Every Finite Group Admits a Just Finite Presentation

Marc Lackenby · 2026

Read Every Finite Group Admits a Just Finite Presentation by Marc Lackenby (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2605-10402.txt.

Introduction

Marc Lackenby settles a question from the Kourovka Notebook, a famous list of open problems in group theory. A finite presentation of a finite group is called just finite if removing any single relation leaves a presentation for an infinite group. Barnea asked, as Problem 21.10, whether every finite group admits such a presentation. His 2026 note answers yes.

Lackenby proves the stronger claim that every finite group admits a finite, just finite presentation, via results about groups with Property FA, Serre's fixed-point property for actions on trees. The note also treats just-(FA) presentations, where dropping any relation destroys that property. Significant assistance came from the Google DeepMind AI co-mathematician tool, as the methodology section details. Readers get a short, sharp resolution of a long-standing question, with a stronger theorem behind it.

Catalog record

CREATORMarc Lackenby
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE11 KB
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.10402

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Every Finite Group Admits a Just Finite Presentation Thanks: The author was partially supported by EPSRC grant EP/Y004256/1. For the purpose of open access, the author has applied a CC BY public copyright licence to any author accepted manuscript arising from this submission. Significant assistance was provided by the Google DeepMind AI co-mathematician tool. See the Methodology section for more details. Marc Lackenby Abstract . A finite presentation ⟨ X | R ⟩ \langle X\,|\,R\rangle of a finite group G G is called “just finite” if removing any relation from R R results in a presentation for an infinite group. It has been an open question (Kourovka Notebook, Problem 21.10) whether every finite group admits such a presentation. We resolve this conjecture in the affirmative. 1. Introduction Inspired by the extensive theory of just infinite groups [ 5 , 6 , 12 , 13 , 2 , 8 , 9 ] , Barnea introduced a notion that is, in some sense, dual [ 1 ] . He defined a just finite presentation of a finite group G , which is a presentation \langle X\,|\,R\rangle for the group with the property that, for every r\in R , the group \langle X\,|\,R\setminus\{r\}\rangle is infinite. In Problem 21.10 of the Kourovka Notebook [ 4 ] , Barnea asked whether every finite group admits a just finite presentation. The goal of this note to prove that this is indeed the case. Theorem 1 . Every finite group admits a finite, just finite presentation. This is actually a consequence of a stronger result. Recall that a group G has Property (FA) if any action of G on a tree has a fixed point. It is a fundamental theorem of Serre [ 10 ] that a finitely generated group has Property (FA) if and only if it is neither a non-trivial amalgamated free product nor an HNN extension. We say that a presentation \langle X\,|\,R\rangle for a group with Property (FA) is just-(FA) if, for every r\in R , the group \langle X\,|\,R\setminus\{r\}\rangle does not have Property (FA). Theorem 2 . Every finitely presented group with Property (FA) admits a finite just-(FA) presentation. This implies Theorem 1 , since a finite group G clearly has Property (FA). Hence, it admits a finite just-(FA) presentation, which is therefore just-finite. We also note the following consequence, concerning groups G with Kazhdan’s Property (T) [ 3 ] . We say that a presentation \langle X\,|\,R\rangle for such a group is just-(T) if, for every r\in R , the group \langle X\,|\,R\setminus\{r\}\rangle does not have Property (T). Since Property (T) implies Property (FA) for countable discrete groups [ 11 ] , Theorem 2 gives the following result. Theorem 3 . Every finitely presented group with Property (T) admits a finite just-(T) presentation. 2. The Construction The aim is to start with a finite presentation \langle X\,|\,R\rangle of the given group G with Property (FA) and modify it to a just-(FA) presentation. Each relation will be substituted for two new relations that have a form based on the following lemma. Lemma 4 (B.H. Neumann [ 7 ] ) . Let H be a group with elements u,v\in H satisfying u^{-1}vu=v^{2} and v^{-1}uv=u^{2} . Then u=1 and v=1 . Proof. From the second relation, v^{-1}uv=u^{2} , we can write the commutator [u,v]=u^{-1}(v^{-1}uv)=u^{-1}u^{2}=u . From the first relation, u^{-1}vu=v^{2} , we can invert it to get u^{-1}v^{-1}u=v^{-2} . We can then write the commutator as [u,v]=(u^{-1}v^{-1}u)v=v^{-2}v=v^{-1} . Equating the two expressions for the commutator, we have u=v^{-1} . Substituting this into the first relation u^{-1}vu=v^{2} yields (v^{-1})^{-1}v(v^{-1})=v^{2} , which simplifies to v=v^{2} . This implies v=1 , and therefore u=1 . ∎ The following type of semi-direct product of cyclic groups plays a technical role in our proof. Lemma 5 . For k>1 , the presentation \langle x,y\,|\,x^{-1}yx=y^{2},x^{k}=1\rangle specifies the group \mathbb{Z}_{2^{k}-1}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{k} , where \langle x\rangle=\mathbb{Z}_{k} and \langle y\rangle=\mathbb{Z}_{2^{k}-1} and the conjugation action of x on \langle y\rangle is y\mapsto y^{2} . Proof. There is a homomorphism \langle x,y\,|\,x^{-1}yx=y^{2},x^{k}=1\rangle\rightarrow\mathbb{Z}_{2^{k}-1}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{k} , since the two relations are satisfied in the image group. It is surjective because the images of x and y generate \mathbb{Z}_{2^{k}-1}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{k} . Any element in \langle x,y\,|\,x^{-1}yx=y^{2},x^{k}=1\rangle can be written as x^{m}y^{n} for some integers m and n . Using x^{k}=1 , we may assume 0\leq m<k . Conjugating y by x a total of k times gives y^{2^{k}} . Since x^{k}=1 , we deduce that y^{2^{k}}=y . So, we may also assume 0\leq n<2^{k}-1 . So \langle x,y\,|\,x^{-1}yx=y^{2},x^{k}=1\rangle has at most k(2^{k}-1) elements. However, \mathbb{Z}_{2^{k}-1}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{k} has exactly this many elements, and therefore the above surjective homomorphism is an isomorphism. ∎ We are now in a position to prove our main theorem. Proof of Theorem 2 . Let G be a finitely presented group with Property (FA). If G is cyclic, G must be a finite cyclic group \mathbb{Z}_{n} and so admits the balanced, just-(FA) presentation \langle x\,|\,x^{n}=1\rangle . Assume G is non-cyclic. Let \langle X\,|\,R\rangle be an irredundant finite presentation for G (that is, for any r\in R , the group H_{r}=\langle X\,|\,R\setminus\{r\}\rangle is not isomorphic to G , implying r\neq 1 in H_{r} ). We define a new presentation P^{\prime}=\langle X^{\prime}\,|\,R^{\prime}\rangle as follows: • X^{\prime}=X\cup\{b_{r}\,|\,r\in R\} • R^{\prime}=\{r^{-1}b_{r}r=b_{r}^{2}\,|\,r\in R\}\cup\{b_{r}^{-1}rb_{r}=r^{2}\,|\,r\in R\} By Lemma 4 , these relations force b_{r}=1 and r=1 for all r\in R . (See Section 3 for a specific example of such a presentation P^{\prime} .) We claim that P^{\prime} presents G . Consider what happens to the group G=\langle X\,|\,R\rangle when a new generator b_{r} is added, the relation r is removed and then replaced by the two new relations r^{-1}b_{r}r=b_{r}^{2} and b_{r}^{-1}rb_{r}=r^{2} . These force b_{r}=1 and r=1 . Conversely b_{r}=1 and r=1 imply the two new relations r^{-1}b_{r}r=b_{r}^{2} and b_{r}^{-1}rb_{r}=r^{2} . Thus, instead of adding these two new relations, we could have simply set b_{r}=1 and r=1 . In other words, the new group is obtained from G=\langle X\,|\,R\rangle by adding the new generator b_{r} and a new relation b_{r}=1 . Hence, this does not change the group. Repeating this for each relation in R , we deduce that P^{\prime} does present G . We must show P^{\prime} is just-(FA). Let r\in R . We show that removing either of the corresponding relations yields a group without Property (FA). Case 1: Remove b_{r}^{-1}rb_{r}=r^{2} . Let K_{1} be the resulting group. As above, let H_{r} be the group \langle X\,|\,R\setminus\{r\}\rangle . This also has a presentation obtained from P^{\prime} by removing the generator b_{r} and the relations r^{-1}b_{r}r=b_{r}^{2} and b_{r}^{-1}rb_{r}=r^{2} . Let k\in\mathbb{N}\cup\{\infty\} be the order of r in H_{r} . Since R is irredundant, k>1 . Thus K_{1} can be decomposed as an amalgamated free product: K_{1}\cong H_{r}*_{\langle r\rangle=\langle x\rangle}B^{\prime} where B^{\prime}=\langle x,b_{r}\,|\,x^{-1}b_{r}x=b_{r}^{2},x^{k}=1\rangle . When k=\infty , we do not include the relation x^{k}=1 . Thus, when k=\infty , B^{\prime} is the Baumslag-Solitar group B(1,2) . When k is finite, Lemma 5 gives that the group B^{\prime} is the semi-direct product \mathbb{Z}_{2^{k}-1}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{k} , and the index of the amalgamating subgroup \langle x\rangle in B^{\prime} is 2^{k}-1 . Thus, when k=\infty or k\geq 2 , this index is at least 3 . An amalgamated free product A*_{C}B is non-trivial when C\not=A and C\not=B . Since [B^{\prime}:\langle

Read the complete text