with some bacterial species invading other species. In the simplest, one-dimensional case, with bacterial motion represented as diffusion, these dynamics can take the form of travelling waves: indeed, the Lotka–Volterra equations of population dynamics [ *[][ , Chap.~3 , pp.~79--118andChap.~13 , pp.~437--483.]murray , 17 ] with diffusion admit travelling-wave solutions [ 9 , 20 , 11 , 10 , 33 ] that are higher-dimensional analogues of the travelling waves of the Fisher equation [ 25 , 32 ] . These travelling waves in the Lotka–Volterra system remain a very active area of research in applied mathematics [ 1 , 30 , 34 , 21 , 6 , 7 ] . Figure 1: Minimal model of the spatial competition of two species with phenotypic variation. (a) A bacterial species has two phenotypes, a growing phenotype B and a persister phenotype P, between which it switches stochastically (dashed arrows). Additionally, the competitor species A induces responsive switching (solid arrow) from B to P. (b) Setup of the one-dimensional competition between these two species: at time t=0 , the first species, in an equilibrium \mathcal{B} of B and P, is in x>0 , while the competitors, in an equilibrium \mathcal{A} of A only, are in x<0 . (c) Dynamics of the spatial competition: after a transient, one equilibrium invades the other with a travelling wave of velocity c . The abundances B(z),P(z),A(z) of B, P, A are fixed in the travelling-wave coordinate z=x-ct . Here, we ask: how do phenotypic variation and switching affect these travelling waves of invasion? To answer this question, we develop a minimal model of the spatial competition of two species (Fig. 1 ): One species has two phenotypes, B and P, between which it switches stochastically [Fig. 1 (a) ]. Moreover, the competitor species A causes responsive phenotypic switching from B to P. These dynamics allow two particular types of homogeneous equilibria: equilibria \mathcal{B} without competitors and equilibria \mathcal{A} of competitors only. (We will not be interested in coexistence equilibria of both species.) We analyse the spatial dynamics resulting from these homogeneous equilibria meeting at x=0 [Fig. 1 (b) ]. After a transient, a travelling wave forms [Fig. 1 (c) ], with one of \mathcal{A},\mathcal{B} invading the other at velocity c . (Again, we will not be interested in the possibility of a coexistence state invading both \mathcal{A},\mathcal{B} .) Combining analytical and numerical calculations, we determine how phenotypic switching affects the wave velocity c . Contrary to the expectation that a hump of a phenotype resilient to the competitors should slow down the wave by which \mathcal{A} invades \mathcal{B} [ c>0 , Fig. 1 (c) ], we reveal that phenotypic switching does not affect c>0 . Conversely, we find that phenotypic switching can speed up invasion of \mathcal{A} by \mathcal{B} [ c<0 , Fig. 1 (c) ]. In this way, our work suggests that phenotypic switching to a phenotype resilient to competition is, surprisingly, not a defensive, but rather an offensive ecological strategy. II RESULTS Let B(x,t),P(x,t),A(x,t) denote the abundances of populations B, P, A, where t is time and x is the (single) spatial coordinate. We model the dynamics of these abundances by the reaction-diffusion system \displaystyle\dfrac{\partial B}{\partial t} \displaystyle=B(1-\alpha A-B-\kappa P)-\beta AB-\gamma B+\delta P+\frac{\partial^{2}B}{\partial x^{2}}, (1a) \displaystyle\dfrac{\partial P}{\partial t} \displaystyle=P(\mu-\xi A-\varpi B-\varsigma P)+\beta AB+\gamma B-\delta P+d\frac{\partial^{2}P}{\partial x^{2}}, (1b) \displaystyle\dfrac{\partial A}{\partial t} \displaystyle=A(\zeta-\eta A-\vartheta B-\iota P)+D\frac{\partial^{2}A}{\partial x^{2}}, (1c) in which \alpha,\beta,\gamma,\delta,\zeta,\eta,\vartheta,\iota,\kappa,\mu,\xi,\varpi,\varsigma and d,D are non-negative parameters. The non-spatial part of this model is the minimal model of phenotypic switching of two species introduced in Eqs. (4) of Ref. [ 14 ] . Thus \alpha,\zeta,\eta,\vartheta,\iota,\kappa,\mu,\xi,\varpi,\varsigma are Lotka–Volterra parameters representing the growth rates of and competition between the different populations, \beta is the rate of responsive switching from B to P, and \gamma,\delta are the deterministic rates of stochastic switching between B and P. The diffusive spatial terms add bacterial motility to this model, with diffusivities d,D . Equations ( 1 ) represent non-dimensional dynamics in which population abundances, time, and space have been rescaled so that B has unit growth rate, carrying capacity, and diffusivity. As noted in Ref. [ 14 ] , too, the same dimensional rescalings must be chosen for B and P lest the switching terms in Eqs. ( 1a ) and ( 1b ) become unbalanced; choosing a different rescaling for A would allow setting, e.g., \eta=1 , but would make comparing competition strengths more difficult. While Eqs. ( 1 ) provide a general model of phenotypic variation, it will turn out to be useful to focus at times on a particular biological realisation of the model, viz., bacterial persistence [ 4 , 22 , 16 , 27 ] . Thus B will represent the “normal” growing phenotype, while P will present the rare, slowly growing, and slowly moving persister phenotype resilient to the competitor A. This corresponds to the scalings [ 14 ] \displaystyle\alpha,\delta,\zeta,\eta,\vartheta,D=O(1), \displaystyle\beta,\gamma,\iota,\kappa,\mu,\xi,\varpi,\varsigma,d=O(\varepsilon), (2) in which \varepsilon is a small parameter representing the relative rareness of persisters. We conclude the setup of the model by analysing its homogeneous steady states. In particular, Eqs. ( 1 ) have steady states \displaystyle\mathcal{A}=(0,0,A_{\ast}), \displaystyle\mathcal{B}=(B_{\ast},P_{\ast},0), (3) of A only and B, P only, respectively, where A_{\ast}=\zeta/\eta and B_{\ast},P_{\ast} are determined by \displaystyle B_{\ast}(1-B_{\ast}-\kappa P_{\ast})-\gamma B_{\ast}+\delta P_{\ast} \displaystyle=0, (4a) \displaystyle P_{\ast}(\mu-\varpi B_{\ast}-\varsigma P_{\ast})+\gamma B_{\ast}-\delta P_{\ast} \displaystyle=0. (4b) Equations ( 4 ) cannot be solved usefully in

Read the complete text