Weibel-mediated filamentary structures observed in the ICF context

C. Ruyer 1,2, S. Bolaños 3, P. E. Masson Laborde 1,2, L. Gremillet 1,2, N. Blanchot 1, G. Boutoux 1,2, W. Cayzac 1, C. Courtois 1, S. G. Dannhoff 4, V. Denis 1, L. Le Deroff 1, C. K. Li 4, J. Fuchs 5, A. Grisollet 1, I. Lantuéjoul 1, R. Riquier 1, R. Smets 6, G. D. Sutcliffe 7, B. Vauzour 1 · 2026

Read Weibel-mediated filamentary structures observed in the ICF context by C. Ruyer 1,2, S. Bolaños 3, P. E. Masson Laborde 1,2, L. Gremillet 1,2, N. Blanchot 1, G. Boutoux 1,2, W. Cayzac 1, C. Courtois 1, S. G. Dannhoff 4, V. Denis 1, L. Le Deroff 1, C. K. Li 4, J. Fuchs 5, A. Grisollet 1, I. Lantuéjoul 1, R. Riquier 1, R. Smets 6, G. D. Sutcliffe 7, B. Vauzour 1 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-10412.txt.

Introduction

C. Ruyer and eighteen colleagues show how thread-like structures form in the expanding plasma plume of a laser-irradiated foil. The Weibel instability, a kinetic effect in mostly thin plasmas, amplifies seed fields when pressure is uneven, sorting particles by current direction into threads wrapped in field loops. Their 2026 paper studies that process in the inertial confinement fusion context.

Sideways cooling during near-spherical plasma expansion naturally drives uneven electron pressure, growing current threads. That growth competes with electron-ion collisions, which tend to even out the electron spread. From theory and computer modeling, the authors estimate the dominant wavelength and amplitude of self-made field ripples. Those estimates explain test data from the OMEGA and Laser Megajoule sites, tying thread formation to conditions in expanding fusion plasmas. In short, tiny plasma physics shapes what large fusion laser shots record.

Catalog record

CREATORC. Ruyer 1,2, S. Bolaños 3, P. E. Masson Laborde 1,2, L. Gremillet 1,2, N. Blanchot 1, G. Boutoux 1,2, W. Cayzac 1, C. Courtois 1, S. G. Dannhoff 4, V. Denis 1, L. Le Deroff 1, C. K. Li 4, J. Fuchs 5, A. Grisollet 1, I. Lantuéjoul 1, R. Riquier 1, R. Smets 6, G. D. Sutcliffe 7, B. Vauzour 1
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.10412

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Weibel-mediated filamentary structures observed in the ICF context C. Ruyer 1,2, S. Bolaños 3, P. E. Masson Laborde 1,2, L. Gremillet 1,2, N. Blanchot 1, G. Boutoux 1,2, W. Cayzac 1, C. Courtois 1, S. G. Dannhoff 4, V. Denis 1, L. Le Deroff 1, C. K. Li 4, J. Fuchs 5, A. Grisollet 1, I. Lantuéjoul 1, R. Riquier 1, R. Smets 6, G. D. Sutcliffe 7, B. Vauzour 1 Abstract In light of novel and past experimental results, we demonstrate how Weibel-mediated filamentary structures can develop in the expanding plasma plume of a laser-irradiated foil. The transverse ballistic cooling that occurs during the quasi-spherical plasma expansion naturally drives an electron pressure anisotropy, resulting in the growth of electron current filaments. This effect competes with electron-ion Coulomb collisions which tend to isotropize the electron distribution function. Based on theoretical and particle-in-cell modeling, we provide estimates of the dominant wavelength and amplitude of the self-generated magnetic fluctuations, which are found to explain experimental data obtained at the OMEGA and Laser Megajoule facilities. I Introduction The Weibel instability Weibel 1959 ; Fried 1959 is a kinetic phenomenon that arises in mostly collisionless plasmas when a pressure anisotropy is present. By amplifying seed magnetic fields and/or current fluctuations, it leads to the segregation of particles according to their current polarity and the formation of current filaments surrounded by magnetic field loops. Understanding the linear and nonlinear properties of the Weibel instability has been the focus of extensive theoretical and numerical work over the past decades Moiseev and Sagdeev 1963 ; Davidson et al. 1972 ; Lee and Lampe 1973 ; Califano et al. 1998 ; Kato 2005 ; Achterberg et al. 2007a ; *Achterbeg_2007b ; Kaang et al. 2009 ; Bret et al. 2010 ; Istomin 2011 ; Pokhotelov and Amariutei 2011 ; Grassi et al. 2017 . This instability has been widely studied in the context of astrophysical plasmas, where the source of anisotropy is typically provided by counter-propagating plasma flows Fried 1959 ; Moiseev and Sagdeev 1963 ; Medvedev and Loeb 1999 ; Drake and Gregori 2012 ; Fiuza et al. 2020 ; Grassi and Fiuza 2021 ; Bresci et al. 2022 . In addition, it has attracted significant attention in relativistic laser-plasma interactions, particularly with regard to ion acceleration applications Fuchs et al. 2003 ; Chen et al. 2009 ; Roth et al. 2013 ; Scott et al. 2017 . It is then triggered by the laser-accelerated electrons, either within the laser irradiation region Sentoku et al. 2003 , in the collisional target bulk Gremillet et al. 2002 or over longer spatiotemporal scales far from the laser impact Quinn et al. 2012 ; Ruyer et al. 2020 ; Zhao et al. 2024 . Its potential development has also been identified in expanding plasmas Thaury et al. 2010 ; Quinn et al. 2012 , though the precise conditions and mechanisms governing its occurrence remain unclear. In this study, we analyze three experiments performed at large-scale laser facilities that reveal Weibel-type filamentary structures in expanding plasma plumes relevant to inertial confinement fusion (ICF). The nanosecond and millimeter scales of these experiments pose significant challenges for kinetic instability analysis, and self-consistent numerical simulations remain computationally infeasible with current or near-future supercomputers. To overcome these difficulties, we employ a semi-analytical model, developed in Ref. True 1985 , which explains how weak electron pressure anisotropy is spontaneously driven during spherical plasma expansion and makes way for the growth of the Weibel instability. Our paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II , we review the basic ingredients of the model, and explain how it can be applied to predict the development of electron anisotropy in plasma plumes and the properties of the resulting Weibel magnetic filaments. We then perform particle-in-cell (PIC) kinetic simulations Lefebvre et al. 2003 to validate our analytical estimates. In Sec. III , we compare our findings with three independent experimental measurements, confirming our understanding of the underlying physics and the ability of our model to predict, at least qualitatively, the onset conditions for the Weibel instability in expanding laser plasmas. Finally, in Sec. IV , we discuss the implications of our results to ICF experiments. II The Weibel instability in an expanding plasma II.1 Spherical plasma expansion as a source of electron thermal anisotropy We start by describing the physical mechanisms underlying the development of electron thermal anisotropy during the expansion of a plasma sphere. We explain how the conservation of electron angular momentum leads to a decrease in transverse electron pressure, which in turn drives the Weibel instability. During the expansion of a hot (quasi-) spherical plasma, the fast and light electrons drag the heavier ions via space-charge fields. In a collisionless medium, the assumption of a central force field constrains the radial evolution of the electron distribution. Specifically, conservation of the electron angular momentum l\equiv m_{e}v_{\perp}r ( m_{e} is the electron mass and v_{\perp} its transverse velocity) causes the transverse electron temperature (or mean transverse kinetic energy) to decrease as T_{\perp}\propto r^{-2} . If the radial temperature drops slower than r^{-2} , a momentum anisotropy naturally arises, with the hotter direction aligned along the radial axis. This mechanism, illustrated in Fig. 1 , is counteracted by electron-ion Coulomb collisions, which tend to isotropize the electron distribution. Therefore, the development of the Weibel instability, which feeds on the electron momentum anisotropy, hinges on the competition between the anisotropy growth resulting from the expansion and its mitigation due to collisions. Figure 1: Sketch of a spherical expansion. Because of ballistic effects, particles that reach position r_{1} have more transverse thermal velocity spread than the particles that reach position r_{2}>r_{1} , thus driving a pressure anisotropy. Electron-ion Coulomb collisions balance this mechanism. The kinetic model we adopt, originally proposed by True True 1985 , is based on the following key assumptions regarding a spherically expanding plasma. First, in the central and dense part of the plasma, the Coulomb collisions are assumed to dominate, enforcing an isotropic Maxwellian electron distribution. Beyond a critical radius r_{\star} , where the electron density is n_{e}(r=r_{\star})=n_{e}^{\star} , the plasma is considered sufficiently collisionless to allow a slight electron pressure anisotropy to arise. The value of n_{e}^{\star} is related to the electron mean free path, \lambda_{\mathrm{mfp}} , through \int_{r_{\star}}^{\infty}dx/\lambda_{\mathrm{mfp}}(x)=1 , yielding n_{e}^{\star}\simeq\frac{3\times 10^{23}\,[{\rm cm^{-3}}]}{Z\ln\Lambda}\,\frac{(3T_{e}[{\rm keV}]/2)^{2}}{L[{\rm\mu m}]}\,, (1) where Z is the ion charge, \ln\Lambda is the Coulomb logarithm, and L is the plasma density scale length. We have neglected electron-electron Coulomb collisions, an approximation valid for Z\gg 1 . For a collisionless, initially Maxwellian plasma, the conservation of total electron energy, E=\frac{1}{2}m_{e}v^{2}-e\phi(r) ( e is the elementary charge) and electron angular momentum, l=m_{e}v_{\perp}r , is employed to parameterize the electron distribution function in the form True 1985 : \displaystyle f_{e} \displaystyle=F_{0}n_{e}^{\star}\exp\left(-\frac{m_{e}v_{r}^{2}-2e\phi}{2T_{e}}-\frac{m_{e}v_{\perp}r-l_{\star}}{l_{0}}\right) \displaystyle\quad{\rm if}\quad m_{e}v_{\perp}r>l_{\star}\,, \displaystyle f_{e} \displaystyle=F_{0}n_{e}^{\star}\exp\left(-\frac{m_{e}v_{r}^{2}-2e\phi}{2T_{e}}\right) \displaystyle\quad{\rm elsewhere.} (2) The normalization factor is F_{0}=(m_{e}T_{e})^{-3/2}(2\pi)^{-1/2} . This model distribution captures two key regimes: for r<r_{\star} , the plasma retains its Maxwellian character, while for r>r_{\star} , particles with large transverse momenta m_{e}v_{\perp}r are increasingly restricted from accessing larger radii, as illustrated in Fig. 1 . Figure 2: Model results for the expansion of a carbon plasma ( Z=6 , A=12 ) with density profile n_{e}=n_{e}^{\star}\exp[-(r-r_{\star})/L] . The

Read the complete text